Resolved :- (1) That the report be received and its contents noted. (2) That an exemption be granted from standing order 47.6.2 (requirement to invite two oral or written quotations for a contract with an estimated value of between £5,000 and £20,000) and the contracts be awarded in five disciplines, namely (i) dam design/safety, (ii) pumping, (iii) geotechnical engineering, (iv) diving and valve refurbishment and (v) general civil engineering, as necessary for the repair works to be undertaken at Firsby Reservoir and to ensure the safety of the reservoir. (3) That the sanction of The Mayor be sought to exempt this decision from the call-in procedure, in order to allow immediate action at Firsby Reservoir and to ensure that reservoir safety is maintained. ( nb : subsequent to this meeting, The Mayor gave the necessary authorisation to exempt this decision from the Council’s call-in procedure)
Word for word from the decision Rotherham published for this meeting.Source: moderngov.rotherham.gov.uk
To report on subsidence at Firsby Reservoir and to seek an exemption from standing order 47.6.2 (requirement to invite two oral or written quotations for a contract with an estimated value of between £5000 and £20,000) in order that appropriate contractors and consultants be appointed to ensure reservoir safety at Firsby.
Recommendations
It is recommended that:
(i) An exemption from standing order 47.6.2 ((requirement to invite two oral or written quotations for a contract with an estimated value of between £5000 and £20,000) be granted and that contracts be awarded in five disciplines namely dam design/safety, pumping, geotechnical engineering, diving and valve refurbishment and general civil engineering as necessary for works at Firsby to ensure reservoir safety. (ii) The sanction of the Mayor be sought to exempt this recommendation from the usual call in procedure in order to allow immediate action at Firsby Reservoir to ensure reservoir safety is maintained. 7. Proposals and Details
Firsby Reservoir has been under special observation since concerns over the dam’s integrity were raised earlier this year in the section 10 inspection. On Monday 8th October subsidence was found in the dam crest. This subsidence originates within the dam structure such that structural safety of the dam is now of concern. The All Reservoirs Panel Engineer visited the site on Tuesday 9th October and has asked for a variety of measures to be taken to best ensure the immediate safety of the dam. These include draining the reservoir to a level 2m below its normal top water level and ground investigation to determine the likely structure of the dam and the possible extent of voids within it, and further analysis of the results in order to determine a plan of action to stabilise the dam structure in the short term.
Firsby has no operational drawdown equipment. Pumping will therefore be required for the required drawdown. Existing disused drawdown equipment will be re-evaluated to see if it can be brought back into operation to reduce pumping costs.
It is proposed to assemble appropriate specialists and contractors in the fields of dam design, pumping, geotechnical engineering, diving and valve refurbishment, and civil engineering in order to deal with the immediate need to ensure the safety of the dam. Specialists and contractors will be drawn from recent experience at Ulley and Thrybergh reservoirs.
8. Finance
The immediate need is expected to be approximately £100,000 across the five principal specialisms detailed in section 7. These works will be funded through existing Council Capital and Revenue funds.
9. Risks and Uncertainties
These works are essential to ensure reservoir safety. Failure to act may result in enforcement action and emergency repair by the Environment Agency.
10. Policy and Performance Agenda Implications
The services ensure the immediate safety of the dam and reservoir at Firsby Reservoir.
11. Background Papers and Consultation
Consultation has taken place with the Director of Legal and Democratic Services and with the Strategic Director of Resources on the proposed exemptions and both support this report.
Contact Names: David Phillips, Team Manager, Transportation and Highways Projects, Planning, Streetpride Department, Tel. ext. 2950, [email protected]
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.