Resolved
Resolved to: (1) Approve the transformation principles for future delivery of the library service as set out in Appendix 1 to the report (“The Next Chapter Nottingham City Council Library Service Transformation, Phase 2 Findings Report, Part 2, REVISED Recommendations December 2022”) (2) Agree to the retention of Aspley Library as a publicly accessible library but redesign the space to enable the building to become a stock distribution hub and base for outreach services as detailed in Section 5.1 3 of the report. (3) Agree, as an alternative to the library closures, to a change of opening hours across the network. This will result in a reduction in service, the implications of which were set out in section 5.2 & Appendix 1 to the report. (4) Note that the proposals, if approved, will be implemented by the Corporate Director for Communities, Environment and Resident Services in accordance with delegation 18 of the Constitution. · Reasons for decision: The recommendations consider feedback given by citizens and stakeholders, including further analysis of the proposals around the closure of three libraries, in particular the following themes: o Importance of Libraries o Use of Technology - The majority said that they would welcome the use of technology as long as physical books and library buildings remain. o Partnerships - The majority were in support of partnership work. o Shared Spaces - Most respondents understood the opportunity of how council services and buildings could co-locate and make efficiencies through the use of shared spaces. o Library Closure Proposals - The majority of responses showed disagreement with the proposals. Emerging factors, concerns raised during the consultation and analysis of new information has raised further questions affecting both the Council and its residents that needed to be considered alongside the responses and data already collected. This changing environment, and the new information established are recognised in the decisions taken. The key considerations included: o Library financial position - To date a saving of £0.154m has been achieved by a staffing restructure within the service. This has enabled the consideration of other options to achieve the remaining saving required of £0.079m. o Library Performance - The emerging picture of the use of libraries has been heavily influenced by the pandemic. Libraries are back to providing many of their services in person however, there has been a shift towards a more blended service. o The library sector has also been identified as playing a central role in meeting the needs of individuals and communities who may be struggling to overcome the impact of the pandemic and the high cost of living. · Other options considered and rejected: Targeted reduction in opening hours and the closure of 1 library: Basford or Radford-Lenton Library This option would see a small targeted reduction in opening hours across the network which would release a potential saving of £ 36K, and would involve a realignment of core hours to be between 9am and 6pm across the whole community network. In addition this would see the full closure of either Radford Lenton or Basford Library making up the remaining saving requirement Benefits and impacts/considerations for closing or retaining Basford or Radford Lenton Libraries is set out below: Radford Lenton Library Basford Library • Catchment overlap with Hyson Green and Central Library • 5,024 households (692 in IMD worst 20%) and 778 library users would have no library provision within a 20 min walk if closed • Annual visits: 19/20: 7,920 pre covid vs 22/23 : 6,986 post covid (est. on 6 month actuals) • Operating cost: £41k with estimate £39k maintenance liabilities • Investment has recently taken place at Radford-Lenton Library making the building more sustainable with reduced maintenance costs longer term • Large space at the back of building provides wider opportunities for community activity and partnership development • Safeguards a community facility in the Radford & Lenton area which has already seen the closure of John Carroll Leisure Centre • University of Nottingham Volunteer Coordinator role – discussions taking place to use library as a base • Catchment overlap with Aspley, Bulwell Riverside, Sherwood Libraries • 3,178 households (1,845 in IMD worst 20%) and 544 library users would have no library provision within a 20 min walk if closed • Annual visits: 19/20: 22,680 pre- covid 22/23:10,174 post covid (est. on 6 month actuals) • Operating cost: £37K with estimate £90k maintenance liabilities • Building design limits potential longer term development but opportunity for direct link to Vernon Park outdoor space with capital investment • Community partnership potential explored, but with no emerging opportunities Continue with current network of 15 Libraries with no operational changes This would see no operational changes to the current library network but would require the completion of investment in the New Central and Sherwood Libraries. However, this option is not considered sustainable for the network size current level of use or for providing an effective and efficient service in the long term. Benefits No immediate change to the current provision in terms of access for citizens. Impacts / Considerations · The saving target would not be achieved without significant further reduction in opening hours, staffing, book resources and library programming and activity · There would be investment required and unresolved maintenance liabilities on some of the older libraries. · This does not deliver a modern agile service, and has limited ability to redirect and target resources to changing community need. L ibraries Transformation as originally proposed with the closure of 3 libraries The original proposals outlined were developed to create a more agile modernised sustainable service whilst retaining a strong community focus. This recognises the need to maximise the use of technology and to work in collaboration with other community partners around delivery of neighbourhood services. Benefits · Would achieve an additional saving of £58K over and above the £79K saving gap required. · Enables the transformation of the service as outlined in the report. · Delivers savings over the next three years with further potential sustainable reductions being able to be considered as the programme progresses. · Ensures that the delivery network mirrors other providers with stronger performance against our benchmarked CIPFA local authority comparators. · Would remove potential maintenance liabilities on older building stock needing significant repair. · Would release potential for sale of sites to contribute a receipt back to the authority which can be used for reinvestment. Impacts / Considerations: · Does not consider consultation feedback and concerns raised by communities and stakeholders · Reduced service provision within the most deprived areas of the City · May limit the opportunity to effectively support communities with emerging issues from post pandemic and cost of living crisis · Reputation management in terms the potential closure of three library service points. · Alignment required to a Council wide programme looking at community assets and on other decisions being made on services and facilities in communities. · Displacement of current users to other neighbouring libraries · Realignment of local activities affected by closures to other libraries in the network Community/Volunteer run Neighbourhood Libraries This would see neighbourhood libraries partially or fully managed by community volunteers. A number of authorities have followed this route with varying success. Where authorities have been successful this has often been as a result of significant investment in community capacity building a sustainable volunteer network developed over a 3-4 year period. Benefits: · Engages citizens directly in providing services in the city. · Reduce paid staff costs for the service. Impacts / Considerations · Limited appetite for resident to run the library service. Many residents feel that that libraries should be run by the authority with paid specialist staff. · Resource and investment required for the development of, and ongoing support and management of volunteers · Any savings achieved through the building a sustainable volunteer network and community capacity are unlikely to be achieved with the MTFP timeframe · Agreements need to be reached around who retains the responsibility for the liabilities of buildings and provision of resources. · Loss of specialist staff skills and resources. · Staff redundancies and associated costs