Resolved
Decision The Development Control Committee agreed to delegate authority to the Borough Planning Officer to make representations to the LTGDC recommending that, subject to referral to the Mayor of London (GLA), planning permission be refused for the reasons set out below. Reasons for Refusal: 1. The proposed development, by reason of the unsympathetic design and appearance of the proposed buildings and the excessive scale and height of the proposed buildings, particularly that of the lower building (Building 2), would neither preserve or enhance the Stratford St John’s Conservation Area and would have a discordant, dominating, overbearing and detrimental impact on the historic character and setting of the Stratford St John’s Conservation Area, causing significant and demonstrable harm to local heritage, townscape and visual amenity, contrary to Policies S3, S11, EQ18, EQ19, EQ27, EQ28, EQ30, EQ31, EQ36, EQ38, H17 and SH2 of the London Borough of Newham Unitary Development Plan (adopted June 2001 and saved from 27/09/2007 by direction from the Secretary of State) and Policies 3A.6, 4B.1, 4B.2, 4B.9, 4B.10, 4B.11 and 4B.12 of the London Plan (Feb 2008: Consolidated with Alterations Since 2004). 2. The proposed development, by reason of the unsympathetic design and appearance of the proposed buildings and the excessive scale and height of the proposed buildings, would have a discordant, dominating, overbearing and detrimental impact on the setting of the Grade II listed buildings and locally listed buildings within the Stratford St John’s Conservation Area and surroundings, particularly The Church of St John the Evangelist, Martyrs’ Memorial, Gurney Memorial Drinking Fountain, former West Ham Town Hall, 13 Broadway, 47 Broadway, 49 Broadway and 361-383 High Street. The proposed development would consequently cause significant and demonstrable harm to local heritage, townscape and visual amenity, contrary to Policies S3, S11, EQ18, EQ19, EQ27, EQ28, EQ30, EQ31, EQ36, EQ38, H17 and SH2 of the London Borough of Newham Unitary Development Plan (adopted June 2001 and saved from 27/09/2007 by direction from the Secretary of State) and Policies 3A.6, 4B.1, 4B.2, 4B.9, 4B.10, 4B.11 and 4B.12 of the London Plan (Feb ... view the full minutes text for item 9.