Decision The Standards Advisory Committee agreed to note: i) The decisions of the Monitoring Officer in respect of the three complaints; ii) The advice on the application of the Code of Conduct to matters of political expression; and iii) The Chief Executive’s response to the challenge of the decisions by Councillor Gray and Councillor Scoresby
Word for word from the decision Newham published for this meeting.Source: mgov.newham.gov.uk
1.1For the reasons set out in this report, the Panel is recommended to note:
1.1.1 The decisions of the Monitoring Officer in respect of the three related complaints.
1.1.2 The advice on the application of the Code of Conduct to matters of political expression.
1.1.3 To note the comments at paragraph 6.
1.1.4 To note that the Chief Executive’s response to Cllrs Gray and Scoresby.
NAME OF LEAD OFFICER: Daniel Fenwick
POSITION: Director of Legal & Governance, Monitoring Officer
Author : Daniel Fenwick, Director Legal & Governance & Monitoring Officer
Tel no: 01708 432714
E-mail address: [email removed]
2. Local Government (Access to Information) Act 1985
Background papers used in preparing this report:
None.
List of enclosures / Appendices:
APPENDIX 1: Cllr Scoresby’s complaint and correspondence APPENDIX 2: Cllr Gray’s complaint and correspondence APPENDIX 3: [name removed] complaint and correspondence
3. Introduction
3.1This report consolidates three complaints on the grounds that they relate to similar if not identical issues in relation to member conduct and ethics and, secondly, the grounds for their rejection are all but identical.
4. The Complaints
Cllr Scoresby
4.1Cllr Scoresby’s complaint is at Appendix 1 and was submitted on 30 November 2015. In summary, she complained she had been subjected to bullying comments and actions by the Mayor and Cllrs Furness and Peppiatt. The complaints referred in large part to comments made in formal Council meetings and otherwise in respect of members carrying out their responsibilities as Cabinet members responding to an Overview and Scrutiny investigation.
4.2As Monitoring Officer, on 10 December 2015 I rejected the complaint on the basis that the comments made were political expression and so should not be investigated (see my explanation below).
Cllr Gray
4.3Cllr Gray’s complaint is at Appendix 2 and was submitted on 12 December 2015. He complained about the Mayor’s comments to him when the Cabinet considered a report on 25th August 2015. As Monitoring Officer, on 5 December 2015 I rejected the complaint on the same basis as Cllr Scoreby’s complaint.
Rachel Collinson
4.4[name removed] (formerly Nunson) complaint was submitted on 21 December 2015. She complained about the comments of Cllr Lester Hudson at a Scrutiny meeting on 24th August 2015. As Monitoring Officer, on 21 January 2016 I rejected the complaint on the same basis as Cllrs Scoreby’s and Gray’s complaints.
4.5Consequently, no investigation will take place and this report is for noting only. Both Cllrs Scoresby and Gray complained to the Chief Executive about my decisions. The Chief Executive rejected the complaints by email dated 18 February 2016. For this reason both complaints are now closed under the Council’s agreed procedures.
5. Reasons for Rejecting the Complaints: Political Expression
5.1As each complaint raised similar if not identical complaints and were rejected on the same grounds, I considered it appropriate to explain the rationale for my decisions to the Committee and on the grounds of transparency.
5.2In summary, I found that all of the comments complained about constituted “political expression” made in formal council meetings and so should not be subject to a Code of Conduct complaint. I further found in each case there was evidence that the comments went beyond political criticism to personal or unsubstantiated abuse. Such a circumstance might be where a comment was purely personally abusive, for example, a direct racial insult or an allegation that someone is a “a liar” without evidence.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.