The Mayor in consultation with the Cabinet (a) approved the Heads of Terms; and (b) agreed to delegate authority to the Project Director to enter into contractual arrangements to put into effect the principles contained in the Heads of Terms (Canning Town) in consultation with the Executive Director (Resources), Head of Legal Services and Divisional Director Property and Design Consultancy. Reason for the decision: This follows on from the decision taken in February 2004 to negotiate the Heads of Terms and consider a possible delivery mechanism with the partners for the Canning Town and Custom House project. This decision grants authority to proceed with these in legal terms.
Word for word from the decision Newham published for this meeting.Source: mgov.newham.gov.uk
Delivering the Renaissance of Canning Town and Custom House
Response to Legal Briefing Paper – Executive Summary
1st February 2005
1 Introduction
This paper provides an executive summary of the response to the legal briefing paper issued by ECF, EP and LBN in relation to the impact of EU procurement legislation and restrictions on the provision of state aid on the proposals for the regeneration of Canning Town.
2 Procurement
2.1We believe that in principle the Public Service Procurement Directives do not apply to the appointment of ECF as developer as envisaged by the heads of terms.
2.2This is on the basis that the arrangements can most properly be considered as a complex contractual arrangement for land development, rather than a contract for the provision of services or the provision of works. In addition, any works or services which are being procured as a result of the contractual arrangement are not works or services which are being provided “for a contracting authority” – except possibly the housing, which will in any event be procured through a tender process undertaken in accordance with the Directives.
2.3In view of the complexity of this issue, we have taken advice from leading counsel, who has confirmed our view as to the likely interpretation of the contractual arrangements. It is never possible to preclude the possibility of a challenge being made in relation to any arrangements entered into by a public sector body, but on balance we consider it unlikely that any challenge would be successful.
2.4We have reviewed the changes which have been made to the Heads of Terms against leading counsel’s opinion, and do not believe that any changes have been made which would impact on this interpretation. Key issues which support the analysis, and which should be retained in any revised contractual structure are:-
• The fact that ownership of the new development will not pass back to any of the public sector parties involved, save for (i) assets of a low value in the overall scheme (such as community buildings) (ii) roads which may be transferred to LBN
1 BLP1.3162026.01.TEKI/22172/00003 3.2.2005 in its capacity as highways authority, but in any event are to be procured by EP; and (iii) housing, which is to be procured through the Directives.
• The Project should retain the “umbrella” structure currently proposed, as any attempt to break it down into a number of constituent parts, covered by separate contracts, might lead to the conclusion that the Project comprises a number of separate procurement projects each of which is covered by the procurement directives.
3 State Aid
3.1Subject to compliance with the constraints referred to below, we do not consider the proposed structure for the Project is inconsistent with the state aid regime.
3.2ECF, by virtue of its constitution, provides state aid whenever it invests in a project. However, this state aid has been specifically cleared by the European Commission, and provided that ECF acts within the terms of such clearance, the state aid is deemed to be allowed. There are one or two clarifications which need to be made on the detailed terms of the Clearance. These are considered as relatively minor in policy terms, and ECF is currently dealing with these directly with ODPM and DTI, with a view to resolving them by end March 2005.
3.3The transfer of land by LBN to ECF will not constitute state aid, provided that the transfer is for value. There is, however, no reason why payment cannot be deferred, as envisaged here, provided that the basis of the deferral can be justified as being market terms.
3.4Much of the infrastructure works are to be provided by EP. The state aid regulations permit EP to provide infrastructure at its own cost, provided that such infrastructure does not benefit one sole end user, without any state aid issues arising.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.