Recommend to Council that: Planning proposals for new housing development are assessed against the criteria of Local Plan Policy C1, and if found to be compliant with the Policy then planning permission be granted without the imposition of a restrictive planning condition that ties the development to the residency criteria set out in the Guidance Note. An existing member of Development Control staff be ‘up-skilled’ to become a specialist ‘Third Tier Officer’, who can provide support and assistance to applicants, agents and Parish Councils etc. A new Guidance Note be produced to cover a much broader range of issues to assist with the interpretation of Policy C1, particularly in relation to how new development can support local services. Subject to Council’s approval to delete the ‘residency qualification’, then a letter be sent to developers and local councils outlining the changes to Policy C1 but that ‘identified local need’ still had to be established.
Word for word from the decision North Kesteven published for this meeting.Source: democracy.n-kesteven.gov.uk
Report Title: Residential Development in Third Tier Villages Key Decision Yes No Recommendation to Council Yes No
Council Meeting Date: 26th February 2009
Purpose of Report This report seeks to identify the opportunities for greater flexibility with the consideration of housing developments in Third Tier Villages, and to report the findings of the public consultation undertaken in connection with the Residency Criteria approved by the Executive Board in January of 2008.
Summary Members have expressed concern that the operation of the adopted Policy C1 is too restrictive and is preventing housing development opportunities in our smaller villages.
The current application of policy limits new housing opportunities to those that represent frontage infill development that meets identified local needs, or which support local services. In terms of interpretation of Policy C1, the Council has identified ‘local needs’ housing as being affordable housing, agricultural workers dwellings, and housing proposals that satisfy the residency criteria set out in the Residency Criteria Guidance Note.
The Residency Criteria Guidance Note has been the subject of public consultation and details of the responses are set out in Appendix 1 of this Report.
To assist with Members understanding of the legal framework associated with the operation of the Policy, and on the options for review, legal advice has been sought from Counsel. His conclusions are as follows;
1. The Council only has the legal power to amend or change Local Plan Policy C1 via the Local Development Framework which will take a considerable period of time to complete.
2. The Residency Criteria (as set out in the clarification note prepared after adoption of the local plan) as drafted represents, in his view, a policy which can carry only limited weight as a material planning consideration, as they have been drafted after, rather than before, the decision to adopt it. The consultation was therefore ineffective for the purpose of adding weight to the policy.
3. If a development proposal is in accordance with the criteria of Policy C1, then there should be no need for the Council to impose a restrictive planning condition. The key test is whether a development proposal satisfies identified local need as set out in Policy C1, rather than the residential qualification as set out in the guidance note. In response to the concerns by Members that the Policy is being applied to restrictively, and in response to some of the comments raised during the consultation exercise in connection with the Residency Criteria Guidelines, the following options are proposed by Offices;
1. That planning proposals for new housing development are assessed against the criteria of Local Plan Policy C1, and if found to be compliant with the Policy then planning permission be granted without the imposition of a restrictive planning condition that ties the development to the residency criteria set out in the Guidance Note.
2. That an existing member of Development Control staff be ‘up-skilled’ to become a specialist ‘Third Tier Officer’, who can provide support and assistance to applicants, agents and Parish Councils etc. This would be a proactive role, and critically would seek to lessen the tension between the aspirations of Members to be less restrictive towards housing development in third tier villages, whilst maintaining credibility in the operation of the Local Plan policy.
3. That a new Guidance Note be produced to cover a much broader range of issues to assist with the interpretation of Policy C1, particularly in relation to how new development can support local services.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.