CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Mid Devon District Council
Scrutiny Committee, Monday 15 January 2024 at 5.30pm

Minutes of the Previous Meeting (0:38:54)

Agreed Scrutiny 2 papers

Scrutiny Committee agreed this item on Monday 15 January 2024. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item61

Resolved

It was AGREED that the minutes of meeting held on 18 th December 2024 would be approved at the next meeting of the Scrutiny Committee on 19 February 2024.
Word for word from the decision Mid Devon published for this meeting. Source: democracy.middevon.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Mid Devon's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Scrutiny Committee

Scrutiny Committee Meeting – Monday 18 December 2023 Responses to Public Questions not submitted in advance of the meeting.

QUESTIONS: Paul Elstone - A Local Resident and Council Taxpayer . My Questions relate to Agenda Item 11 The 3 Rivers Lessons Learned Report. Question 1 - Section 1 Summary and Recommendations states Quote “All relevant material was made available”. How can this be stated and when the Working Group had been told that Council Officers were threatening Members of the General Public with criminal action, if they provided certain documents ? It seems that former Council Leaders also received veiled threats if they made documents they may have held available. That despite being fully aware, the currentCouncil Leader failed to intervene to ensure key documents were released.

Response: As far as the Working Group were concerned they were content with all the information that was made available to them from both officers and members of the public (who supplied some of this information directly to members of this group and the Chair of the Committee). The Council would like to make it explicitly clear that there have been no officer threats. The Council have simply written to 3 members of the public with regard to data protection breaches as advised by the Data Protection Officer and the Information Commissioner Officer

Question 2 Why were the former Council Leaders not interviewed in person, especially when the Working Group were made fully aware of the threats against them ?

Response: It was the Working Group’s prerogative to carry out their investigation however they deemed appropriate. There were no threats contained within the request, it simply stated that any information supplied would be verified by the Council’s District Solicitor.

35 Question 3 Evidence is available which conflicts with several statements in the report. Did the Working Group have time to fully fact check the information they were provided with?

Response: The Working Group were content with all of their investigations carried out.

Question 4 The Working Group Report identified many and serious governance failings. What the Working Group have failed to do, is to reference who should have prevented these serious failings and how. It should be clear to any anyone with an understanding of the responsibilities of Local Government Statutory Officers, what the full root cause is. It has nothing to do with the various excuses the Public have previously been given including Government policy. Why was the root cause not directly addressed in the report and something that is a serious omission ?

Response: The working group didn’t highlight one specific root cause within their report and made the recommendations they felt were appropriate.

36 Question 5 There is one email that fully identifies the root cause. An email written to an MDDC Senior Officer in February 2020 and signed by ALL the Cabinet Members then, including the current Council Leader and a Deputy Leader. Yet in the report there is no reference to some very serious concerns even allegations including concerns that there could be a prima facia case to involve the police. An email that can only be described as explosive. Was this relevant material given to the Working Group ? If so, and given its importance, how many of the signatories were interviewed and who? It is an email given the full content that warrants being in the public domain.

Response: Council officers are not aware of the email being referred to, but would be happy for you to forward it on to them so we can verify your allegations. We would also be interested to know how you have obtained an internal officer/member email.

Responses from Deputy Chief Executive (S151) Officer

37 QUESTIONS: Goff Welchman - A Local Resident and Council Taxpayer . My Questions relate to Agenda Item 11 The 3 Rivers Lessons Learned Report.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Answers to Public Questions not submitted in advance of the meetingReport 457 KB DownloadRead as text
PDF
Minutes of the Previous Meeting (0:38:54)Minutes 210 KB Download

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

19 of 26 attended
RG
Councillor Rachel GilmourChairman, present
GW
Councillor Gill WestcottVice-Chair, present
DB
Councillor David BroomCommittee Member, present
EB
Councillor Emma BuczkowskiCommittee Member, present
AC
Councillor Andy CuddyCommittee Member, present
GC
Councillor Gordon CzapiewskiCommittee Member, present
GD
Councillor Gwen Duchesne MBECommittee Member, present
MF
Councillor Matt FarrellCommittee Member, present
BH
Councillor Ben HoldmanCommittee Member, present
LK
Councillor Lloyd KnightCommittee Member, present
RR
Councillor Rhys RobertsCommittee Member, present
SR
Councillor Sue RobinsonCommittee Member, present

All 26 on the meeting page

On this subject at Mid Devon

Search all
  1. Minutes of the Previous Meeting (0:38:54)This decision
  2. Minutes of the Previous MeetingApproved
  3. Minutes of the Previous MeetingApproved
  4. Minutes of the Previous MeetingApproved
  5. Minutes of the Previous MeetingApproved
  6. Minutes of the Previous MeetingApproved

More from Mid Devon Scrutiny Committee

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
7 Sep 2026 The Local Government Reorganisation Working Group - Verbal Update (00:43:58)RESOLVED that: The meeting taking place on the 22 September 2026 of the LGR Working Group be postponed. The LGR Worki... Decided Open
17 Aug 2026 Access to Information - Exclusion of Press & PublicRESOLVED : That under S100A(4) of the Local Government Act 1972, in accordance with Part I of Schedule 12A, the press... Decided Open
13 Jul 2026 Review of Let's Talk Mid Devon - Improvement PlanRESOLVED that the Let’s Talk Mid Devon District Council – Improvement Plan update be presented at the Scrutiny Commit... Decided Open
8 Jun 2026 Election of Vice-Chair of the Scrutiny CommitteeRESOLVED that Cllr S Robinson be elected Vice-Chair of the Scrutiny Committee for the municipal year 2026/2027. Decided Open
20 Oct 2025 Election of ChairRESOLVED that Cllr G Czapiewski be elected Chair for the purposes of this meeting only. (Proposed by Cllr C Adcock an... Decided Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies