Item5
Resolved
For the reasons set out in the report and its appendices, Cabinet RESOLVED to AGREE: I. The closure of Newham City Farm; II. The inclusion of the farm site in the wider Beckton Parks Master plan as set out in section 6.4 of the report; III. The farm site remaining a publicly accessible open space; IV. To note the recommendations of the Housing, Environment and Regeneration Scrutiny Committee following both its study of the options and visit to the farm, as set out in section 8.3 of the report and the proposed responses as set out in section 8.4 of the report; V. To delegate authority to the Corporate Director of Environment, Highways and Sustainable Transport, in consultation with the Cabinet Member for the Environment, Highways and Sustainable Transport to undertake an initial consultation and feasibility exercise to support the delivery of a masterplan for Beckton District Park, Beckton Park and King George V Park, and that an interim report setting out the emerging findings be presented to Cabinet in February 2022; and VI. Furthermore, to note that, if approved, £75,000 of Section 106 monies would be allocated to fund the consultation and feasibility exercise. Alternatives Considered To do nothing – this option was not recommended. The current site did not meet the ongoing needs of the animals or visitors and remained closed to the public as it presented a risk to both the animals and visitors. Additionally, this would lead to further ongoing decline in the condition of the farm. The current revenue budget position was unsustainable with an identified ongoing pressure of £440,000 per year identified. To seek Capital Investment to re-open farm - this option was not recommended. Whilst capital investment could bring the farm up to a standard that met the ongoing needs of the animals or visitors, the current revenue budget position was unsustainable. The combination of the undelivered saving and additional revenue requirements had identified an ongoing pressure of £440,000 per year. Capital renewal of the site would take between two and four years with a more efficient site only slightly reducing the farms revenue costs. This scenario would create a position where £440,000 would need to be found for 2021/22 and 2022/23 and a likely reoccurring pressure of at least £300,000 thereafter. Explore alternate delivery models – this option was not recommended. The site had previously been run independently on two occasions by Community Links and Active Newham, in both cases the arrangement was unsustainable and handed back to the Council early. The site condition and revenue position meant that it would not be appropriate to hand over as-is. Significant capital and revenue investment over a number of years would be required to bring the site up to a standard before it could re-open with the reinstatement of the revenue budget required.
Word for word from the decision Newham published for this meeting.
Source: mgov.newham.gov.uk