Decision That the Mayor in consultation with the Cabinet agreed: ( i ) to approve a member performance management scheme for cabinet members, mayoral advisers and lead members on community forums as set out in appendix 2 to the report; (ii) that the Mayor appoints two members to the Performance Group; (iii) to recommend to Council that it approves the scheme for all other positions attracting a special responsibility allowance and appoints two members to the Performance Group; and (iv) that the Mayor and Council give authority to the Chief Executive to make minor alterations to the operation of the scheme following consultation with the Performance Group in the light of experience from the pilot scheme. This decision is subject to the call-in process as a Member had reserved the right to seek call-in of the decision.
Word for word from the decision Newham published for this meeting.Source: mgov.newham.gov.uk
Notes of meeting held on Monday 8th March 2004, 7.12 p.m. – 8.24 p.m.
SCHEME COMMENTS RESPONSE Member Evaluation Individual members comments The Chair and members of the are summarised as follows: Working Party responded as follows: Council Decision • The Council decision was • All councillors should that the scheme should be achieve certain applied to members with requirements. In order to SRA’s and yet the paper evaluate members with before them suggested that SRA’s there should be a other (backbench) members baseline for levels of should partake albeit on a achievement. The ALG voluntary basis. recommended evaluation.
• Councillors without SRA’s should be judged by the electorate.
• Do not think that job • The decision to evaluate descriptions can be applied and therefore have job to members. descriptions was taken by Council in December. Again the ALG recommended that councillors have job descriptions. This is also part of the member allowance scheme.
• The Mayor should monitor This does not preclude the the performance of the Mayor monitoring the executive not the council. performance of cabinet The Council should monitor members etc. It complements it. the performance of the Mayor
• Those members with SRA’s • Members in receipt of should be accountable to SRA’s should be reporting the Mayor but they should to the Mayor anyway. They write reports to the Mayor need to justify to the at appropriate stages. electors why members are given SLA’s.
• The Working Party wants to produce a clear and transparent scheme. Scrutiny • One of the duties of • It would cause fundamental Scrutiny is to hold the problems to exclude executive to account – it scrutiny members from the does not seem appropriate process. However the for a member of scrutiny to working party would look be monitored by the at members’ concerns and executive. possibly amend so members of the executive do not evaluate scrutiny members. (Note – The scheme has been amended so that the panel interviewing Scrutiny Chairs would consist of the 2 councillors appointed by Council. Therefore the 2 appointees should not be Chairs of Scrutiny)
• There are 16 areas of • The Head of Scrutiny is accountability for the Chair revising Job descriptions, of Scrutiny, which should but members only need to be reduced to 4. concentrate on the most relevant areas of accountability pertaining to that member.
Performance group • Would those officers on the • Officers would not be panel be checking up on discussing members; they councillors? would provide information and advice.
• Who would monitor the • In theory one panel would members of the monitor the members of the performance group? other panel and vice versa.
Evaluation • Already have evaluation • An evaluation scheme and training as part of could show where member development. improvements could be made. It is an opportunity for councillors to improve.
• Should be on a voluntary • We were asking for basis. Backbench members volunteers to see how the should not be guinea pigs. scheme progresses.
• No member should be commenting on the individual performance of another member, especially of another political group. Action Plans • Would there be one • Yes there would only be assessment report. one assessment.
What if the individual does The members of the panel not agree with it would it and the individual would still be published? seek to reach an agreement.
• What would happen if the • It would be for the evaluation process showed individual member to that a member was decide what they should do performing badly? to improve performance
• Setting personal action • Setting personal action plans should be entirely plans would be entirely voluntary. voluntary.
Costs • Is there an initial and • Cost likely to be lower than annual cost? people would assume.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.