Resolved
Resolved to (1) note the context, evidence, information, and findings from the library consultation set out in the Libraries Assessment Future Library Provision to 2030 Report (Appendix 1), which has led to the final recommendations for the future provision and delivery of the Library Service to 2030; (2) agree the officer recommended proposal set out in section 3 of the report in order to deliver a sustainable library service to 2030 whilst achieving the agreed MTFP budget saving for the Service of £1.524m. The savings will be allocated to the appropriate budgets where costs savings will be achieved for each affected site; (3) recognise that this level of library provision is considered to fulfil the City Council’s statutory obligations. Where additional service provision can be delivered by external partners or voluntary support, this is supplementary to the City Council’s statutory requirement; (4) actively work and engage with community and third sector partners to develop and deliver community activity and library provision for the city. Reasons for decisions: · The proposal will enable the authority to provide a sustainable library service going forward to 2030, achieving the MTFP saving agreed for the service whilst providing its statutory duty of comprehensive and efficient service. The recommendation has fully considered a range of factors including cost, usage, library performance, location, and community need, as well feedback from an extensive consultation process regarding the future delivery of the service. Other options considered: · In reaching the recommendations, a range of alternative options were considered, none of which were ultimately taken forward: o Option 1 Maintain Current Library Network Recommendations § Benefits: No immediate changes to access § Impacts: Fails to meet budget savings, requires costly maintenance, does not support a modern, agile service and align to Best Value and the Duties and Powers review previously undertaken. o Option 2 Consultation Proposal § Benefits: Achieves budget savings, retains a core network, meets statutory duties, eliminates some maintenance liabilities. Allows for potential community asset transfer. § Impacts: Does not respond to concerns raised by citizens and stakeholders from the consultation in relation to operational hours and the longer-term potential to build back. o Option 3 Further Reduced Network § Benefits: Achieves savings through reduction of buildings without reducing opening hours for the remaining library network, retains a modern efficient network of quality facilities and with skilled staff. Enables capital receipts from asset sales. § Impacts: Reduces household access to libraries (below 70% of households would be withing a 20 min walk of a library), risks not meeting residents needs, statutory duty and legal challenges. Diminishes Nottingham’s standing of library points per 1,000 population compared to all other core cities. o Option 4 Community/ Volunteer Run Libraries § Benefits: Engages citizens and reduces staff costs. § Impacts: Low resident interest in managing libraries, long setup times, unresolved liability issues and limited cost savings. o Option 5 Outsource to a Third-Party Provider § Benefits: Potential for cost efficiencies through economies of scale and opportunity to transfer risks and liabilities of buildings and service delivery. § Impacts: Required detailed appraisal and procurement work, unlikely to meet savings targets on time, involves staff transfers (TUPE).