Resolved
(1) to approve the commencement of the fit-out works for the new project; (2) to approve the funding for the fit-out works from the agreed capital programme; (3) to delegate authority to the Corporate Director for Resident Services to enter into a contract to deliver the fit-out works, and to procure any specific purchases required in relation to the fit-out in accordance with the Council’s Contract Procedure Rules. · Reasons for the decision The fit-out of the replacement Nottingham Central Library is a key foundation stone for the broader regeneration and activation of the Broadmarsh development. The Central Library will also act as a significant draw and destination building for one of the largest regeneration schemes taking place in the city. · Other options considered To not provide a Central Library service: this would reduce development costs, but the Council would be open to judicial challenge as to whether it was fulfilling its statutory responsibility for providing a comprehensive Library Service. The Libraries Needs Assessment, currently out for consultation, clearly showed a high usage of the Central Library as part of the city’s overall library provision. Its role demonstrated that it was an essential part of the development of the Service and a key holder of collections and resources that help support the Neighbourhood and Community Library offer. Removal of the Central Library provision would break the agreed working protocol between the Nottingham City and Nottinghamshire County Councils. This agreement shares responsibility for provision of the City and County Archives and a Central Library Service provision for Nottingham and Nottinghamshire. For these reasons, this option is rejected. To refurbish the existing Angel Row site: the current condition of Angel Row is poor. In light of its failing drainage and mechanical, electrical and asbestos issues, the cost of refurbishment would be on par with the replacement costs for a Library at the Broadmarsh complex. A sale has been agreed for the site that will make a significant capital receipt towards the capital programme. If the existing site is retained for the Central Library, the capital receipt would not be available and the regeneration opportunity for the development of the Angel Row site and the surrounding area would be lost. For these reasons, this option is rejected. To reduce and further sub-divide the current Library space designated within the Broadmarsh complex in order to reduce development costs: the space allocated within the Broadmarsh complex has been designed specifically for the replacement Central Library, including (but not limited to) structural loadings, lift location and key mechanical and electrical infrastructure. Sub-dividing the space would be very difficult and costly to undertake at this point, now that the building has been built and modified for the replacement Library. Making the Library smaller would compromise the collections and material that the Central Library is expected to hold and would give rise to an ongoing need for further off-site storage. This off site storage would need to be managed and run to help support book stock and other specialist material required. For these reasons, this option is rejected. To convert Loxley House and incorporate the Central Library within this building: the design and floor loadings of Loxley House do not lend themselves to an easy conversion to accommodate the replacement Central Library. Detailed designs, structural loading calculations, acoustic management and mechanical and electrical studies would need to be commissioned to determine its viability and provide an understanding of potential costs. This work would conflict with letting and partnering agreements currently ongoing and being pursued with Loxley House by the Council. This work would also further delay the opening of Central Library to the public by at least one year. For these reasons, this option is rejected.