CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Nottingham City Council
Executive Board, Thursday 28 April 2022 at 3.15pm

External Review of Housing Financial Management and Council Response

Noted Executive 3 papers

Executive Board noted this item on Thursday 28 April 2022. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item130

Resolved

Resolved to: (1) receive and note the Key Findings Report from Richard Penn following his independent investigation (2) receive and note the further work undertaken by CIPFA (including appendices relating to workstreams A and B) (3) note that the current organisational arrangements between the NCC and NCH do not provide officers sufficient assurance that the HRA ring fence can be adequately protected under existing arrangements, and in turn councillors have been unable to gain the required level of assurance in relation to the HRA ring fence (4) authorise the Corporate Director of Finance and Resources and Section 151 Officer, following the receipt of further work from CIPFA outlined in the report, to seek a Ministerial Direction from government to repay in aggregate up to £40 million from the General Fund to the HRA (subject to any mitigations to reduce this sum) (5) note the options and key lines of enquiry for funding the rectification of the breach to the HRA ring fence and to note that there will be an impact on the 2022/23 – 2025/26 MTFP which will be reported to Executive Board and/or Full Council in due course (6) approve, the serving of a 12 months’ Notice to Terminate on NCH in respect of its housing functions and to take over direct management of council housing from the expiry of that notice period or sooner by agreement (7) note that there will be engagement with tenants and leaseholders to ensure a smooth transition and continuity of service about ongoing service provision. This will include how the voice of tenants will be heard by Nottingham City Council as the landlord after the service is brought under direct control (8) authorise the Corporate Director of Growth and City Development to take such steps as may be necessary to deliver an effective transfer of housing management functions back to the Council, in consultation with the Portfolio Holder for Housing, Corporate Director of Finance and Resources and Section 151 Officer and Director of Legal and Governance and Monitoring Officer. This to include, amongst other things, arrangements for the protection of employment rights for NCH staff through TUPE transfer, arrangements for effective tenant and leaseholder engagement and empowerment in the decision making about services, and the transfer of relevant third party contracts and any other relevant arrangements as may be necessary to support an effective transition. (9) authorise the Corporate Director of Growth and City Development to take such steps as may be necessary to affect such short term and practical arrangements in relation to the governance arrangements of NCH to facilitate an effective transition, in consultation with the Portfolio Holder for Housing, Corporate Director for Finance and Resources and Section 151 Officer, the Corporate Director of Resident Services (in their capacity as the shareholder representative for NCH) and Director for Legal and Governance and Monitoring Officer, including positive liaison with the NCH Board and effecting any changes that may be necessary to the Articles of Association of NCH and Board appointments (10) delegate to the Corporate Director of Growth and City Development a provisional budget of £750,000 to deliver on the above recommendations from HRA funds, as a proper use of those funds, in consultation with the Portfolio Holder for Housing, Corporate Director for Finance and Resources and Section 151 Officer and Director for Legal and Governance and Monitoring Officer (11) note that a report is brought back to Executive Board and subsequently to Full Council to identify arrangements for a greater level of councillor engagement in overview and scrutiny arrangements for policy development, priority setting and holding to account for performance in relation to housing management matters, following the return of management of the council’s housing stock to the council (12) note that the Overview and Scrutiny Committee will receive update reports to enable the implementation plan and consultation arrangements to be reviewed during the transition through the Council’s scrutiny arrangements. · Reasons for the decisions To ensure robust, swift and decisive action to address acts of unlawfulness in relation to breaches of the HRA ring fence by the Council including through its arrangements with NCH. To provide timely assurance to all stakeholders including members, tenants, taxpayers, the Improvement and Assurance Board and government that the issues that have been identified are accepted by the Council and that appropriate action will be taken urgently to address them. · Other Options Considered An alternative approach would be to retain NCH as an Arms Length Management Organisation and to explore with its management the necessary improvements that the Council requires to be made. This approach has been rejected as the governance and financial controls are not fit for purpose. CIPFA have advised that they have seen no evidence from NCH of an appetite to ring-fence HRA funding and expenditure from its non-HRA activities, and moreover NCH considers that it has no obligation to ring fence HRA funds. Given the seriousness of the issue and gravity of the situation that the Council faces, in the light of evidence received this alternative approach is considered untenable and has been rejected.
Word for word from the decision Nottingham published for this meeting. Source: committee.nottinghamcity.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Nottingham's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Executive Board

Subject: External Review of Housing Financial Management and Council Response Corporate Director(s)/Director(s): Sajeeda Rose, Corporate Director, Growth and City Development Portfolio Holder(s): Cllr. Linda Woodings Report author and Kevin Lowry Interim Director of Housing contact details: Other colleagues who Clive Heaphy, Corporate Director, Finance and Resources have provided input: Beth Brown, Head of Legal and Governance Subject to call-in: Yes No Key Decision: Yes No Criteria for Key Decision: (a) Expenditure Income Savings of £750,000 or more taking account of the overall impact of the decision and/or (b) Significant impact on communities living or working in two or more wards in the City Yes No Type of expenditure: Revenue Capital If Capital, provide the date considered by Capital Board Date: Total value of the decision: £750k Wards affected: All Date of consultation with Portfolio Holder(s): 23 April 2022 Relevant Council Plan Key Outcome: Clean and Connected Communities Keeping Nottingham Working Carbon Neutral by 2028 Safer Nottingham Child-Friendly Nottingham Healthy and Inclusive Keeping Nottingham Moving Improve the City Centre Better Housing Financial Stability Serving People Well Summary of issues (including benefits to citizens/service users):

Nottingham City Council (NCC) is responsible for council housing and the operation of the Housing Revenue Account (HRA). These responsibilities are outlined in legislation (principally the Local Government and Housing Act 1989 and subsequent amendments) and any guidelines on operation of the HRA from Government. This responsibility cannot be delegated.

Housing Management and Maintenance functions can be delegated and since 2005 NCC has arranged that Nottingham City Homes (NCH) manage HRA funds on behalf of, and under the control of NCC. NCH is a wholly owned Company and a Partnership Agreement is in place covering working arrangements between the NCC and NCH. NCH acts as an Arms’ Length Management Organisation (ALMO) and was originally set up to access Decent Homes Funding. It is recognised that beyond investment to achieve decent homes standards, NCH has had success in improving core housing services. NCH have achieved improvements to housing stock, including the response to fire safety following Grenfell and home insulation works. The Council will want to build on the improvements made to date in terms of housing quality and safety standards.

Page 1 of 19 HRA funds are for the benefit of the council’s tenants and leaseholders and are funded primarily by rents and service charges. The HRA is a strictly ring-fenced account of the General Fund (GF) for specific purposes set out in the legislation and guidelines.

A review commissioned by the Council has identified that NCC, including through its arrangements with NCH, has acted unlawfully in relation to breaches of the HRA Ring Fence.

The issue was previously reported to and considered at an Extraordinary meeting of Full Council on 4 January 2022. Amongst other actions agreed, two further reports were commissioned. This paper addresses key points arising from the findings of these two reports by an independent investigator, Richard Penn and CIPFA (Charted Institute of Public Finance and Accountancy).

The further work commissioned from Richard Penn and CIPFA, following the identification of initial breaches, has identified the causes of the unlawfulness and how it came about and that the scale of unlawful use of funds diverted away from the HRA is greater than first identified.

CIPFA’s initial report identified the unlawful treatment by NCC of the NCH ‘management fee rebate’ which was valued at £14.367m. CIPFA’s additional work has uncovered a further sum of up to £25.759m of detected and assessed issues taking the overall scale of the issue of up to £40.126m. This comprises:

i) Issues raised in the original report concerning the unlawful treatment by NCC of NCH ‘management fee rebates of £14.367m (35.8% of the total).

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
External Review of Housing Financial Management and Council ResponseReport 260 KB DownloadRead as text
PDF
Key Findings Report for Nottingham City CouncilReport 210 KB Download
PDF
NCC HRA Phase 2 Final Report 260422 (002): FINALReport 1.5 MB Download

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

7 of 17 attended
DM
Councillor David MellenChair, present
SL
Councillor Sally LongfordVice Chair, present
CB
Councillor Cheryl BarnardCommittee Member, apologies (unwell)
EC
Councillor Eunice Campbell-ClarkCommittee Member, apologies (personal reasons)
RH
Councillor Rosemary HealyCommittee Member, apologies (on leave)
NK
Councillor Neghat KhanCommittee Member, present
AW
Councillor Adele WilliamsCommittee Member, present
SW
Councillor Sam WebsterCommittee Member, present
LW
Councillor Linda WoodingsCommittee Member, apologies (council business)
KC
Councillor Kevin ClarkeNon-voting, present
AR
Councillor Andrew RuleNon-voting, present
CH
Clive HeaphyOfficer, in attendance

All 17 on the meeting page

More from Nottingham Executive Board

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
22 Sep 2026 Corporate Plan Delivery – Tranche 3Resolved to: (1) approve the proposals included within the paper; (2) delegate authority to the Section 151 Officer t... Approved Open
22 Sep 2026 Quarter 1 (Q1) Delivery Plan Performance ReportResolved to: (1) note the Q1 Delivery Plan Performance Update presented at Appendix A; (2) receive future updates of ... Noted Open
22 Sep 2026 Adult Social Care Strategy - Enabling Gloriously Ordinary LivesResolved to: (1) endorse, approve and adopt the Adult Social Care Strategy – Enabling Gloriously Ordinary lives 2026-... Approved Open
22 Sep 2026 HRA funded capital adaptations - Stairlifts, Step lifts, through-floor lifts and hoistsResolved to: (1) approve the request to procure and award a framework for HRA Specialist Equipment – mechanical; stai... Approved Open
22 Sep 2026 Recommissioning of Changing Futures Services in Nottingham - Key DecisionResolved to: (1) note that the Director of Public Health will vary the contract for the Changing Futures Main Deliver... Approved Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies