CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
London Borough of Newham
Cabinet, Thursday 25 March 2004

Final report of the Excel Arms Fair Scrutiny Commission (EP63/2004)

Approved Executive 2 papers

Cabinet approved this item on Thursday 25 March 2004. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item18

Resolved

Decision That the Mayor in consultation with the Cabinet approve the recommendations of the Excel Arms Fair Scrutiny Commission and the Mayor’s response, as set out in item 19 on the agenda. Members commented on the recommendations of the Scrutiny Commission and specific reference was made to the need to address the right to protest against a recognition of commercial realities. However, the Arms Fair had seriously inconvenienced local residents both in relation to police activity and the behaviour of demonstrators. The Mayor sought a review of the Council’s lettings policy and the issue of enforcement action taken against organisations flyposting in the borough. He was firmly of the view that organisations that behaved in an anti-social way should not be permitted to use the Council’s facilities or have access to the Council’s buildings. The decision was taken for the reasons set out in the report. Decision That the Mayor in consultation with the Cabinet ( i ) approve the recommendations of the Excel Arms Fair Scrutiny Commission and the Mayor’s response, as set out in agenda item 19; and (ii) request officers to report on the legal implications of the following in relation to the Council’s lettings policy:  a list of activities that are and are not permitted on our premises  establishing a list of organisations that are barred from using our facilities, to include all those guilty of fly posting in the borough  to be reassured that no political or religio us extremists or supporters of prescribed groups have access to our buildings  officers to prepare a tough letting contract that enables the Council to secure variable deposits, to offset against possible damage or cleaning up arrangements  these deposit s to be forfeited in the event of a breach of that contract and the need to cancel the booking  the Council to insist that adequate stewarding and security is in place for all public political meetings.
Word for word from the decision Newham published for this meeting. Source: mgov.newham.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Newham's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Cabinet

Impact of Excel Arms Fair Scrutiny Commission

IMPACT OF EXCEL ARMS FAIR SCRUTINY COMMISSION

DRAFT FINAL REPORT 16th February 2004

COUNCILLOR PAUL BRICKELL, CHAIR

http://www.newham.gov.uk/democracy/Scrutiny/ 1 Impact of Excel Arms Fair Scrutiny Commission CHAIR'S FOREWORD The Arms Fair - DSEi - held at the Excel Exhibition Centre in September, 2003, and the activity surrounding it, had a very significant negative impact on local people, especially in the Custom House area. The Overview and Scrutiny Committee therefore set up our Commission to look into how to improve planning and lessen disruption if the event takes place in future years.

I am grateful to all the organisations concerned in the Left to right - Cllr Sarah Ruiz, exercise for giving freely of their Cllr Marie Collier, Cllr Paul time to contribute to our work (a Brickell (Chair) Cllr Alan Talyor, Cllr Pat Holland full list appears in Appendix 2), and also to the Commission Members for their commitment to the task. I would also like to thank Councillor Pat Holland, a local Ward Member, who, though not part of the Commission, joined in all our activities and took the lead in going out and about talking to local people.

Although the staging of the event is to some extent a contractual matter between Excel and Spearhead, the company who runs it, there are also lessons for others, including the Council and the police. I hope that our findings and recommendations will influence all parties concerned so that if DSEi must take place at Excel again, it will do so in a way that enables our residents to go about their daily business with the minimum of upheaval.

Paul Brickell Chair, Impact of Excel Arms Fair Scrutiny Commission

http://www.newham.gov.uk/democracy/Scrutiny/ 2 Impact of Excel Arms Fair Scrutiny Commission EXECUTIVE SUMMARY This report gives an account of the Scrutiny Commission's plan of work for its investigation into the impact on local residents of the Arms Fair at Excel in September, 2003. It sets out the evidence of all the key parties involved in the organisation of the fair and the events surrounding it, and suggests how we might all work towards lessening the impact on Newham's residents in the future.

We found that strenuous efforts had gone into:

• ensuring delegates got to the fair safely and with the minimum of inconvenience; • attempting to ensure security was not breached at Excel itself; • preventing crime and maintaining public order; and • facilitating lawful demonstration

However, addressing the needs of the local community left much to be desired.

Nevertheless, most of those we spoke to expressed a willingness to consider ways in which to lessen the disruptive impact on local people in future, and we hope they will respond positively to the recommendations in this report. They are: Specific recommendations in relation to DSEi

A. That the Mayor initiates discussions as soon as possible between himself, the Chief Executive of Excel, the Chief Executive of Spearhead, the Borough Commander, the senior Metropolitan Police Officer in charge of policing DSEi and the Director of Campaign Against the Arms Trade. The aim of such discussions should be:

• to enable all parties to understand that the level of disruption experienced by local people in 2003 was unacceptable and must not be repeated;

• to explore the advisability of holding the Arms Fair in Newham again; and

• if DSEi 2005 does go ahead, to begin a process (to be continued by Council officers and local Members) of asserting the rights of local people and advocating effectively on their behalf in the preparation period.

B. That a communications strategy is drawn up between Excel, the police and the Council to ensure that all local residents are fully consulted and informed in advance of any future Arms Fairs at Excel. This process should adopt various channels of communication in addition to those already used, e.g:-

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
EP63Report 154 KB DownloadRead as text
PDF
Final report of the Excel Arms Fair Scrutiny Commission (EP63/2004)Report 85 KB Download

At this meeting

Whole meeting
3MINUTESOn the agenda 5School Admissions for 2005/06 (EP50/2004)Agreed 6Integrated Mental Health Services (EP51/2004)Agreed 7Newham Early Years Strategy 2004/07 (EP52/2004)Agreed 8Creation of an Audit Board (EP53/2004)Agreed 9Bus Route 25 - Conversion to 'Articulated' Bus Operation (EP55/2004)Agreed 10London Bus Priority Network - Route 5 - A124 Barking Road - Proposed Bus Priority Measures (EP55/2004)Agreed 11Integrated Community Equipment Service (EP56/2004)Agreed 12Final report of the Vocational Education and Regeneration Scrutiny Commission (EP57/2004)Approved 13Mayor's response to the final report of the Vocational Education and Regeneration Scrutiny Commission (EP58/2004)Approved 14Final report of the Front of House Scrutiny Commission (EP59/2004)Approved 15Mayor's response to the final report of the Front of House Scrutiny Commission (EP60/2004)Approved 16Final report of the Improving Newham Streets Scrutiny Commission (EP61/2004)Approved 17Mayor's response to the final report of the Improving Newham Streets Scrutiny Commission (EP62/2004)Approved
18Final report of the Excel Arms Fair Scrutiny Commission (EP63/2004)This decision
19Mayor's response to the final report of the Excel Arms Fair Scrutiny Commission (EP64/2004)Approved 20Final report of the Green Procurement Scrutiny Commission (EP65/2004)Approved 21Mayor's response to the final report of the Green Procurement Scrutiny CommissionApproved 22Evaluating Performance of Members with Special Responsibility Allowances (EP67/2004)Agreed 23Protocols for Executive Working Arrangements (EP68/2004)Agreed 24The Influential Councillor (EP69/2004)Agreed 25Silvertown Way Planning Brief - Adoption as Supplementary Planning Guidance (EP6/2004)Agreed 26Stratford Rail Lands Framework Plan - Adoption as Supplementary Planning Guidance (EP7/2004)Agreed 27New Supplementary Planning Guidance - Environmental Sustainability Checklist for Mayor Development: Results of Public Consultation (EP9/2004)Agreed

Who was there

24 of 30 attended
NT
Norman TurnerOfficer, present
CW
Chris WoodOfficer, apologies
BH
Bob HeatonOfficer, present
HS
Helen SidwellOfficer, present
IT
Ian TompkinsOfficer, apologies
SR
Sir Robin WalesChair, present
AB
Councillor Andrew BaikieMember, present
CB
Christine BowdenMember, present
LB
Councillor Lyn Brown MPMember, present
UD
Councillor Unmesh Desai AMMember, present
LH
Councillor Lester HudsonMember, present
GL
Councillor Graham LaneMember, present

All 30 on the meeting page

On this subject at Newham

Search all
  1. Final report of the Excel Arms Fair Scrutiny Commission (EP63/2004)This decision
  2. Mayor's response to the final report of the Excel Arms Fair Scrutiny Commission (EP64/2004)Approved

More from Newham Cabinet

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
17 Nov 2026 Quarter 2 2026/27 Budget Monitoring ReportDecision For the reasons set out in this report and its appendices, Cabinet RESOLVED to: i ) Note the General Fund Re... Noted Open
17 Nov 2026 Draft Budget Proposals for 2027/28 and the MTFPDecision For the reasons set out in this report and its appendices, Cabinet RESOLVED to: i) To agree, for the purpose... Agreed Open
17 Nov 2026 Newham Lane Rental SchemeDecision For the reasons set out in this report and its appendices, Cabinet RESOLVED to: i) Approve the roads the Cou... Approved Open
17 Nov 2026 Holiday Activities and Food (HAF) Programme Grant Funding Approach 2027 and 2028Decision For the reasons set out in this report and its appendices, Cabinet RESOLVED to: i) To officers allocating HA... Decided Open
17 Nov 2026 Pre Procurement Report Approval - Schools Capital Condition Programme 2026/2027For the reasons set out in this report and its appendices, Cabinet RESOLVED to: i) Accept £ 4,021,591 of grant fundin... Agreed Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies