RESOLVED that the application be refused for the following reasons: 1. The proposal is considered to be in direct conflict with Policy DMG1 of the Ribble Valley Core Strategy insofar that the proposed development would result in significant measurable harm to the residential amenities of the occupiers of numbers 3-5 ‘The Willows’ by virtue of direct overlooking, from elevated positions from habitable room windows, within close proximity which would afford direct views into the private residential garden areas and habitable rooms of the affected dwellings. As such the proposal would significantly undermine and diminish the sense of privacy enjoyed by occupiers of the existing properties. It is further considered that the proposal would prove harmful to existing residential amenities by virtue of its overall scale and proximity to the affected dwelling, resulting in a significant undue and unsympathetic overbearing impact upon. 2. The proposed development, by virtue of its overall design, scale and elevational language, would result in the introduction of an incongruous, unsympathetic, and discordant form of development, of an overtly suburban appearance, that fails to respond positively to the inherent visual character of the area or the inherent defining characteristics of the immediate streetscene. As such the proposal is considered to be in direct conflict with Policy DMG1 of the Ribble Valley Core Strategy and Paragraphs 130 and 134 of the National Planning Policy Framework insofar that the proposed development would be of significant detriment to the character and visual amenities of the area. 3. The proposed development is considered to be in direct conflict with Policy DMG3 of the Ribble Valley Core Strategy insofar that the proposed site arrangement precludes the ability for vehicles to adequately manoeuvre and park safely within the site. (Cllr S Brunskill spoke on the above application as ward councillor, then left the meeting and took no part in the debate or vote)
Word for word from the decision Ribble Valley published for this meeting.Source: democracy.ribblevalley.gov.uk
PROPOSED FIVE NEW DWELLINGS ON SITE OF FORMER PACK HORSE GARAGE. PACK HORSE GARAGE MELLOR BROW MELLOR BB2 7PL
CONSULTEE RESPONSES/ REPRESENTATIONS MADE:
PARISH COUNCIL:
No representations received in respect of the application. ENVIRONMENT DIRECTORATE (COUNTY SURVEYOR):
The Highways Development Control Section have offered the following observations:
Lancashire County Council acting as the Local Highway Authority does not consider that the application as submitted fully assesses the highway impact of the proposed development and further information is required as set out in this response. Without this information the Local Highway Authority is unable to provide final highway advice on this application.
Site Access:
The LHA are aware that the proposed dwellings will be accessed off Mellor Brow which is a C classified road subject to a 30mph speed limit. The LHA have reviewed SPA drawing number 5766-PH03B titled "Proposed Site Plan Pack Horse Garage Site" and are aware that the site will use the access which already serves 6 dwellings following application references 3/2019/0190 and 3/2016/0092. Not only this but the access has already been approved to serve 9 apartments following successive applications on the footprint of the proposal, as highlighted above. Therefore, with these factors in mind the LHA have no further comments to make regarding the site access.
However, the LHA will require full height kerbs to be provided from the end of the proposed stone wall located at the site access to the retaining wall structure fronting the adopted highway. The LHA require full height kerbs to be erected to prevent vehicles from parking on the retaining wall structure, as shown on Google Streetview with the images being dated June 2022. The LHA require this to ensure that the safety of the access is not compromised.
Highway Safety: There have been no Personal Injury Collisions recorded within 200m of the site and therefore the LHA have no pre-existing highway safety concerns.
Internal Layout:
The LHA have reviewed SPA drawing number 5766-PH03B titled "Proposed Site Plan Pack Horse Garage Site" and are aware that 21 car parking spaces will be provided for the development which complies with the LHAs parking guidance as defined in the Joint Lancashire Structure Plan which requires 3 spaces for each dwelling to be provided.
However, the LHA require the spaces located on the driveways of Plots 4 and 5 to be removed. This is because there is not enough reversing space for vehicles to exit the designated parking area for each plot. This is because Plot 4 can only provide approximately 2m of free space, while Plot 5 can only provide 4.5m without both Plots being bound by the retaining wall structure. For the area to comply with the LHAs guidance, a minimum of 6m of free space behind the driveway is required and so the LHA cannot accept the shortfall for the parking area.
Furthermore, even if the LHA accepted the shortfall in the reversing space of the car parking areas the usability of the driveway and the garage for Plot 4 will be compromised. This is because should Plot 5 be using their driveway, the occupants of Plot 4 will be unable to access their driveway or garage either to exit or enter the site. This is due to the narrowness of the access track where Plot 4 is located.
In this location, the access track reduces in width from approximately 7.8 m to 1.8m and reduces further where Plot 4 is located. This means that vehicles accessing or egressing from the driveway or garage from Plot 4 will have to overlap the driveway for Plot 5. However, should a vehicle be parked there, Plot 4 will be unable to do this making the area unusable. As a result, the LHA require the two spaces fronting the Plots to be removed and relocated to the private parking area.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.