Resolved
For the reasons set out in the report and its appendices, Cabinet RESOLVED to AGREE: i) To commence a procurement exercise to tender a two stage works contract through a restricted tender to commence in July 2023 at an estimate value of £2,415,584 to provide a new standalone classroom block, including a new PMLD resource provision at Colegrave Primary School; ii) To delegate the approval for the Pre Construction Services Agreement) for Colegrave primary school under delegated authority to the Director of Asset Management; iii) To commence a procurement exercise to tender a single stage works contract through a restricted tender to commence in July 2022 at an estimated value of £1,174,763 to reconfigure and relocate the school kitchen including associated works at Winsor Primary School; and iv) To delegate the authority to award the contract to carry out the refurbishment of the school kitchen including associated works at Winsor Primary School to the Corporate Director of Children and Young People Services in consultation with the lead Member for Education and Children`s Social care. Alternative Options Considered A number of options have been explored as part of this exercise. These are as set out below. 1. Do Nothing The mobile classrooms at Colegrave Primary School are life expired and will require replacement within the next 5 years. The school will need to continue to fund the considerable ongoing maintenance repairs whilst the demountable are in place. If the existing buildings are not replaced, they will fall into a further state of disrepair, which will lead to a reduction in teaching space and a shortfall in pupil spaces. There would also be no fundamental improvements to the PMLD resource provision if this issue were not addressed. At Winsor Primary School, school meals will continue to be wheeled through long and narrow corridors with mobile servery counters taking up valuable space within the current gymnasium area. Also the current Health and Safety issues associated with this situation will not be addressed. 2. Alternative Procurement Route Other procurement routes, including framework agreements have been considered and rejected. The values of the contracts at both schools being under £5,336,937 (inclusive of VAT), it is not deemed necessary to follow the route of a framework agreement to meet the FTS (Find a Tender Service) requirements. Extensive experience has demonstrated good value for money can be achieved by the use of Constructionline route via a selective tendering process. E-Auctions have been considered and rejected, this is because the construction Industry does not generally use or support e-auctions due to the extent of the supply chain requirements which are to be procured at a later date.