Recommended to Council: 1. That additional funding of £310,000 be vired from the unallocated New Build budget 2015/16 to allow for the works required at Hutson Drive, North Hykeham and St John’s Square Bracebridge Heath, to be funded from the major repairs reserve. The budget be profiled as detailed in the report. 2. That additional revenue funding of £44,800 for 2015/16 and a new Revenue Budget for 2016/17 be approved of £49,400 3. To note that a Value Engineering exercise will be undertaken with the Councils appointed Consultant Engineers and the current lowest tenderer to establish if savings to the tendered price for the works at Hutson Drive North Hykeham can be made. 4. That works are permitted to commence at Hutson Drive North Hykeham as per the previously published programme from within the existing available budget and that the proposed virement support to the original budget be made available to complete the repairs to the St Johns flats commencing in February 2016. 5. That a delegated authority is given to the Chief Executive, following consultation with the Leader of the Council, to agree the final payment by leaseholders taking into account the projected cost of the work.
Word for word from the decision North Kesteven published for this meeting.Source: democracy.n-kesteven.gov.uk
To update the Policy Board on the latest available information relating to the projected structural improvement costs to flats at Hutson Drive, North Hykeham and to incorporate the tender costs into an overall project delivery budget to allow the remedial works at both Hutson Drive and St Johns Square Bracebridge Heath to commence in 2015/16 with completion in 2016/17.
To seek approval from Executive Board and then Full Council, to vire a further £310,000 from within the approved 15/16 unallocated new build budget, this is to be funded from a draw down from the Major Repairs Reserve (MRR).
To seek approval from Executive Board to increase the revenue budget for this scheme by £44,800 in 2015/16 from £154,000 to £199,400 and also approve a revenue budget of £49,400 in 2016/17
Background
A report presented to Executive Board on 4th June 2015 provided information and approved a budget of £990,000 relating to the projected structural improvement costs to flats at Hutson Drive, North Hykeham and St Johns Close Bracebridge Heath. A subsequent Executive Board report was approved to profile the budget £490,000 in 2015/16 and £500,000 in 2016/17.
At the same Executive Board meeting a Revenue budget of £154,600 ( £145,000 plus £9,600 specifically for compensation was approved for 2015/16 to cover costs that are not deemed capital expenditure e.g. compensation payments and decant costs.
Since the June report the Councils consulting Engineers, Stirling Maynard, have developed a proposal designed to ensure the long term stability of the structures which will allow re-occupation of the flats with the minimum impact on residents. The existing low floor to ceiling heights restricted the structural work options available, with the final design influenced by a tenant consultation exercise. Further investigations carried out since the June report have identified that work to provide a new foundation to the central spine wall of the properties will now also be required.
Tender Exercise
Following advice from Lincolnshire Procurement a tender exercise has been undertaken which invited contractors contained within the Lincolnshire New Build Framework. During the tender period tenderers were offered the opportunity to visit the Hutson Drive flats to fully establish the requirements of the repair specification. Of the six tenderers invited, two companies submitted tender prices:-
D Brown Building Contractors - £ 740,519 Keir Services £856,542
The original budget approved for the capital works at both Hutson Drive and St Johns Square totalled £990,000.
As a proportion of the overall budget, it had been anticipated that the cost of the Hutson element of the repairs would be £566,000. As can be seen the submitted tender sum for Hutson exceeds the proportional budget by £174,000.
Value Engineering
In order to ensure that the property repairs are undertaken as soon as possible the Councils consultant Engineers provided a tender package based on information known at the time.
Further design evaluation carried out during the tender period has suggested there may be alternative solutions to provide support to the spine wall of the properties which will reduce the need to carry out the considerable structural underpinning.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.