Approved: 1. That the provision of free 360 litre recycling bins is not rolled out to the remainder of the district. 2. The implementation of a promotion campaign regarding the availability of subsidised 360 litre recycling bins. 3. That the subsidised price for 360 litre recycling bins is retained at £18.80 for the remainder of the calendar year and that the price from 01 January 2013 rises to £20 per bin. 4. That where recycling bins with significant contamination are rejected that no return visit to collect the bins is made until the next scheduled collection. 5. That the radio and media campaign regarding contamination in recycling bins is continued.
Word for word from the decision North Kesteven published for this meeting.Source: democracy.n-kesteven.gov.uk
To provide Policy Board with information on two initiatives within the waste and recycling service: • Results of the second larger recycling bin trial. • Progress of the public awareness campaign to tackle contamination in the recycling bins.
Summary
360 litre Recycling bin trial
As an initiative to investigate how to increase recycling Members approved at a meeting of Executive Board on the 13th September 2011 that a trial scheme of offering free larger recycling bins be implemented. A trial to offer a free larger 360 litre recycling bin to residents on two routes commenced. Approximately 1,700 labels were attached to bins and by the close of the application period 488 requests for an exchange had been received.
Analysis of two collections (both before and after the trial) revealed that a total 3.9 tonnes additional recycling was collected from the two routes. This would equate to: • Approximately 51 tonnes for these two routes in a full year; • Approximately 1,000 tonnes for the entire 40 routes (assuming similar take up of bins in the rest of the District if the scheme was rolled out; • An increase of around 2.2% in the headline recycling rate (based on 2010/2011 performance).
The results of the trial were reported back to Policy Board on the 22nd March 2012 after which Officers were asked to undertake a further trial. Members wished for an “urban” area to be chosen so a route in Sleaford was selected.
During the summer the trial was repeated on route 15 in Sleaford. Approximately 1,300 properties received a label inviting them to exchange for free their existing 240 litre recycling bin for a 360 litre recycling bin. By the close of the application period 190 requests had been received.
Analysis of impact
The analysis of the tonnage that was undertaken for the first trial was easy as each route was compared like for like. The difficulty Officers have in presenting the tonnage data for the second trial is the impact of the relief arrangements that came into effect on the 2nd June. From this date the vehicle collecting route 15, together with the 3 other recycling routes on that day, receives help collecting part of its route so therefore the direct tonnage cannot be compared.
In order to provide some comparable data Officers have had to analyse the data from all five recycling vehicles (including the relief vehicle) – see table below.
Date Tonnage (before) Date Tonnage (after) Difference 5th April 51.08 14th June 49.70 19th April 51.66 28th June 51.90 3rd May 50.94 12th July 56.62 17th May 50.58 26th July 50.48 31st May 52.60 9th August 56.98 23rd August 60.44 Mean 51.37 54.35 2.98
Note – it should be borne in mind that the increase observed may be due in part to seasonal factors such as weather, holidays, the impact of the Olympics etc. Based on an the assumptions on additional capacity from the earlier trial one would anticipate that the additional capacity offered (190 bins x 120 litres) could be expected to generate no more than 1.5 tonnes of additional recycling per fortnight. The figure of almost 3 tonnes would equate to an additional 16 kg per bin – this is considered wholly unrealistic – thus supporting the argument that other factors may have influenced the outcome. It would not therefore be appropriate to extrapolate District wide performance from this latest trial.
Financial appraisal
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.