Resolved :- (1) That the report be received and its contents noted. (2) That the serving of Tree Preservation Order No. 3, 2016, with regard to the trees of various species, which are the described in the submitted report and are situated on land off Blue Man’s Way at Catcliffe , under Section 198 and 201 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990, be confirmed.
Word for word from the decision Rotherham published for this meeting.Source: moderngov.rotherham.gov.uk
Outline planning permission for the erection of residential development on land off Blue Man’s Way at Catcliffe was refused by the Council on 22/02/16 (RB2013/1342). After the application was refused works started on site to fell some of the trees and a Tree Preservation Order (TPO) was served on 15/03/16. Any objections to the TPO had to be submitted by 22/04/16 and an objection was subsequently received from agents acting on behalf of Network Space on 20/04/16.
An appeal against the refusal of the planning permission (RB2013/1342) was submitted on 16/05/16 and will be determined by way of a public inquiry in due course.
Council’s Tree Service Manager comments
The Tree Service Manager has considered the objections raised and has commented as follows:
The main parts of the objection appear to be as follows:
1. The site does not contain rare or endangered wildlife or vegetation and does not contain any veteran, ancient or even mature trees. 2. The scrub growth on the site does not especially have a good amenity value and is not important in the wider landscape context. 3. The trees and shrubs growing on the site are very young (less than 15 years old) self-set specimens which are of poor form and are unlikely to grow into large well-formed specimens making up a woodland of importance. 4. The use of Tree Preservation Order to protect common scrub growth is not an appropriate use of a TPO 5. There is a lot of woodland and scrub cover within 500 metres of the site, totalling at least 18 hectares. This includes the publically assessable Catcliffe Flash Local Nature Reserve. Therefore, it is not expedient to protect the scrub growth on the site as there is plenty of publically accessible scrub and woodland close by. 6. The Council’s reasons and TEMPO assessment of the amenity and expediency of protecting the scrub growth with a Tree Preservation Order is fundamentally flawed. 7. The site is not important under the Council’s Core Strategy policy CS20 1.The site does not contain rare or endangered wildlife or vegetation and does not contain any veteran, ancient or even mature trees.
It is accepted that the protected woodland area concerned consists of young dense self-set trees and shrubs that generally may be described as ‘scrub’. The Joint Nature Conservancy Council classifies scrub as scattered bushes to closed canopy vegetation, dominated by locally native or non-native shrubs and tree saplings, usually less than 5m tall, occasionally with a few scattered trees.
Some of the trees, mostly Silver Birch and some Willows, appear to be over 5m tall but there are no mature, veteran or ancient trees. As far as I am aware a detailed study of the wildlife on the site has not been carried out to confirm the site does not contain or support rare or endangered wildlife. I am aware the Council’s Ecologist has reported reservations regarding the Phase 1 Ecological Report and the Ecological Compensation and Enhancement Plan submitted as part of the application to develop the site in his memorandum to Planning Services dated, 1 June 2015. For this reason, unless any further evidence is provided, it is not possible to comment further on this part of the objection at this stage.
2.The scrub growth on the site does not especially have a good amenity value and is not important in the wider landscape context.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.