Relationship Between Black Boys and the Borough Scrutiny Commission - Phase II Report
AgreedExecutive3 papers
AI summaryNewham Cabinet agrees to consider the Phase II scrutiny report on Black boys' experiences and provide an Executive Response to its eight recommendations within the statutory timeframe.
Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeAgreedConsider report and provide Executive Response
MoneyNot stated
What happens nextExecutive Response dueWithin the statutory timeframe
Who it affectsBlack boys and young menAcross education, justice and employment
What was decided
Cabinet agreed to consider and respond to the Phase II report and its recommendations, which were endorsed by the Overview and Scrutiny Committee on 16 December 2025.
Cabinet will provide an Executive Response to the recommendations within the statutory timeframe, indicating how it has taken into account the scrutiny recommendations.
The report contains eight strategic recommendations covering data, education transitions, wraparound support, exclusions, governors, youth justice, partnerships and progress on Phase I. Report P21, P22, P23, P24, P26, P27, P28, P29, P30
Why
The Commission found that little progress has been made in improving outcomes for young Black boys and men over several decades, with persistent attainment gaps and over-representation in the criminal justice system. Report P14, P17
The Council's Constitution and statute require Cabinet to respond to scrutiny recommendations, indicating how they have been taken into account.
The Phase I report was approved by Overview and Scrutiny Committee on 4 June 2024 and submitted to Cabinet on 3 September 2024, with Phase II following to deepen the inquiry. Report P35
What happens next
By March 2026, all data captured by the Council's educational systems and services should be disaggregated for Black boys aged 11 to 18, using Free School Meals and CAMHS data. Report P22
By September 2026, a five-year statistically rigorous wraparound support pilot should begin in two or more maintained secondary schools for Black boys in years 7 to 11. Report P24
The Executive Response to the Phase II Report should include a summary of progress made on the Phase I recommendations. Report P30
The money
£100,000 Cost of the CAMHS Commission on the Future of Inclusion and Belonging, noted by Commission Members in the context of the Council's overall budget Report P44
Options considered
Chosen: Agree to consider and respond to the report and provide an Executive Response within the statutory timeframe
Rejected: Alternatives considered. Not applicable
Implications
Equalities: Recommendations address racial disparities in education, policing, employment and health for Black boys and young men, and engagement with the public sector equality duty. Report P14, P17, P51
Financial: A five-year wraparound pilot is proposed, alongside broader wraparound improvements, voluntary sector grant exploration and the Council's Inclusive Economy work on routes into employment. Report P24, P29
Staffing: Recommendations require collaboration across council services, schools, NHS services including CAMHS, the Metropolitan Police, criminal justice partners and the voluntary, community and faith sector. Report P24
Risk: The Commission warned that without disaggregated data and tailored approaches, Black boys will continue to fall through gaps in service design and provision. Report P20, P43
Other: The Commission expressed concern about slow pace of progress and limited engagement from some secondary school leadership and governing bodies, identified as the cohort whose decisions shape Black children's life chances. Report P11
Who and where
Black boys and young men aged 11 to 18 in the London Borough of Newham Report P22, P31
Maintained primary and secondary schools and their governing bodies Report P24, P27
Newham Council services, including Education, Children's Services and Youth Justice Report P22, P26, P28
NHS services and CAMHS, the Metropolitan Police Service and criminal justice partners Report P24, P46
Local employers and the Inclusive Economy directorate Report P29, P37
The voluntary, community and faith sector Report P24, P29
Parents and carers of Black boys Report P26, P27
Timeline
4 June 2024: Phase I report approved by the Overview and Scrutiny Committee Report P35
3 September 2024: Phase I report submitted to Cabinet Report P35
Summer 2024 to November 2024: Phase II evidence gathering, site visits and focus groups Report P35, P37, P43
16 December 2025: Overview and Scrutiny Committee endorsed the Phase II report and recommendations
20 January 2026: Cabinet agreed to consider the report and provide an Executive Response
By March 2026: All relevant Council data to be disaggregated for Black boys aged 11 to 18 Report P22
Within nine months of the report: Captures data on demographics of chairs of governors; wraparound support improvements for all Black boys in the Borough Report P24, P27
By September 2026: Five-year wraparound support pilot to begin in two or more maintained secondary schools Report P24
Within two years of the report: Database of demographics of all maintained school governors to be compiled Report P27
Plain English for the jargon
R4B Commission: Relationship Between Black Boys and the Borough Scrutiny Commission, set up by the Overview and Scrutiny Committee in 2021.
OSC: Overview and Scrutiny Committee of the Council.
SIMS: Schools Information Management System used by Newham Council's educational systems.
CAMHS: Child and Adolescent Mental Health Services.
SEND: Special Educational Needs and Disabilities.
YJS: Youth Justice Service.
HMIP: Her Majesty's Inspectorate of Prisons.
MPS: Metropolitan Police Service.
MOPAC: Mayor's Office for Policing And Crime.
VRU: London's Violence Reduction Unit.
UEL: University of East London.
IOPC: Independent Office for Police Conduct.
SMILE-ing boys: Newham Turnaround team project referenced as an example of wraparound support.
Policing with Compassion: Newham pilot programme focused on improved police interactions with neurodivergent young people.
What was decided, why, and what happens next
Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.
Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
Item11
Resolved
Decision For the reasons set out in the report and its appendices, Cabinet RESOLVED to Agree to: i) Consider and respond to the report and recommendations, as endorsed by the Overview and Scrutiny Committee on 16 December 2025. In accordance with statute and the Council’s Constitution, the Cabinet should now respond, indicating how it has taken into account the scrutiny recommendations (as per the pro forma); and ii) Provide an Executive Response to the recommendations made within the statutory timeframe. Alternatives Considered Not applicable
Word for word from the decision Newham published for this meeting.Source: mgov.newham.gov.uk
Scrutiny Commission Report Relationship Between Black Boys and the Borough - Phase II Report - December 2025
newham.gov.uk Table of contents Chair’s Foreword p4 Executive Summary and Recommendations p6
Introduction p11
Methodology p13 Education and School Experience p23 Criminal Justice and Youth Offending p32
Building Equity Through Partnerships p39
Recommendations p48 Conclusions p53
Appendices p55 01
Section 1: Background, Introduction and Methodology Chair’s Foreword Councillor McAlmont The Overview and Scrutiny Committee via its Relationship Between Black Boys and the Borough Scrutiny Commission has investigated the experience of Black boys and young men within the London Borough of Newham. Sadly, since I arrived in the UK from Guyana in 1983, I have seen little progress in the outcomes for our young Black boys and young men. This is a source of considerable personal dismay and disquiet, not least because of my own current professional context, working in education. However, in addition, in this intervening time of some forty years, there have also been several key legislative measures, inquiries and reports that have addressed race and the experiences of our Black young men, particularly in areas like education, employment, justice and policing, with varying success. Despite these efforts, outcomes have largely remained unchanged.
Hence, my Commission has sought to challenge there is no pipeline that leads to a life in and out this status quo. It has identified key areas in need of the margins. How we address these systemic of intervention, heard from community inequalities is critical in a borough like ours, where stakeholders and conducted research to the future of the community is deeply tied to the recommend avenues for meaningful change with outcomes of its youth. For Newham’s Black boys the hope of diminishing the disproportionately and young men to thrive, local policy and services negative outcomes for Black boys in Newham. As must engage with their realities, amplify their we saw evidenced in our first report, our Black voices, and invest in long-term, community-rooted children and young men face many persistent change. obstacles to their positive achievement and attainment of wellbeing, through the combination It is not enough for our schools and other of intersecting factors class, environment and institutions not to be racist: we need to be anti- structural poverty. racist. This is not as easy nor as obvious as it may sound, especially when we see the retrograde We see in the second phase of our investigations measures in the U.S., for example, against that education remains key, in order to ensure that embracing diversity, and the strength which comes
4 Relationship Between Black Boys and the Borough Scrutiny Commission Phase II Report
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.