Resolved :- (1) That the report be received and its contents noted. (2) That the serving of Tree Preservation Order No. 5, 2018, be confirmed without modification with regard to the Oak tree which was the subject of this report, situated on land at The Manorial Barn, Chaff Close, Whiston, Rotherham under Section 198 and 201 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990.
Word for word from the decision Rotherham published for this meeting.Source: moderngov.rotherham.gov.uk
That Members confirm the serving of Tree Preservation Order No. 5, 2018 without modification with regard to the Oak tree which is the subject of this report, situated on land at The Manorial Barn, Chaff Close, Whiston under Section 198 and 201 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990.
Background
The Oak Tree is protected by Whiston Conservation Area. A section 211 notice to prune the oak tree was submitted under application reference RB2018/1532. The intended work was to crown lift to between 4 and 5 metres, top canopy and remove branches over hanging thatched roof.
It was considered the the proposed work to the tree is likely to cause significant damage to the tree’s structure , are vague and open to interpretation and will result in a loss of amenity to the conservation area. As such, a Tree Preservation Order was placed on the Oak tree under a new TPO No. 5 2018 on 2 November 2018 and all interested parties notified.
The purpose of this report is to assess the objections received and determine whether the TPO should be confirmed or not.
The government’s advice in the National Planning Practice Guidance (NPPG) states that,
“When deciding whether an Order is appropriate, authorities are advised to take into consideration,
what ‘amenity’ means in practice what to take into account when assessing amenity value what ‘expedient’ means in practice what trees can be protected and how they can be identified
When granting planning permission authorities have a duty to ensure, whenever appropriate, that planning conditions are used to provide for tree preservation and planting. Orders should be made in respect of trees where it appears necessary in connection with the grant of permission”.
Objections
A representation has been received from Whiston Parish Council objecting on the following grounds – The tree is only to be pruned and not felled. Concerns that RMBC have not identified structural issues in the tree. Concerns that the tree will damage the adjacent Grade II* Listed Building through direct damage.
One Right to Speak request has been received.
Comments from Tree Service Manager
The Tree Service Manager has considered the objection raised and has commented as follows:
The Tree is to be pruned and not felled Tree Preservation Orders are created to stop the poor management of trees that will reduce the amenity of the tree and, if they are stood in a conservation area, the amenity of the conservation area.
Pruning works that have the potential to damage a tree’s structure, affect its good health and destroy its natural appearance can also be judged as being poor management that reduces a tree’s amenity value. It is not just the felling of a tree that warrants the use of a tree preservation order.
In this case the works specification included in the conservation area section 211 notice was:
“1 x oak tree (t1) crown lift to between 4 and 5 metres, top canopy and remove branches over hanging thatched roof”
The specification starts well and is clear in its intent to remove branches growing below a maximum height of 5 metres; however the second half of the specification is very poor and not descriptive in its intentions.
British Standard 3998:2010 Tree Work – Recommendations (arboriculture’s industry best practice guide to tree management), section 7.7.2 states that a work specification should:
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.