CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Rotherham Metropolitan Borough Council
Planning Board, Thursday 4 August 2005

Outline application for the erection of a 7,897 m² food and non-food superstore (use class A1), two 465 m² restaurants (Use class A3), residential development, a petrol filling station and car parking at land at Westgate/Main Street, Rotherham Town Centre (RB2004/067(OUT))

Refused Planning

Planning Board refused this item on Thursday 4 August 2005. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item46

Resolved

Resolved :- That planning permission be refused for the following reasons:- 1. The applicant has failed to demonstrate a quantitative and/or qualitative need for the convenience goods element of the proposal, and as such the proposals would be detrimental to Rotherham town centre. As such the proposal is contrary the provisions of PPS6. 2. In the absence of an identified need for the convenience element of the proposal, the proposed location of the superstore on an edge of centre site, would lead to consequences that would be likely to have a harmful impact on the vitality and viability of Rotherham Town Centre. As such the proposal is contrary to the provisions of U.D.P. policy RET3, and the provisions of PPS6. 3. The proposed superstore by virtue of its scale, massing, and position in relation to the Cutlers Arms, would unduly compete with and dominate the listed building to the detriment of its setting. As such the proposal is contrary to the provisions of U.D.P. policy ENV2.8, and the provisions of PPG15. 4. The proposed unjustified demolition of unlisted buildings within the Conservation Area which make significant contributions to the character and appearance of the conservation area and the setting of the listed building, and there replacement with an area of car parking, is detrimental to the setting of the listed building and the character and appearance of the Conservation Area. As such the proposals are contrary to the provisions of U.D.P. policies ENV2.8, ENV2.11, ENV3.1, and the provisions of PPS1 and PPG15. 5. The proposed superstore by virtue of its scale, mass, and siting , and its awkward relationship with the Cutlers Arms, is considered to be detrimental to the setting of the Conservation Area, and the visual amenity of the area. As such the proposal is contrary to the provisions of U.D.P. policies ENV2.12 and ENV3.1, and the provisions of PPS1 and PPG15. 6. The proposed petrol filling station by virtue of its alien utilitarian appearance and prominent position is detrimental to the setting of the Conservation Area and the visual amenity of the area. As such the proposal is contrary to the provisions of U.D.P. policies ENV2.12, ENV3.1, and the provisions of PPS1 and PPG15. 7. The proposed area of external car parking by virtue of its scale, prominent position and poor appearance, and its relationship to the Westgate frontage is detrimental to the setting of the Conservation Area and the proposed riverside walk, and fails to make the most efficient use of land. As such the proposal is contrary to the provisions of U.D.P. polices ENV2.12 and ENV3.1, the provisions of PPS1 and ... view the full minutes text for item 46.
Word for word from the decision Rotherham published for this meeting. Source: moderngov.rotherham.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Rotherham's papers

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in

No papers were published with this item. The decision above is the council's full record of it.

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

16 of 21 attended
SW
Councillor Sheila WalkerChair, present
AA
Councillor Alan AtkinMember, present
PB
Councillor Patrick BurkeMember, expected
JB
Councillor Josephine BurtonMember, apologies
BC
Councillor Brian CuttsMember, present
BD
Councillor Barry DodsonMember, present
DH
Councillor David HallMember, present
BK
Councillor Barry KayeMember, present
NL
Councillor Neil LicenseMember, apologies
RL
Councillor Reg LittleboyMember, present
RM
Councillor Rose McNeelyMember, present
GN
Councillor Geb NightingaleMember, present

All 21 on the meeting page

On this subject at Rotherham

Search all
  1. Outline application for the erection of a 7,897 m² food and non-food superstore (use class A1), two 465 m² restaurants (Use class A3), residential development, a petrol filling station and car parking at land at Westgate/Main Street, Rotherham Town Centre (RB2004/067(OUT))This decision
  2. Site Visit - Demolition of dwellings and outline application for the erection of 15 dwellings including details of access, appearance, layout & scale at land at Churchill Avenue / Greenland Avenue, Maltby (RB2023/1364)Agreed
  3. Site Visit - Outline planning application, with all matters reserved except means of access, comprising up to 185 dwellings, vehicle and pedestrian access, parking, public open space, landscaping, balancing ponds and associated works, land north of Tickhill Road, Maltby (RB2022/1638)Agreed
  4. Site Visit - Outline application for the erection of up to 217 dwellinghouses including details of access at land off Shrogswood Road, Whiston for Ernest V. Waddington Ltd. (RB2022/0017)Agreed
  5. Courtesy Consultation in respect of Outline Planning Application with some matters reserved (Approval being sought for Access) for an employment-led development of B1/B2/B8 Uses at Land at Shireoaks Common, Shireoaks, Nottinghamshire for Bassetlaw District Council (18/00413/OUT) (rb2018/0623Decided
  6. Courtesy Consultation - Reserved Matters Application for the Approval of the Layout, Scale Appearance and Landscaping Following Outline Application 14/00431/OUT - Erection of 261 dwellings including open space and associated service infrastructure for Bassetlaw District CouncilNoted

More from Rotherham Planning Board

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
29 Oct 2026 Minutes of the previous meeting held on 8th October 2026- That the minutes of the previous meeting of the Planning Regulatory Board held on Thursday, 8 th October, 2026, be ... Approved Open
29 Oct 2026 Development Proposals- (1 ) That , on the development proposals now considered, the requisite notices be issued and be made available on t... Approved Open
29 Oct 2026 Report of the Service Director for Planning, Regeneration and Transport - Whitestone Solar Farm - Nationally Significant Infrastructure Project Update- That the update be received and the contents noted. Noted Open
8 Oct 2026 Minutes of the previous meeting held on 17th September, 2026- That the minutes of the previous meeting of the Planning Regulatory Board held on Thursday, 17 th September, 2026, ... Approved Open
8 Oct 2026 Development Proposals- (1) That, on the development proposals now considered, the requisite notices be issued and be made available on the... Approved Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies