Item57
Resolved
Decision - Herringthorpe Playing Fields on land off Badsley Moor Lane and Badsley Street South, Rotherham Attention was drawn to the decision of the Planning Inspector in relation to the above application which was allowed for the erection of 10 No. 15 m high floodlight columns at Herringthorpe Playing Fields. The Inspector dealing with the appeal considered the main issues to be:- • The effect of the proposal on the character and appearance of the area. • The effect of the proposal on the living conditions of local residents with particular regard to matters of noise and other disturbance and light pollution. • Whether the proposal would lead to an increase in parking on the surrounding streets, and if so, whether it would adversely affect road safety and the living conditions of nearby residents. The Inspector addressed these matters in his response, but referred to the fourth reason for refusal and the indication that the proposal would have an unacceptable impact on local biodiversity and the reference to bats, which were one of the most sensitive receptors to artificial lighting and some bird species. The Inspector pointed that whilst bats may be roosting in the wider area and use the playing field and its trees for foraging, this had not been established. Nor were details of any bird species that might be affected been given. In his response the Inspector also noted the many concerns raised by local residents in individual letters of representation and a 574 signature petition, together with comments from Ward Members and the Open Spaces Society. Amongst other objections raised were disturbance from light pollution, noise from the additional activities and later use, parking problems and congestion, harmful visual impact, loss of public open space and the effect on wildlife and trees. Taking together, all these comments demonstrated a considerable level of local feeling. However, none were sufficient to alter the conclusions that led to the Inspector’s decision. Taking into account all other matters raised, the Inspector concluded that the appeal should be allowed. In addition, whilst the Inspector was satisfied the Council gave reasonable planning grounds to support its decision with regard to the first three reasons for refusal he considered it manifestly failed to do so with regard to the fourth reason relating to impact on biodiversity. This resulted in the applicant incurring unnecessary expense in having to contest a matter at appeal which was not raised as an issue either at the pre-application stage or during processing of the application and that a partial award of costs was justified. The applicant was now invited to submit to the Council details of those cost with a view to reaching agreement as to the amount. (b) Planning Board Agenda Papers Reference was made to the cost associated with the production of agenda papers and it was suggested that Members use the bookmarked electronic version of the agenda, which was circulated to those Members that currently accessed ... view the full minutes text for item 57.
Word for word from the decision Rotherham published for this meeting.
Source: moderngov.rotherham.gov.uk