Resolved
Resolved :- (1) That the contents of the report be noted. (2) That the draft response to the DCLG Consultation Paper on the Localisation of Business Rates be approved.
Cabinet (Pre-Intervention noted this item on Wednesday 2 June 2004. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.
Resolved
Resolved :- (1) That the contents of the report be noted. (2) That the draft response to the DCLG Consultation Paper on the Localisation of Business Rates be approved.
ROTHERHAM MBC LOCAL GOVERNMENT RESOURCES REVIEW CONSULTATION – PROPOSALS FOR BUSINESS RATES RETENTION Rotherham MBC welcomes the opportunity to comment on the proposals for the retention of Business Rates. The Council is an active member of bodies like SIGOMA and Local Government Yorkshire and Humber and would broadly endorse their comments on the proposals.
Although the Council is supportive of the objectives of increasing local financial autonomy and promoting local decision making and accountability, the current proposals give rise to significant concerns on the Council’s part.
Firstly, as the proposed system stands, the Council has significant worries about its fairness, believing that there is a substantial risk that economically and socially challenged areas will be disadvantaged as the link between resources and need is not robustly established at the centre of the system and will not be regularly reviewed and maintained over time.
Secondly, the measures consider only one element of local government funding in isolation and do not take into account authorities’ capacity to generate income from other sources such as the Council Tax and fees and charges. It should also be noted that authorities’ need to spend on services is not linked to their capacity to generate economic growth; indeed the most needy authorities are most likely to have the lowest potential to generate additional rates income.
Thirdly, as the current proposals represent a major change in the way that local government is financed and are complex, the Council would ask that further time is allocated to assess the impact of such a substantial change and to avoid perverse incentives and unexpected results.
Fourthly, as currently constructed the measures allow ministers significant discretion (for example on the timing of re-equalisations), which runs counter to the claimed objectives of promoting local autonomy.
In the light of these general concerns the remaining comments follow the question format set out in the appendix to the report issued in July
Component 1: Setting the baseline
Q1: What do you think that the Government should consider in setting the baseline?
The Council believes that it is essential that any baseline reflects key authorities’ spending needs and their capacity to generate income from all sources, Business Rates, Council Tax and fees and charges etc. It will also be vital that this relationship is maintained over time and that measures are set in place to avoid a divergence between resources and need. Otherwise the proposals will have a significantly detrimental effect on disadvantaged areas and regions.
Q2: Do you agree with the proposal to use 2012-13 formula grant as the basis for constructing the baseline? If so, which of the two options at paragraphs 3.13 and 3.14 do you prefer and why? The Council does not consider that 2012/13 Formula Grant allocations represent a valid basis for the construction of a baseline. It is important that the baseline reflects the most up to date assessment of need. Current allocations have been subject to the “floors and ceilings” damping mechanism which diverts funds from authorities like Rotherham with high levels of need to areas with lower need and lower deprivation. Failure to adjust for damping would effectively lock in shortfalls in funding for areas with high levels of assesses need, fixing their disadvantage under the current system.
Component 2: Setting the tariffs and top ups
Q3: Do you agree with this proposed component of tariff and top up amounts as a way of re-balancing the system in year one?
The proposed method would appear logical, providing the right option is chosen regarding the annual adjustment of the tariff and top-up amounts. i.e. in order not to penalise top-up authorities, the top up needs to be increased by RPI.
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
PDF |
Consultation on Business Rates AttachmentReport | 8 pages | DownloadRead as text |
PDF |
Draft Response to Government Consultation on the Localisation of Business RatesReport | 6 pages | Download |
Follow Cabinet (Pre-Intervention at Rotherham and we tell you when its next papers are published, before the meeting rather than after it.
| Meeting | Decision | Outcome | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2 Jun 2004 | IntroductionResolved :- (1) That a variation to the Standing Orders to allow for filming in the Council Chamber be approved. (2) ... | Approved | Open |
| 2 Jun 2004 | Questions from Members of the Public.It was agreed to provide a detailed answer in writing. | Agreed | Open |
| 2 Jun 2004 | Awards- That Members and staff involved be congratulated on these achievements. | Decided | Open |
| 2 Jun 2004 | John GomersallResolved :- That the best wishes of the Council be forwarded to John for a speedy recovery . | Decided | Open |
| 2 Jun 2004 | Wath Comprehensive SchoolResolved :- (1) That everyone involved in developing the new premises be congratulated on this outstanding success an... | Decided | Open |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.