Item172
Resolved
Resolved :- That planning permission be refused for the following reasons:- 1. The Council considers that the development of this site for residential purposes conflicts with the advice contained in the report approved by the Council on 07 June 2006 which upheld the need for a presumption against development on Greenfield sites in the interests of sustainability and the requirement to meet Regional and National regeneration/housing targets. Furthermore, no information has been submitted by the applicant that justifies the release of this Greenfield site in preference to other more sustainable brownfield sites, to the detriment of the long-term strategic sustainable development objectives within the Rotherham Borough. 2. The Council considers that the application does not bear a good relationship to the locality and having regard to the information supplied in the Design and Access statement, does not respect the density of the locality. In this respect the application fails the tests of PPS1: Delivering Sustainable Development which states that design which is inappropriate in its context, or which fails to take the opportunities available for improving the character and quality of the area should not be accepted. In addition the Council considers that the provisions of PPS3 Housing are material since this development is considered not to be well integrated with and complementary to neighbouring buildings and the local area in terms of density, layout and access. 3. The proposed turning area is substandard in size and will not cater for the typical turning manoeuvres of a refuse vehicle such that long reversing manoeuvres will be required into the classified highway to the detriment of the free and safe flow of other traffic. 4. The Council considers that the proposed means of vehicular access to the site will have a negative impact upon the amenity of the neighbouring property at 19 Morthen Road through disturbance caused by vehicles passing close to principal rooms, windows and private gardens, contrary to Policies HG4.4 Back Land and Tandem Development' and ENV3.1 'Development and the Environment' of the adopted Unitary Development Plan and to advice contained in Housing Guidance 2 'Back Land and Tandem Development'. 5. The provision of the required visibility splays would result in the loss of an excessive amount of the roadside wall and loss of street definition and would further entail the opening up of views into the site, to the detriment of the visual amenity of the Wickersley Conservation Area, contrary to Policy ENV2.11 'Development in Conservation Areas’ of the adopted Unitary Development Plan and to advice contained in Environment Guidance 3: ‘Development in Conservation Areas’. 6. The Council is not satisfied that adequate measures have been made for the retention and/or conversion of the existing building within the south eastern corner of the site. In the absence of such proposals, the loss of this building would be detrimental ... view the full minutes text for item 172.
Word for word from the decision Rotherham published for this meeting.
Source: moderngov.rotherham.gov.uk