- (1) That, on the development proposals now considered, the requisite notices be issued and be made available on the Council’s website and that the time limits specified in Sections 91 and 92 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 apply. In accordance with the right to speak procedure the following people attended the meeting and spoke about the applications below:- - Proposed external ramps to front and rear of property at 24 Spinneyfield, Moorgate for Rhodos Properties (No 4) Limited (RB2023/0927) [name removed] (Applicant) [name removed] (Objector) [name removed] (Objector) A statement was also read out at the meeting on behalf of [name removed] (Objector). A statement was also read out at the meeting on behalf of [name removed] (Objector). - Change of use from C3 dwellinghouse to C2 residential institution at 14 Mair Court Moorgate for RMBC (RB2024/0185) [name removed] (Applicant) [name removed] (Objector) [name removed] (Objector) [name removed] (Objector) [name removed] (Objector) [name removed] (Objector) [name removed] (Objector) [name removed] (Objector) [name removed] (Objector) [name removed] (Objector) A statement was read out on behalf of [name removed] (Objector) A statement was read out on behalf of K. Oommen (Objector) A statement was read out on behalf of [name removed] (Objector) A statement was read out on behalf of [name removed] (Objector) A petition was also received in relation to this application containing 221 unverified signatures calling on the Council to withdraw the application owing to a lack of duty of care, a lack of transparency and openness by the Council and due to the negative impact on road safety, traffic and parking. (2) That applications RB2023/0927 and RB2024/0185 be granted for the reasons adopted by Members at the meeting and subject to the relevant conditions listed in the submitted report.
Word for word from the decision Rotherham published for this meeting.Source: moderngov.rotherham.gov.uk
REPORT TO THE PLANNING BOARD TO BE HELD ON THE 21st March 2024
The following applications are submitted for your consideration. It is recommended that decisions under the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 be recorded as indicated.
Application Number RB2023-0927 https://rotherham.planportal.co.uk/?id=RB2023/0927 Proposal and Proposed external ramps to front and rear of property, 24 Location Spinneyfield, Moorgate Recommendation Grant Conditionally
This application is being presented to Planning Board due to the number of objections received.
Site Description & Location
The applicant is 24 Spinneyfield a bungalow with a hipped roof and single storey flat roof extension to the rear. It’s generally of brick construction and clay roof tiles. Parking for some 5 cars is provided to the front.
Spinneyfield is a typical suburban inter war street defined by a mixture of detached bungalows and two storey red brick dwellings, with large residential gardens. Background
RB2022/1550 - External access ramps to front & rear and demolition of garage and erection of detached outbuilding to rear to provide ancillary living accommodation - WITHDRAWN
Proposal
The applicant seeks retrospective permission for disabled access ramps to the front and rear. The ramps provide access for the residents to the front drive and the rear garden. The ramps are constructed in concrete with metal handrails painted black. The maximum height of the ramps both front and rear are 450mm.
This application relates only to the external ramps and does not concern the use of the property. It is understood that the property is used for supported living which is not considered to represent a change of use of the property and falls within Use Class C3b.
The applicant has submitted a supporting statement regarding what use class the use falls into. This has been submitted by the applicant due to the number of objectors raising concerns about a change of use. The contents are paraphrased below:
24 Spinneyfield provides a type of supported living accommodation that falls squarely within Use Class C3(b) - up to 6 people living together as a single household and receiving care. It meets the definition of "specialised supported housing" in government guidance. The residents have disabilities but are living together, interacting, and working towards goals to enhance their independence over time.
The letter analyses planning case law, arguing that previous judgments support the view that Use Class C3(b) can cover accommodation even with full-time care, provided the residents live together as a household. The number of residents, nature of disabilities, and whether carers live on-site are not definitive. At 24 Spinneyfield the residents interact, dine together, hold tenancies for the property and live with independence.
The submission includes a recent appeal decision allowing Use Class C3(b) for a property with 2 men with additional needs and rotational care workers. This has clear parallels with 24 Spinneyfield.
The current use given the occupancy as set out by the applicant, at 24 Spinneyfield falls within Use Class C3(b) based on legislation, case law and appeal precedent.
This application therefore relates only to the provision of ramps to the front and rear of the property. Development Plan Allocation and Policy
The Core Strategy was adopted by the Council on the 10th September 2014 and forms part of Rotherham’s Local Plan together with the Sites and Policies Document which was adopted by the Council on the 27th June 2018.
The application site is allocated for residential purposes in the Local Plan, (For the purposes of determining this application the following policies are considered to be of relevance:
CS27 Community Health and Safety CS28 Sustainable Design SP11 Development in residential Areas SP55 Design Principles
Other Material Considerations
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.