CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Ribble Valley Borough Council
Planning and Development, Thursday 22 September 2022 at 6.30pm

Planning Application 3/2022/0672 - Land off Whalley Road, Mellor Brook, BB2 7HY

Refused Planning 1 paper

Planning and Development refused this item on Thursday 22 September 2022. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item301

Resolved

RESOLVED that the application be refused for the following reasons: 1. The proposal is considered to be in direct conflict with Key Statement DS1 and Policies DMG2 and DMH3 of the Adopted Ribble Valley Core Strategy insofar that approval would lead to the creation of new residential dwellings, located outside of a defined settlement boundary, without sufficient justification - insofar that it has not been adequately demonstrated that the proposal is for that of local needs housing that meets a current identified and evidenced outstanding need or that the proposal would meet any of the exception criterion inherently contained within either of the policies. 2. The proposed dwellings, by virtue of their elevated nature, overall footprint, and forward projection relative to the adjacent residential development to the west, would result in the introduction of an incongruous and discordant form of development that fails to respond to nearby inherent patterns of development. As such the proposal is considered to be in direct conflict with Policy DMG1 of the Ribble Valley Core Strategy and Paragraphs 130 and 134 of the National Planning Policy Framework insofar that the proposed development would be of significant detriment to the character and visual amenities of the area. (Cllr S Brunskill spoke on the above application as ward councillor, then left the meeting and took no part in the debate or vote. Matthew Wyatt spoke in favour of the above application) (Cllr S Brunskill returned to the meeting before the next item of business)
Word for word from the decision Ribble Valley published for this meeting. Source: democracy.ribblevalley.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Ribble Valley's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Planning and Development

APPLICATION REF: 3/2022/0672

GRID REF: SD 364220 431258

DEVELOPMENT DESCRIPTION:

PROPOSED ERECTION OF 3 NEW 3 BEDROOM ADAPTABLE AND SPECIALIST BUNGALOWS EXCLUSIVELY FOR OVER 55'S. LAND OFF WHALLEY ROAD MELLOR BROOK BB2 7HY

CONSULTEE RESPONSES/ REPRESENTATIONS MADE:

PARISH COUNCIL:

Balderstone Parish Council have objected on the following grounds:

Regarding planning application 3/2022/0672, the proposed erecting of three specialist bungalows adapted for over 55’s. While Balderstone parish council (BPC) supports this type of specialised development within the community, the harm of this particular development on the local environment outweighs the benefits.

For example, the development is situated outside of the settlement boundary of Mellor brook and is placed within open countryside, contrary to the Core Strategy policies (DME Z, DME3, EN4) and will impact TPO trees. In addition, the proposed development is set in an elevated position and closer to Whalley Road than the existing dwellings; ultimately the suggested plans would be highly prominent in the street scene which could change the aesthetic of the area.

The overall read quality of the submitted reports is also poor, with a lack of colouration within the report figures making the document difficult to analysis. Further to this, the accompanying wildlife surveys were conducted in 2019 and therefore may be misrepresentative. We suggest higher quality images are obtained and surveys that reflect the current wildlife status are conducted. Once achieved BPC would appreciate an opportunity to review and respond to such documentation.

Furthermore, the land to the west of the proposed site has recently been developed, with 5 two storey dwellings (planning application ref. 3/2018/1080) although these dwellings have been completed, the surrounding woodland, countryside and infrastructure that was disturbed during their construction has yet to be reinstated. Unfortunately, construction materials remain discarded and damage to the adjacent footpath and retaining wall have not been rectified. This has resulted in a prolonged disruption for wildlife and an on-going hazard for pedestrians using the pavement. As the woodland has not been restored, the continuous woodland / wildlife corridor of the Ancient Mammon woodland, a Biological Heritage Site has been disrupted and therefore any continued development would only be detrimental.

Due to negligence regarding the landscape management plan BPC has already attempted to correspond with the developer, however any concerns raised have been ultimately ignored. Therefore, BPC cannot support this development as its developers fail to protect and enhance the local environment.

ENVIRONMENT DIRECTORATE (COUNTY SURVEYOR):

The Highways Development Control Section have offered the following observations:

Lancashire County Council acting as the Local Highway Authority does not consider that the application as submitted fully assesses the highway impact of the proposed development and further information is required as set out in this response. Without this information the Local Highway Authority is unable to provide final highway advice on this application.

The LHA are aware that the site will be accessed off Whalley Road which is an unclassified road subject to a 30mph speed limit. The LHA have reviewed LMP Architects drawing number 22/044/P01 titled "Proposed Site Plan" and are aware that each dwelling will have its own independent access. The LHA have reviewed each access in turn and are aware that the access width of all 3 complies with the LHAs guidance.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Planning Application 3/2022/0672: Land off Whalley Road, Mellor Brook, BB2 7HYReport 359 KB DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

12 of 22 attended
AB
Councillor Alison BrownChair, present
A(
Councillor Anthony (Tony) AustinCommittee Member, present
IB
Councillor Ian BrownCommittee Member, present
SB
Councillor Stella Brunskill JPCommittee Member, present
R(
Councillor Robert (Bob) BullerCommittee Member, present
SC
Councillor Stuart CarefootCommittee Member, apologies
JC
Councillor Judith ClarkVice-Chair, present
LE
Councillor Louise EdgeCommittee Member, apologies
KF
Councillor Kerry FletcherCommittee Member, present
MF
Councillor Mark FrenchCommittee Member, present
BH
Councillor Brian HoldenCommittee Member, apologies
KH
Councillor Kevin Horkin MBECommittee Member, present

All 22 on the meeting page

On this subject at Ribble Valley

Search all
  1. Planning Application 3/2022/0672 - Land off Whalley Road, Mellor Brook, BB2 7HYThis decision
  2. Local Validation Checklist for Planning ApplicationsApproved
  3. Local Validation Checklist for Planning ApplicationsAgreed
  4. Planning Application 3/2022/0879 - Land South of Ludlow Road, Clitheroe, BB7 2RJDeferred
  5. Planning Application 3/2022/0637 - Keepers Cottage, Northcote Road, Old Langho, BB6 8DBApproved
  6. Planning Application 3/2022/0857 - Croasdale Farm, 1 Whinney Lane, Langho, BB6 8DQApproved

More from Ribble Valley Planning and Development

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
27 Aug 2026 3/2025/0801 - Land to east of Salesbury View WilpshireRESOLVED THAT COMMITTEE: REFUSE PLANNING PERMISSION for the following reasons: 1. The proposed development would be o... Refused Open
27 Aug 2026 3/2022/0317 - Land at Higher Standen Farm and Part Littlemoor Farm ClitheroeRESOLVED THAT COMMITTEE: GRANT planning permission subject to the following condition(s): 1. Unless explicitly requir... Approved Open
27 Aug 2026 3/2026/0442 - Castle Museum Clitheroe Castle Castlegate Clitheroe BB7 1AZRESOLVED THAT COMMITTEE: GRANT planning permission subject to the following condition(s): The development hereby perm... Approved Open
27 Aug 2026 3/2025/0997 - Land off Henthorn Road Clitheroe BB7 3BYRESOLVED THAT COMMITTEE: Application deferred to enable an alternative access directly off Henthorn Road to serve the... Deferred Open
27 Aug 2026 3/2026/0230 - Land to the south of Ribblesdale Primary School west and north of Higher Standen DriveRESOLVED THAT COMMITTEE: DEFER AND DELEGATE to the Director of Economic Development and Planning for approval subject... Deferred Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies