Resolved
Resolved to (1) make the site known as the Broad Marsh Development site surplus to all Council requirements; (2) make the surplus Broad Marsh Development site available for sale on the terms set out in the Heads of Terms in the Exempt Appendix; (3) delegate approval of the final Heads of Terms for sale, save for the sale price, to the Corporate Director for Growth & City Development; (4) delegate approval of the final sale price to the Corporate Director for Growth & City Development in consultation with the S151 Officer. If the final sale price varies by more than £750K the decision will revert to the Executive Board/Leaders Key Decision; (5) approve the Council entering into an agreement which governs the future relationship between the vendor and purchaser (Memorandum of Understanding); (6) note that this disposal is an ‘off-market’ disposal which has been agreed in line with the Council’s adopted Disposals Policy. Reasons for decisions: · The Council has, alongside its appointed agents, undertaken a full analysis of the disposal options available and several scenarios have been considered and set out in the exempt appendix. The proposed sale as set out in the Heads of Terms contained in the exempt appendix is recommended as the best way to proceed to ensure the timely and successful re-development of the site as well as delivery of a capital receipt to the Council. It is recognised that the Council is not able financially to deliver this development. · To allow Officers to progress a sale at pace. The proposed terms of the sale as set out in the exempt appendix are substantially agreed with only minor matters to be finalised. Given the timeframe for completion of this matter it would not be an efficient use of time to bring a decision back to the Executive Board. · It is recognised that this is a significant disposal in terms of the capital receipt and therefore any variation to the final sale price will be approved by the Corporate Director for Growth & City Development in consultation with the S151 Officer. If the variation is outside the approval level of the Corporate Directors a decision will be taken back to the Executive via the most appropriate route given that this transaction is scheduled to complete in the 2024-25 financial year. · Nottingham City Council as landowner and Local Authority has actively promoted the redevelopment of the Broad Marsh area for several years and has delivered significant progress through its own resources and funds and by securing external grants. This work will continue with the purchaser to ensure the successfully delivery of the redevelopment project. · In December 2024, the East Midlands Combined County Authority (EMCCA) granted stage one approval to £3.3 million of funding towards the Broad Marsh project. The funding is part of EMCCA’s Investment Fund which grants funding to projects which will make an impact in the region by investing in homes, jobs, manufacturing, clean energy creation and greener spaces. The Broad Marsh project is being actively supported by EMCCA due to the positive contribution it will make towards its Strategic & Investment Framework which sets out the vision for the region. The project will also support the East Midlands Inclusive Growth Strategy which guides how the EMCCA invests a £4 billion funding pot to help drive a thriving economy across Derby and Derbyshire, Nottingham and Nottinghamshire. The £3 million investment into Broad Marsh will enable additional demolition to be undertaken at an early stage which will remove holding liabilities associated with the site. Other options considered: · Do Nothing – this option was rejected due to the significant cost of holding the site vacant being incurred by the Council and the very likely risk that these costs would increase substantially soon. A do-nothing option would result in no progress in terms of the redevelopment of the site which goes against the work completed by the Council on developing a vision and master plan. A do-nothing scenario would damage stakeholder relationships particularly with the Citizens of Nottingham, East Midlands Combined County Authority and the Nottingham University Hospitals Trust who have a significant part to play in the development of the site. · Delivery by the Council – this option would see the Council deliver the proposed regeneration project from planning to construction. This is a substantial undertaking which would require significant capital funds, and a skill set which is not held within the Council’s teams. The Council would benefit from profit created by the site, but it would also carry all risk associated with the development. Given the Council’s current resource and financial restrictions, this option is not deliverable and has been rejected. · Joint Venture Type Agreement – these options would see the Council partnering with an organisation to facilitate the delivery of the master plan. Responsibilities for progressing various aspects of the development would lie with defined stakeholders. This option would see the Council carrying medium to high risk in terms of cost, control, planning risk, resource risk, speed, and market appetite. This option was rejected due to the time and cost associated with securing a partner and the current holding cost liabilities require the authority to act quickly to reduce that risk and this option would see that burden being retained for a longer period.