CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Middlesbrough Borough Council
Audit Committee, Thursday 31 July 2025 at 1.30pm

Review of the Effectiveness of Audit Committee - Final Report, Recommendations and Next Steps

Agreed Finance 2 papers

Audit Committee agreed this item on Thursday 31 July 2025. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item24/4

Resolved

It was agreed that a discussion pre meeting would need to be held away from the actual committee meeting room. · Stopping or Limiting Members Substitution - the review found that substitutions are rarely used and although the system works well it was suggested that substitutions needed to be limited and best practice was not to have them at all. · Members preference was to have a limitation and a pool of audit committee trained members for this purpose. A Member raised that there needs to be more training in this area, rather than just the one-hour compulsory training per year. · Appointing two Independent Members to the Audit Committee, with remuneration at an appropriate level. This review highlighted that most Councils have this, and it is best practice. Concerns were raised regarding the cost of the remuneration which was potentially £5,000 to £7,000 per year. The advantages of this were discussed, such as having specific individuals who can bring a specialist accounting skill set to the committee, but Members would like to see how this works in other Councils and what value this has added. The External Auditor spoke about this being a compliance point as the English Devolution Bill stated a requirement of one Independent Member to be part of the committee. Advice was given that the standard is a minimum of two Independent Members, as best practice and there will need to be good enough reasons for not implementing this and to also consider external scrutiny. · A training needs analysis and a training plan was recommended for each Audit Committee Member, covering all CIPFA best practices, risk, governance and control. This training needed to be for substitute members also. It was mentioned that this kind of training had been offered before, but there was low take up from Members. Members discussed that they each had different skills sets and that some of the training was not needed for everyone. The review highlighted individual training needs analysis should be carried out per member. A Councillor, who was in attendance as an observer in the public gallery, stated that he could not attend the substitute training for Audit Committee as he had other Council commitments during the time that the training was taking place. ... view the full minutes text for item 24/4
Word for word from the decision Middlesbrough published for this meeting. Source: moderngov.middlesbrough.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Middlesbrough's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Audit Committee
This report is being read into text

Papers are read newest first, so recent reports come through within hours. Until then, open it at source.

Open the PDF

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Findings of the Review of the Effectiveness of Audit Committee by the Local Government Association /4Appendix 1 223 KB Copy on its way
PDF
Review of the Effectiveness of Audit Committee: Final Report, Recommendations and Next StepsReport 311 KB Copy on its way

At this meeting

Whole meeting
24/3Work Programme (Standard Item)Agreed
24/4Review of the Effectiveness of Audit Committee - Final Report, Recommendations and Next StepsThis decision

On this subject at Middlesbrough

Search all
  1. Review of the Effectiveness of Audit Committee - Final Report, Recommendations and Next StepsThis decision
  2. Audit Committee Review of EffectivenessAgreed

More from Middlesbrough Audit Committee

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
25 Jun 2026 Management of Strategic Risk 17 - Funding for Key External Projects led by TVCA or MDCAGREED that: 1. The latest position regarding Strategic Risk 17 be noted. 2. The Committee considered that it had rec... Agreed Open
25 Jun 2026 Training Programme for Audit Committee MembersAGREED that: 1. The proposed Audit Committee Member training programme for 2026/27 be approved. 2. Attendance at iden... Agreed Open
25 Jun 2026 Head of Internal Audit Annual Report 2025/26AGREED that: 1. The report be noted. 2. The Corporate Director of Finance present a report to the September 2026 meet... Agreed Open
25 Jun 2026 Outcome of the Review of Internal AuditAGREED that: 1. The findings of the review of the Council’s current internal audit arrangements be noted. 2. The prop... Agreed Open
25 Jun 2026 Counter Fraud Annual ReportAGREED that: 1. The 2025/26 be noted. Agreed Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies