RECOMMENDED: That the membership and structure of the Planning Committees remain the same but that all meetings be held in the Council Chamber, Sleaford; That, in respect of all Committee/Panel meetings, the minutes should aim to be dispatched within 14 working days after the date of the meeting instead of awaiting dispatch of agenda for the following meeting;
Word for word from the decision North Kesteven published for this meeting.Source: democracy.n-kesteven.gov.uk
To present to the Executive Board the final recommendations from the Local Economy Overview and Scrutiny Panel in respect of the Committee Structure review.
Background
At the July/August meetings the three Overview and Scrutiny Panels agreed to appoint a Committee Structure Task and Finish Group. The purpose of the appointment was to examine the effectiveness of the Council’s current committee structure and make any appropriate recommendations for improvement.
To allow a broader balance of membership and greater ownership of the review three Members from each Panel were nominated onto the Group, as follows:
• Councillors Oxby, Suiter and Whittle (Local Community OSP); • Councillors Goldson, Little and Wright (Local Environment OSP); • Councillors Chambers, [name removed] and Wylie (Local Economy OSP).
At the Task and Finish Group’s first meeting Councillor Chambers was appointed as Chairman.
Research
Various forms of research have been undertaken in an attempt to gather as much evidence as possible on the current structure and ideas for possible future arrangements. The following research was undertaken:
Making comparisons with other authorities
At the Group’s first meeting the scoping exercise for the review was undertaken. Members requested information on the operation of committee structures at other local authorities.
The Group asked for a list of suitable authorities to consider, that fell into any of the following categories:
• Authorities rated as “Excellent” in their CPA Assessment; • Authorities that have climbed the league tables during the last few years; and • Authorities of a similar size to NKDC and with a similar ratio of Councillors to residents.
The Scrutiny Officer gathered information from Council websites on 18 different local authorities, six from each of the three categories above. Practically every Council investigated operated with a different committee structure to the next: whether this was the Scrutiny arrangements; the number of Elected Members serving on the Planning Committee; or the methods for member involvement in audit, governance and performance issues.
This piece of research clearly did not provide the Group with a blue-print committee structure to adopt. In fact, quite the opposite was the case. The evidence suggested that there was not a ‘one size fits all’ approach to committee structures. Each Council had adopted a system based on its individual circumstances.
This proved to be useful exercise as the Group realised they should concentrate more on gathering information internally than looking at other authorities.
Interviews with Members
The following Members were invited to attend a meeting of the Group to give their views and answer questions on various, relevant aspects of the Council’s committee structure:
• Leader of the Council; • Chairman of Planning Committee; • Chairman of Licensing Panel; • Chairman of Audit Committee; • Chairman of each Overview and Scrutiny Panel .
Interviews with Officers
The following Officers were invited to attend a meeting of the Group to give their views and answer questions on various, relevant aspects of the Council’s committee structure:
• Ian Fytche, Chief Executive; • Patricia Phillipson, Head of Corporate Strategy; • Jane Wells, Head of Planning, Economic and Cultural Services; • Andrew McDonough, Development Control Officer; • John Gibson, Principal Environmental Health Officer; • Neil Chadwick, Licensing Officer; • Dave Penman, Scrutiny Officer.
The general views from the various discussions with Members and Officers are summarised below:
Audit Committee
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.