Approved 1. That the option of setting up a Local Authority Wholly Owned Company is not pursued at this time and that an in-house Building Control service be retained 2. That the Idox software is procured and financed from the Invest to Save Reserve and repaid over a period of 5 years.
Word for word from the decision North Kesteven published for this meeting.Source: democracy.n-kesteven.gov.uk
To consider the option for an ‘arms length’ Building Control service; To consider the software needs of the service; To consider the financial position of the service.
Summary
1. An ‘Arms Length’ Building Control Service
At its meeting on 31 March 2011 the Executive Board decided to retain an in-house Building Control service, following the failure of a number of ‘shared service’ initiatives that had been considered over a period of a number of years.
However, it was agreed that the option of moving to an ‘arms length’ service (a Local Authority Wholly Owned Company - LAWOC) would be considered, and that a report would be brought to Policy Board regarding this option by March 2012. A report on the subject is attached as Appendix 1.
It is considered that this option does not present significant advantages at this time for a number of reasons:
• The small size of the unit, and the limited potential for trading, compared to the costs of establishing the LAWOC. Examples of areas where this has been done are in much larger Local Authorities; • Lack of in-house expertise in managing a private sector concern; • The LAWOC would not offer the opportunity to trade on a level playing field with the private sector in relation to the fee-earning work of the unit – the rules regarding fee setting for Local Authorities would still apply; • If the LAWOC was to trade at a loss the District Council would still be liable to meet the losses.
2. Building Control Software
If the service is to remain in-house (or even if a LAWOC were to be established) there is a need for the software used by the unit to be upgraded.
It has long been recognised in the unit that the current software (Civica, previously known as Flare) is outdated and unsuitable for use. However, over the past few years it has not been appropriate to look to upgrade the software whilst options for shared services were being considered, as any move to a shared service would have had to consider software as part of its business case.
Appendix 2 gives details of the advantages of the preferred solution (Idox), along with the costs of implementation.
The costs of procuring the software can be met by increasing the fees for chargeable work to recover the cost over a period of 5 years as well as from the annual saving on licences of £3,900 when compared to the existing software.
3. Building Control financial position
Building Control is required by Regulation to ‘break even’ on the fee earning elements of its work. This is allowed to be averaged over a number of financial years. Fees are analysed each year in order, so far as possible, to achieve this, but the level of fee income is also dependent on the volume of work attracted. The service also has non-fee earning work (around 20% of the total) and thus operates at a net cost to the Council overall.
For a number of years the volume of work in Building Control has been falling due to the economic climate. In the current financial year income is currently projected to be £40,000 lower than budgeted – however a reduction in the staffing complement has saved £47,000 in compensation.
The financial position for 2010/11 to 2012/13 is summarised in the table below
2010/11 (actual) 2011/12 2012/13 (projected) (budgeted) Total £467,000 £375,000 £368,000 expenditure Total income £389,000 £340,000 £414,000 (including recharges to other services) Balance on £78,000 £41,900 -18,600 (surplus) chargeable work Net cost of £78,000 £35,000 -46,000 (surplus) service
Note – the budgeted figures for 2012/13 do not take account of costs of software procurement)
Recommendations
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.