Item15
Resolved
For the reasons set out in the report, Cabinet RESOLVED to AGREE: i) The refurbishment of two existing identical buildings owned by the council to convert into 16No. (8No. in each) affordable homes for London Affordable Rent; ii) To waive the requirements under the Contract Standing Order to undertake competition in order to permit the direct award of the below EU threshold works contract detailed in para 2.1.3of the report; iii) To award a JCT design and build contract to Proma Construction Management Limited (herein further referred to as the contractor) for a value of £1,894,661.96 (excluding VAT) including a 10% contingency sum in order to permit the refurbishment to commence in this (2020/21) financial year. Alternatives considered The revised procurement strategy on the 22 nd November 2019 identified an alternative route to demolish the buildings and design and construct a new proposal on the site. This option was not taken further as the total costs for this was estimated at £6.14million and the initial survey of the buildings revealed that it was in relatively good condition and was suitable for refurbishment. This meant that the council commenced enabling works in anticipation of refurbishment. The alternative of not proceeding with the chosen contractor would be to end the existing licence with the contractor which concludes on the 30 th November 2020. This would then allow Newham to re-tender the scheme competitively and be in a position to grant possession to another contractor to undertake the work. The consequences with this would be: Loss of continuity with the programme with the building ready for refurbishment works to commence immediately and impact on the GLA programme. Loss of inherent knowledge in the scheme by a contractor that has undertaken the enabling works contract and has been involved in the design process and who crucially is aware of the risks/ cost within the existing building. A fixed price has been obtained at today’s prices and there will be no guarantee that the future tender price would be better than the proposed offer submitted by the contractor especially with contractors with less intimate knowledge of the building who would price risk into the project accordingly. The early delivery of the scheme will have a positive impact on mitigating costs associated with providing temporary accommodation. Delay to the programme of at least 4 months with a re-commencement of works on site in April 2021 rather than in December 2020 with any movement in tendering prices in the interim. Reputational risk with the adjoining site being hindered from its delivery of homes for the borough. This therefore supports the basis for awarding the Contract to the current contractor undertaking the works on the adjoining site and which has completed the enabling works.
Word for word from the decision Newham published for this meeting.
Source: mgov.newham.gov.uk