Ken Stimpson Academisation - Judicial Review Update
DecidedExecutive4 papers
AI summaryCabinet authorises lease of Ken Stimpson playing fields to 4Cs Academy Trust with a buffer strip retained for public use, ending the Judicial Review claim.
Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeDecidedWith 4Cs Academy Trust, excluding public buffer strip
MoneyUp to £150,000 potential JR defence cost avoided. Plus £20,000 Academy fencing contribution
What happens nextNot stated
Who it affectsNot stated
What was decided
Cabinet authorised the Council to enter a lease of the playing fields (shown red and cross-hatched black on the plan) with the 4Cs Academy Trust, excluding areas retained by the Council for continued community use (shown blue with black diagonal hatching). Report P8
Cabinet approved the draft lease at Appendix 3 as the basis for the final lease, subject to minor non-material amendments by the Interim Director for Legal and Governance, and authorised a new Community Use Agreement with the Academy Trust covering community use of the playing fields outside school hours. Report P8
Cabinet delegated authority to the Director of Legal and Governance to settle outstanding terms and to negotiate with the Academy Trust on the basis that each party bears its own legal costs of the Judicial Review, but to pay the Trust's reasonable costs if needed to secure settlement. Report P8
Why
On 13 March 2025 Full Council decided to grant a 125-year lease to the 4Cs Academy Trust, but the parties could not agree the extent of the lease and the Trust filed a Judicial Review claim on 18 June 2025, which the High Court permitted to proceed on 23 September 2025. Report P1, P2
Negotiations have now concluded successfully: the Academy Trust has accepted a buffer strip around the playing fields (10m east, 15.5m south, 20m west) being excluded from the lease and retained by the Council for public recreational use, with a Community Use Agreement securing access outside school hours. Report 2.30
Settling the claim in this way avoids a contested substantive hearing, which could have cost the Council in the region of £100,000-£150,000 plus the Academy Trust's legal costs, and is expected to lead to the withdrawal of the Judicial Review. Report 2.36
What happens next
Complete the lease of the playing fields and the Community Use Agreement, and lodge a consent order to settle the Judicial Review proceedings, which the Academy Trust will then withdraw. Report 2.34, 2.35
Progress the separate second lease for the school buildings, which remains subject to resolving the interests of two PFI project companies and the community use arrangements for the sports hall and library. Report P8, 2.27, 2.28
Consult Ward Councillors and the Save Werrington Fields group; report their views verbally to Cabinet. The 2-metre fence is already owned by the Council and additional fencing is expected to cost the Council approximately £10,000 plus VAT. Report 4.1, 2.30, 2.33
The money
£20,000 Contribution by the Academy Trust towards the fencing between the playing fields and the perimeter buffer Report 2.30
approximately £10,000 plus VAT Expected additional fencing cost to the Council Report 2.30
in the region of £100,000-£150,000 Potential cost to the Council of unsuccessfully defending the Judicial Review to a substantive hearing, excluding the Academy Trust's legal costs Report 2.36
Options considered
Chosen: Approve the lease and Community Use Agreement. Settles the Judicial Review, withdraws the claim against the Council, and provides the community use safeguards Report 8.1, 2.36
Rejected: Do not approve the lease. Would require the Council to defend the Judicial Review publicly at significant cost, with no clear benefit and a risk of a challenge from the Save Werrington Fields Interested Party over the Community Use Agreement Report 8.2, 8.3
Implications
Legal: Authorising the lease and Community Use Agreement is intended to settle and lead to the withdrawal of the Judicial Review claim, with costs negotiated on a each-side-bears-its-own basis unless payment is needed to secure settlement. Report 2.35, 2.36, P8
Financial: Settling avoids a potential £100,000-£150,000+ defence cost; the Academy Trust will contribute £20,000 to fencing and the Council will spend about £10,000 plus VAT on additional fencing. Report 2.30, 2.36
Equalities: Continued public use of the retained buffer strip and Community Use Agreement mitigates potential adverse impacts on protected groups such as disabled people, women and elderly people who may disproportionately use the land for recreation. Report 7.1
Risk: There is a risk that Save Werrington Fields, as an Interested Party, could challenge the Council's position on the Community Use Agreement if it is not completed. Report 8.3
Other: The decision splits the academisation lease into two parts: a playing fields lease now, and a separate school buildings lease to follow once PFI project company interests are resolved. Report 2.27, P8
Who and where
4Cs Academy Trust (Ken Stimpson Academy) Report 2.5, P8
Save Werrington Fields residents group (Interested Party in the Judicial Review) Report 2.21, 2.31
Members of the public who use the playing fields at Werrington for recreation Report 2.3, 2.11
Pupils and staff of Ken Stimpson Academy Report 2.5, 2.27
Two PFI project companies with interests in the school buildings Report 2.27, P8
Ward Councillors for the affected area Report 4.1
Timeline
13 March 2025: Full Council decided to grant a 125-year lease to the 4Cs Academy Trust covering the main school site and all or part of the playing fields Report P1
18 June 2025: The Academy Trust filed a Judicial Review claim with the High Court (Administrative Division) Report P2
10 July 2025: The Council filed Summary Grounds for resisting the Judicial Review claim Report P2
23 September 2025: The High Court granted the Academy Trust permission to pursue the Judicial Review claim Report P2
14 October 2025: Cabinet resolved unanimously to seek a stay of the Judicial Review and to negotiate settlement, including a buffer strip retained by the Council for public use Report P3, P4, 2.18
24 March 2026: Cabinet considered this report and authorised the lease of the playing fields and Community Use Agreement Report P8
30 April 2026: Stay of the Judicial Review proceedings is currently scheduled to expire
Plain English for the jargon
4Cs Academy Trust: The multi-academy trust that runs Ken Stimpson Academy following its conversion from a community school
Academisation: The process of a maintained community school converting to academy status, here Ken Stimpson Community School becoming Ken Stimpson Academy on 1 September 2023
Judicial Review: A court process by which a judge reviews the lawfulness of a public body's decision; the 4Cs Academy Trust challenged the Council's handling of the academisation lease
PFI: Private Finance Initiative; two PFI project companies hold interests in the school buildings that must be resolved before that part of the lease can complete
Community Use Agreement: An agreement governing public access to the playing fields outside school hours, intended to safeguard continued community recreation use
Tenancy at will: A temporary occupation arrangement granted to the Academy Trust on conversion, pending the long-term lease
What was decided, why, and what happens next
Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.
Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
Item140
Resolved
RESOLVED to: 1. Authorise the Council to enter a lease of the playing fields as identified coloured red and cross hatched in black on the plan at paragraph 2.1 below with the 4Cs Academy Trust, excluding those areas that are to be retained by the ... view the full minutes text for item 140.
Word for word from the decision Peterborough published for this meeting.Source: democracy.peterborough.gov.uk
On 13 March 2025, Council decided to grant a 125-year lease to the 4Cs Academy Trust, covering the main school site and all or part of the school playing fields.
It was not possible, however, to reach agreement on the extent of the grant of lease and on 18 June 2025, the Academy Trust filed a Judicial Review claim with the High Court (Administrative Division). The Council filed its Summary Grounds for resisting the claim on 10 July 2025 and on 23 September 2025 the Court granted the Academy Trust permission to pursue the Judicial Review claim as the grounds raised arguable points of law.
On 14 October 2025 the Cabinet considered a number of options in response to the Judicial Review proceedings and resolved unanimously to instruct officers
a. to seek a stay (adjournment) of the Judicial Review proceedings; and b. to negotiate with the Academy Trust to seek to settle the proceedings by allowing a lease to be agreed excluding a strip of land around the playing fields which was to remain in the ownership of the Council and to remain available for public recreational use.
The negotiations with the Academy Trust have now concluded successfully and the Council is in a position to finalise the lease and the associated Community Use Agreement with the Academy Trust.
85 24 March 2026 Cabinet
Recommendations
Cabinet is requested to:
1. Authorise the Council to enter a lease of the playing fields as identified coloured red and cross hatched in black on the plan at paragraph 2.1 below with the 4Cs Academy Trust, excluding those areas that are to be retained by the Council for continued community use shown in blue and black diagonal hatching in the same plan. 2. Approve the attached draft lease (Appendix 3) as the basis on which the Council will enter into the final lease, subject to any minor, non-material amendments required by the Interim Director for Legal and Governance. 3. Authorise the Council to enter into a new Community Use Agreement with the 4Cs Academy Trust governing the community use of the playing fields as identified coloured red and cross hatched in black in the plan at paragraph 2.1 below outside of school hours. 4. Delegate authority to the Director of Legal and Governance in consultation with the Executive Director of Corporate Resources and Executive Director for Children’s Service to settle any outstanding terms and complete all necessary legal and procedural formalities associated with the lease, the community Use Agreement and any related documentation. 5. Note the ongoing work to progress the grant of a lease of the school buildings to the 4Cs Academy Trust, which remains subject to completing any steps required with the relevant PFI project companies that hold an interest in those school buildings. 6. Authorise the Director of Legal and Governance, in consultation with the Executive Director of Corporate Resources, to negotiate with the Academy Trust on the basis that each party should bear its own legal costs arising from the Judicial Review proceedings, but to agree and arrange payment of the Trust’s reasonable legal costs if this is necessary to secure settlement and conclude the Judicial claim against the Council.
86 24 March 2026 Cabinet
1. Purpose/Reason for Decision
1.1The purpose of this report is to update Cabinet on the progress with the resolution of a Judicial Review claim and to seek approval for the next steps required to complete the lease and Community Use Agreement.
2. Background and key issues
The Land
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
Goods Shed (Fletton Quays) DisposalCabinet unanimously RESOLVED to: 1. Authorise the disposal of the Goods Shed on the terms set out in Exempt Annex 2 o...
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.