That the definitions at higher and middle rate be amended from the engine size of the vehicle driven to: o Higher: Field role where a car is an essential requirement to fulfil the role. o Middle: Required to attend meetings at locations not suited to public transport and to ensure time efficiency 2. That colleagues should be served with notice of the change by 01.07.15; and 3. That the changes should take effect from 1 st April 2016 for existing colleagues, with no buy-out. 1. That the definitions at higher and middle rate be amended from the engine size of the vehicle driven to: o Higher: Field role where a car is an essential requirement to fulfil the role. o Middle: Required to attend meetings at locations not suited to public transport and to ensure time efficiency 2. That colleagues should be served with notice of the change by 01.07.15; and 3. That the changes should take effect from 1 st April 2016 for existing colleagues, with no buy-out. Actions: Christine Cooper Russell Stone
Word for word from the decision North Kesteven published for this meeting.Source: democracy.n-kesteven.gov.uk
The Essential Car Allowance has been reviewed and it is proposed changes to the definitions at higher and middle rate are implemented.
Summary The proposed changes to definitions at higher and middle rate are to move from the engine size of the vehicle driven to; o Higher: Field role where a car is an essential requirement to fulfil the role. o Middle: Required to attend meetings at locations not suited to public transport and to ensure time efficiency o The rates of mileage are as follows and will be unchanged: Higher Middle Difference Car Allowance £1239 £963 £276 Mileage 50.5p 40.9p 9.6p However, some colleagues will reduce from Higher to Middle rates.
The below table shows a summary of who is affected and how: Total Union Non-union colleagues members affected Stay the same 109 51 58 Reduce to middle rate 33 10 23 Move to middle rate 7 2 5 from casual
Appendix 1 shows the union consultation responses and responses to those comments. A discussion with the unions has ensured resolution.
The options available now are: o Do nothing. Keep the definitions as they are and make no change to eligibility criteria. o Move to the new definitions effective from 01.07.15, communicating the change with all colleagues. To affect this change, it has been suggested a lump sum is appropriate for those colleagues who are reducing from high to middle band. NKDC have a protected pay criteria of 1 year but it may be felt appropriate due to the lesser impact to reduce this to 6 months but this will need to be further discussed with the unions once a proposal is agreed. o Move to the new definitions from 01.01.16 with no buyout as colleagues will have had over 6 months’ notice of the change to terms and conditions. o Move to the new definitions from 01.04.16 with no buyout as this starts the new financial year with a reduced cost.
Any new starters from 1st July 2015 will be placed on the new mileage rates with immediate effect.
Recommendations 1. The preferred option is to move to the new definitions from 1st April 2016 with no buyout and start financial savings from this date, serving colleagues with notice of the change by 01.07.15. IMPLICATIONS Relationship to Community Strategy Not applicable.
Customer Impacts Customer service will continue to be excellent as colleagues are defined the correct essential car allowance dependent on their actual job role.
Financial Impacts Savings will commence from April 2016 at approximately £16,000 per annum.
Impact on Performance and data quality No applicable.
Human Resources Contract amendments will be required for all essential car users and any HR Policies amended to also reflect this change.
Sustainability Impact Assessment Using the job role requirement, rather than car engine size, fits with the Councils sustainability priority.
Equality Impact Assessment No issues
Value for Money To pay car allowance relative to the job role will justify value for money more effectively.
Risk Management No issues
Legal Considerations No issues.
Ethics and Probity No issues
Communications All colleagues within the council must be communicated with to understand the changes and how they will affect them. They have been initially informed as part of the formal consultation with unions and any queries have been resolved. REASON FOR RECOMMENDATION
OTHER OPTIONS CONSIDERED
APPENDIX NO. TITLE 1. Formal consultation response summary and feedback. 2.
BACKGROUND PAPERS The following background papers within Section 100D of the Local Government Act 1972 were used in the preparation of this report but if none were used then please state Title Location of Background Papers
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.