Item34
Resolved
Resolved to (1) declare the site known as ‘Land & Buildings situated at Pavilion Road and Trentside and 672 sq. yards or thereabouts, Trentside , West Bridgford, Nottingham’ surplus to the Property Trading Account and make the property available for disposal. (2) delegate approval of the final sale terms (Heads of Terms) for the freehold sale of the site to the Corporate Director for Growth and City Development in consultation with the Corporate Director of Finance and Resources (s151 Officer) and in consultation with the Leader and Deputy Leader should any changes be proposed in relation to restrictive/other covenants /overage. (3) delegate the final decision to dispose of the asset to the Corporate Director for Growth & City Development in consultation with the Corporate Director of Finance and Resources (s151 officer) once all required due diligence has been satisfied. (4) To delegate the approval of any required licences/agreements/deeds to ensure completion of the sale to the Director of Economic Development & Property. Reasons for decisions: · To facilitate a sale the assets comprising ‘Land & Buildings situated at Pavilion Road and Trentside and 672 sq. yards or thereabouts, Trentside , West Bridgford, Nottingham’ will need to be declared surplus to the Property Trading Account and made available for sale on terms to be agreed and approved. If suitable terms are not agreed the assets will remain part of the Property Trading Account. · Delegating agreement of the final sale terms as documented in the Heads of Terms will allow the disposal to proceed without the need to bring a decision back to the Executive Board. Agreement will be in consultation with the s151 Officer and with the Leader and Deputy Leader should any changes be proposed in relation to restrictive/ other covenants /overage. · The final decision to sell the asset will be delegated to allow the sale to complete when all documentation has been agreed. This decision will only be made following the satisfactory conclusion of all required legal, financial, and commercial due diligence. Such due diligence will include: a. Obtaining independent valuation advice to confirm viability and that the Council has complied with its Best Consideration obligations; b. Any required financial due diligence such as anti-money laundering checks, financial viability checks, purchaser identity checks and any other required due diligence; c. Any additional finance/legal/property due diligence identified during the disposal process. · The appointment of external specialists to advise on this disposal is key to the Council ensuring the Council meets its Best Consideration obligations, completes the disposal in a timely manner if approved and ensures that all prior due diligence/risk mitigation measures have been completed satisfactorily. External appointments will extend to specialist agency advice and valuation work, externalised legal work, and specialist financial appraisal work if required. · The delegation of any required licences/agreements/deeds to the Director of Economic Development & Property has been included to ensure the disposal, if approved, progresses at pace. Other Options considered: · The Council has considered all available options which include do nothing, extend/re-gear the occupational leases and the recommended option of disposal. · Do nothing and retain the current arrangement - The option of do nothing would maintain the current landlord and tenant position. The current long lease has circa 37 years to expiry with a rental income received which is subject to upward and downward review which therefore makes it higher risk from a revenue performance perspective. · The benefits of the ‘do nothing’ option is: o Officer time will be saved by not negotiating with the tenant. o The asset becomes more valuable to the Council as the lease moves to expiry as its ability to charge a market rent becomes closer. o The Council continues to receive a rental income from the site. o Upon expiry of the lease there would be potential redevelopment/disposal options available for the Council as freehold owner although this option is in 37 years and therefore calculation of the benefit to the Council currently cannot feasibly be determined. · The risks associated with the ‘do nothing’ option: o The tenant has stated that failure to redevelop the property could adversely impact the future viability of the asset and in this scenario the tenant may not undertake the redevelopment and could ultimately look to relocate. o Relations with the tenant could breakdown which will impact the ongoing landlord & tenant relationship and may have wider implications for both parties. It is noted that the site sits outside the Nottingham City administrative boundary but the economic benefits to the city are realised. o The tenant may be unable to undertake the significant redevelopment due to funding restrictions associated with a short unexpired lease. o The Council’s revenue is dependent on tenant performance for the next circa 37 years which represents a risk to income security. o The Council could lose the opportunity to secure a longer-term lease agreement on more financially stable terms later. o The Council could lose the opportunity to secure a significant capital receipt until lease expiry if a disposal was not progressed. · Lease Re-Gear: A lease re-gear would result in the surrender of the current lease agreement and simultaneous grant of a long new lease on agreed terms. · The benefits of this option are: o A lease re-gear could potentially provide a rental income based on market values. o The longer lease would enable the tenant to draw down funding to facilitate the redevelopment of the site which would deliver economic benefits to the City. o A long lease with secure income with uplifts to market rent could be sold in the future to raise additional capital. o The Council maintains an element of control over a significant asset outside the administrative area. · The risks of this option are: o Agreement requires a willing landlord and tenant, and the tenant has made its position clear that it would only wish to proceed with acquiring the freehold interest. o If terms fail to be agreed – this would revert to the risks associated with option 1. o Locking the land into a long lease agreement means the Council’s control is limited. o Agreeing terms of a new lease which cater for re-development/wider use of the site will be complex to agree therefore taking up significant officer time and resulting in higher costs for specialists. o The value of the Council’s freehold interest would decrease significantly particularly in the event of a 99-year lease or longer being granted. o If a premium payment was negotiated the revenue pressure would need to be mitigated. o A longer lease would defer any ability for the Council to review its disposal/redevelopment options.
Word for word from the decision Nottingham published for this meeting.
Source: committee.nottinghamcity.gov.uk