Item9
Resolved
For the reasons set out in the report, Cabinet RESOLVED to AGREE i) The proposal for future annual payments by Lister and Rokeby Schools, in respect of school contributions for PFI services set out at paragraph 3.5 and table 2 of the report; ii) To delegate authority to the Corporate Director of Resources to: a) agree to formalise the above with Lister and Rokeby schools, including agreement of Heads of Terms and execute agreements as appropriate; b) consult and seek authority from Schools Forum regarding annual payments to the Councils general fund from the DSG in respect of contributions for PFI services as set out at paragraph 3.5 and table 2 and at paragraph 3.6 and table 3 of the report. iii) To note that officers intend to approach the Department for Education to seek additional Government funding in respect of increasing costs on the education PFI contracts and that, should additional Government funding not be made available, additional sums will need to be set aside within the Delegated Schools Budget (DSB) to make allowance for the potential shortfalls identified within the PFI models as set out at paragraph 4.7 of the report. Alternatives considered Do Nothing Option – Continue to invoice for payments with the schools likely to make partial payment against these invoices. This is not recommended because under recovery of sums invoiced by the Council will result in increasing accumulated shortfall to the Council’s forecast income. The matter will not be settled causing ongoing tension between the Council and the schools. Continue to conclusion of the Expert determination (see paragraph 2.4). This option should result in a clear and unambiguous ruling. The Council has already made some contingency plans in the event that the Expert does not determine wholly in our favour but these do not cover the entire disputed amount. The schools have been unable to make similar contingency plans and it is clear that the schools would be unable to honour any commitment to pay substantial sums due under a binding determination in the event that the ruling is not largely or entirely in their favour without very serious impact on their schools budgets and consequent detriment to the quality of education offered. As maintained schools the Council may have to step in to support the organisation and finances of the schools in any case. Therefore, this option is not recommended. Litigation: this approach is not recommended. It would damage working relationships between the Council and the schools which are otherwise positive and constructive. The Council has developed strong working relationships with these schools in order to deliver on key priorities for education in Newham. Lister school has agreed to expand by two forms of entry from 2021, to meet demand for additional secondary school places. Without this expansion the Council will not be able to offer all children a secondary school place for year 7 in 2021 and beyond. Rokeby School is working closely with the Council and an Interim Executive Board to support ...
Word for word from the decision Newham published for this meeting.
Source: mgov.newham.gov.uk