That the structural problems identified at Huston Drive North Hykeham be noted; 2. That a further report be submitted to Executive Board in June on the outcome of the consultation being undertaken and the decisions required as a result; and 3. That additional investigations should take place in all blocks of Council flats to identify whether similar concerns may exist elsewhere and that the Chief Executive be authorised to undertake any necessary immediate actions as appropriate, subject to a report back to the Executive Board.
Word for word from the decision North Kesteven published for this meeting.Source: democracy.n-kesteven.gov.uk
To consider the latest available information on the structural defects identified at Hutson Drive, North Hykeham.
Background
There are 36 flats at Hutson Drive constructed in the early to mid-1960’s. Following reports of cracking in one of the flats officer inspections were undertaken which highlighted concerns requiring the advice of specialist consultants. The Council’s structural engineers (Stirling Maynard) were instructed to undertake more detailed investigations to advice on the nature of the cracking and to recommend a way forward.
The survey work focussed on the level of deflection in the concrete floor beams in two properties and concluded that the level of deflection was unacceptable. Stirling Maynard recommended that the ceilings should be supported with ‘acro’ props as a matter of urgency in the two properties surveyed. This work was carried out and was followed by surveys of the majority of the remaining properties to assess whether the problem was more widespread. Similar concerns were identified in other flats and as such it was recommended that all ground and first floor properties should also be supported in the same way.
The Councils response was immediate and included:
establishing a multi-disciplinary project team to oversee the Council’s response;
installing ceiling supports in all ground and first floor properties;
visiting and risk assessing all occupiers of ground and first floor properties;
moving some occupants of properties into temporary accommodation as a result of these assessments;
appointing Stirling Maynard to undertake detailed investigatory work on the construction of the floors to establish the nature of the fault and the required remedial action;
informing the Homes and Communities Agency (HCA) (under the Council’s self- regulation duty); and providing regular support for the remaining occupants, agreeing compensation and re- assessing whether other relocation options should be pursued.
The initial outcome of the detailed investigatory work has now been received by the Council and the key finding is that the floor construction does not appear to match the original drawings for the properties in the Council’s possession. In particular, the load bearing tolerance of the floors is insufficient as compared with the original designs and structural repairs would always have been required at some stage to the properties.
All tenants and leaseholders of the properties have been kept informed of progress with the investigations and the outcomes which now require a long term solution. Tenants have been re-assessed on their ability to remain and given an opportunity to request a move until repairs are completed. The majority have elected to remain in their current homes and their tolerance over the level of inconvenience has been appreciated by all those involved in the response.
Officers have been working with Stirling Maynard to design a repairs solution. The preferred solution is based on fitting reinforced beams under each ceiling. It is acknowledged that this would be a very significant amount of work which will require tenants to move out of their properties for the duration of the works. As such it is considered that a requirement for consultation with tenants under Section 105 of the Housing Act 1985 applies and that the outcome of this process is considered by the Executive Board before a decision is made to proceed. It is suggested that this process would be concluded by the June meeting. At the same time a formal statutory consultation will take place with leaseholders which will also be reported back to the June meeting.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.