It was agreed that this matter would be deferred to the next scheduled meeting, 17 April 2025, for final consideration and approval. The Chair thanked the Internal Auditor and the officers for the information provided. AGREED as follows: 1. That the Head of Corporate Finance would circulate the CIPFA guidance document(s) to the Committee Members. 2. That the principles of conducting a self-assessment were approved. 3. That this matter be deferred to the 17 April 2025 meeting for final consideration and approval. In the interim, officers would undertake a further options appraisal as to how the review could be conducted, for consideration at that meeting. 4. That the information, as presented, was noted.
Word for word from the decision Middlesbrough published for this meeting.Source: moderngov.middlesbrough.gov.uk
Approves a review of its own effectiveness and, provides direction on the proposed method and timing of the review.
3. Background and relevant information
3.1The latest guidance on audit committees in local government, published by the Chartered Institute of Public Finance and Accountancy (CIPFA) in October 2022, recommends that committees should complete a periodic self-assessment of their effectiveness. Alternatively, an independent review can be undertaken. The guidance includes a checklist to support the self-assessment, enabling the Committee to highlight the areas where it has made an impact on the Council’s governance, risk management, control and audit arrangements. This Committee has not undertaken any assessment against this guidance.
3.2It is recommended that the Committee completes an assessment against the guidance, either through a facilitated self-assessment that would be led by Veritau, or this an independent commissioned review.
3.3The outcomes of this exercise will help to support the preparation of the Audit Committee’s future work programme, training plans and the annual report. The exercise may also identify areas requiring changes or improvements in the Committee’s method of working or in how it communicates its activities to the Council’s leadership and wider public.
3.4Members’ support is sought for completion of a review of the Committee’s effectiveness, and direction on the form and timing of the review. Options for the method for undertaking the review are summarised as follows:
Self-Assessment (whole committee)
Benefits Disadvantages
All Members will have the May lack external perspective / opportunity to contribute to the relevant knowledge of audit review committee best practice in local government Members have a good understanding of the Council, its
2 This document was classified as: OFFICIAL
priorities and existing governance arrangements
Self-assessment (Member working group)
Benefits Disadvantages
More focused and potentially less May lack external perspective / time consuming relevant knowledge of audit committee best practice in local government Members have a good understanding of the Council, its priorities and existing governance arrangements
External review
Benefits Disadvantages
Will be seen as independent and There will be a cost, which could be objective significant (and therefore budget implications)
Offers an opportunity to learn from Only limited options may be best practice in other local available to access relevant authorities and/or the wider public expertise sector May not fully understand or reflect ‘local’ priorities or ways of working
4. Other potential alternative(s) and why these have not been recommended
4.1There are no other options available.
5. Impact(s) of the recommended decision(s)
Topic Impact Financial (including An internally facilitated self-assessment can be delivered procurement and within the current contract budget management Social Value) arrangements for the Internal Audit service provided by Veritau. Should the Committee decide to seek an
3 This document was classified as: OFFICIAL
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
Outcome of the Review of Internal AuditAGREED that: 1. The findings of the review of the Council’s current internal audit arrangements be noted. 2. The prop...
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.