Decision The Mayor agreed to award the contract for a total of £ 1.255 million for the supply of the 28 Mechanical Sweepers to Johnson Sweepers Ltd and Tennant Ltd with the operating lease to Siemens Financial Services: a. 3 x Tennant 424 pedestrian sweepers at £41k over a 3 year period b. 19 x Johnson CN101 compact sweepers at £ 720k over a 3 year period c. 4 x Johnson mid range CX200 sweepers at £ 267k over a 5 year period d. 2 x Johnson VT650 road sweepers at £227k over a 5 year period Reasons for the Decision In order to reach the recommendations the Council conducted a market testing exercise with the help of Sector Treasury, who are the Council’s financial advisors. Using EU frameworks covering Outright Purchase and Operating Lease. Results of the Outright Purchase tender exercise highlighted our preferred supplier(s). Each was the most economically advantageous in terms of cost, sustainability, efficiency, maximum productivity and fit for purpose solution, whilst meeting our specification requirements. Newham’s finance section evaluated the reports and concurred with Sector that an Operating lease with annual payments in advance gave Newham the best cost saving option. The report and decision have complied with Part 4.5, paragraph 16 of the Constitution. The decision is not subject to the Call-In process and may be implemented immediately.
Word for word from the decision Newham published for this meeting.Source: mgov.newham.gov.uk
This report seeks Mayor’s approval to award the contract for the procurement of 28 Mechanical Sweepers.
Recommendations
The Mayor is asked to award the contract for the supply of the 28 Mechanical Sweepers to Johnson Sweepers Ltd and Tennant Ltd with the operating lease to Siemens Financial Services.
3 x Tennant 424 pedestrian sweepers at £41k over a 3 year period 19 x Johnson CN101 compact sweepers at £ 720k over a 3 year period 4 x Johnson mid range CX200 sweepers at £ 267k over a 5 year period 2 x Johnson VT650 road sweepers at £227k over a 5 year period
Total value of the contract is £ 1.255 million.
Reasons for the recommendations
In order to reach the recommendations the Council conducted a market testing exercise with the help of Sector Treasurary, who are the Council’s financial advisors. Using EU frameworks covering Outright Purchase and Operating Lease.
Results of the Outright Purchase tender exercise highlighted our preferred supplier(s). Each was the most economically advantageous in terms of cost, sustainability, efficiency, maximum productivity and fit for purpose solution, whilst meeting our specification requirements. Newham’s finance section evaluated the reports and concurred with Sector that an Operating lease with annual payments in advance gave Newham the best cost saving option.
NAME OF LEAD OFFICER: Jarlath Griffin POSITION: Head of Operation
Originator of report: Adrian Furminger Tel no: 020 337 30361 E-mail address: [email protected]
Local Government (Access to Information) Act 1985 Background papers used in preparing this report: • Pre-procurement Report to the Mayor in March 2010
List of enclosures / Appendices: • None Report - Part A
1. Introduction and Background
1.1The objectives for procurement of the fleet are;
• To obtain value for money from the procurement • To minimise the cost to the Council of existing spot / contract hire arrangements • To have one maintenance provider – in house or external • To have arrangements that are OJEU compliant • To have a new fleet in place as soon as practical • To have arrangements in place that can be cliented without an increase in resources. • To have sufficient flexibility in the arrangements to react to changes in client demand.
This phase of the Fleet procurement programme is for the procurement of Mechanical Sweepers for Street Cleansing.
Sector, the Council’s Treasury Management advisers, were asked to advise on aspects of the tender. Sector advised that a variety of Frameworks are available and introduced the council to The Procurement Partnership Ltd (TPPL) who would help to find suitable frameworks. The Council therefore had a number of options on procurement.
After discussing the needs of Street Cleansing, The Procurement Partnership Ltd (TPPL) recommended relevant Braintree Framework.
Tenders were issued to obtain a preferred supplier and pricing for outright purchase based on the requirement for 28 Mechanical Sweepers built to the specifications agreed by the project team and the clients. The tenders were evaluated against an evaluation matrix prepared and agreed by the project team, resulting in Johnston and Tennant becoming our preferred suppliers.
The pricing information was used as a basis to obtain operating lease prices and the Council was recommended to use the Walsall framework for this exercise.
The Walsall framework tender returned prices which were reviewed by Finance and evaluated by the Councils project team.
Officers have evaluated and recommended the best procurement route, taking in to consideration outright purchase against leasing and factoring in the option of various payment periods.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.