Termination of Current Lease and Grant of Tenancy at Will - 9 -15 Bridge Street – KEY/23FEB26/04
ApprovedExecutive1 paper
AI summaryPeterborough Cabinet approves surrender of the existing lease and grant of a Tenancy at Will at 9-15 Bridge Street to retain the Middleton's pub after the operator entered administration in November 2025.
Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeApprovedSurrender of current lease and new short-term letting approved
MoneyRent below best considerationAggregate rental may exceed £250,000 threshold
What happens nextGrant Tenancy at WillTerms set out in Exempt Annex
Who it affects9-15 Bridge Street, Middleton'sCommercial unit on the main shopping street
What was decided
Cabinet approved the surrender of the current lease at 9-15 Bridge Street and the grant of a new Tenancy at Will on the terms in the Exempt Annex. Report P9
Cabinet noted the proposed rent is below best consideration reasonably obtainable and accepted the circumstances that require this. Report P8, 5.3
Cabinet reviewed the background that led officers to recommend the new arrangement. Report P7
Why
The current tenant, Gastro Pubs Limited trading as Middleton's, entered administration on 14 November 2025, requiring a revised letting arrangement. Report P3, 2.1
A governance review and the Monitoring Officer advised that the aggregate rental value over the full contractual term should determine the approval route, and that transactions potentially failing the best consideration test should go to Cabinet. Report P1, 2.3, 2.4, 4.1
What happens next
Officers will proceed to surrender the existing lease and grant the Tenancy at Will to the administrator on the agreed terms. Report 9.2, 9.3
The Council will then seek a longer-term letting for the premises through the open market. Report 9.3, 5.3
The money
£250,000 Aggregate rental threshold above which Cabinet approval is required Report P1, P13
Options considered
Rejected: Take no action. Risk of lease being disclaimed, leaving a vacant prominent high street unit with loss of income and rising maintenance liability Report P47, 9.1
Chosen: Approve a new Tenancy at Will. Keeps the premises occupied, maintains activity on Bridge Street, and protects income while a long-term letting is sought Report P49, 9.2, 9.3, 5.1
Implications
Legal: Tenancy at Will is treated as a short-term disposal under section 123 of the Local Government Act 1972, exempting it from the best consideration duty, though the Council has chosen to apply the test in policy. Report 7.1, 7.5, 7.6
Financial: The proposed rent is below best consideration reasonably obtainable and is presented on a cost mitigation basis ahead of a future long-term letting. Report 5.3, 7.2
Legal: All best consideration decisions and reasoning must be fully evidenced and documented to be defensible. Report 7.4
Equalities: No Equality Impact Assessment was undertaken as the report covers governance arrangements for property transactions and does not give rise to equality impacts. Report 8.1
Climate: No carbon impacts are anticipated, as the use of the property and tenant are not changing. Report 3.2
Who and where
Gastro Pubs Limited (trading as Middleton's), the current tenant in administration Report 2.1
Bridge Street shoppers and nearby businesses Report 5.2, 9.3
Peterborough City Council as landlord and income recipient Report 3.1, 5.1
Timeline
14 November 2025: Gastro Pubs Limited entered administration Report 2.1
4 March 2026: Cabinet decision to approve surrender and Tenancy at Will Report P5
Plain English for the jargon
Tenancy at Will: A flexible, informal letting with no fixed term that either party can end at short notice, often used as a temporary arrangement before a formal lease is agreed.
Best consideration reasonably obtainable: The duty under section 123 of the Local Government Act 1972 for councils to secure the highest monetary value, typically open market value, when disposing of land.
Surrender of lease: The ending of an existing lease by agreement between landlord and tenant before its expiry date.
What was decided, why, and what happens next
Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.
Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
Item125
Resolved
RESOLVED to: 1. Review the background information leading to a decision to recommend approval of a new Tenancy at Will for the site. 2. Note the circumstances that require the letting at the proposed rent (i.e. less than ‘best consideration’) to progress. 3. Approve the Surrender of the current lease and the grant of a Tenancy at Will on the terms set out in the Exempt Annex
Word for word from the decision Peterborough published for this meeting.Source: democracy.peterborough.gov.uk
Historically, officer delegations were applied by reference to annual rent. As a result, commercial leases were approved under officer delegation for transactions not exceeding £250,000. The council’s governance arrangements confirm that for property transactions involving the grant of commercial leases, the aggregate rental value over the full contractual term should determine the level of approval required, rather than the annual rent alone.
The council is additionally obligated by law to demonstrate it has achieved best consideration reasonably obtainable for all disposals (except for those leases granted than by way of a short tenancy (i.e. not exceeding seven years)
The tenant of 9-15 Bridge Street has entered Administration and is consequently seeking a revised tenancy arrangement. Accordingly, Cabinet approval is required to approve a decision to agree a new Tenancy at Will for the premises to allow continuation of occupation by the tenant.
Details of the terms for the Tenancy at Will, including commercially sensitive information, are contained within the Exempt Annex to this report.
171 4 March 2026 Cabinet
Recommendations
1. Cabinet is requested to:
i. Review the background information leading to a decision to recommend approval of a new Tenancy at Will for the site.
ii. Note the circumstances that require the letting at the proposed rent (i.e. less than best) to progress.
iii. Approve the Surrender of the current lease and the grant of a Tenancy at Will on the terms set out in the Exempt Annex
1. Purpose
1.1The purpose of this report is to seek Cabinet approval: -
I. After review of the background and considerations in reaching a decision, to permit the letting of this property in accordance with the terms given as set out in the Exempt Annex.
II. To allow the short-term letting of unit 9 –15 Bridge Street at a rent that could exceed the £250,000 aggregate rental threshold when assessed over the possible period of occupation.
1.2Commercially sensitive information relating to the tenancy agreement is set out in the Exempt Annex and is not included in this report
2. Background and key issues
2.1The property is currently occupied by Gastro Pubs Limited trading as Middleton’s who entered administration on 14th November 2025.
2.2As part of the Administration process, discussions for a new tenancy agreement have been negotiated and agreed in principle.
2.3Following a governance review, the Monitoring Officer has advised that the more cautious, and as such proper route, is for the aggregate rental value over the full contractual term to be used to determine the appropriate approval route. For the avoidance of doubt, aggregate rental value has been calculated over the full contractual term, excluding the exercise of tenant break options, in line with this advice.
2.4The governance review further recommends that any transactions which may not clearly satisfy the requirements of Section 123 of the Local Government Act 1972, particularly the duty for the Council to secure ‘best consideration reasonably obtainable’, should be referred to Cabinet for
172 4 March 2026 Cabinet
approval. This approach recognises that the wider background and contextual considerations are integral to determining whether 'best consideration’ can be achieved.
3. Corporate Priorities
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
Goods Shed (Fletton Quays) DisposalCabinet unanimously RESOLVED to: 1. Authorise the disposal of the Goods Shed on the terms set out in Exempt Annex 2 o...
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.