What was decided
Approved application RB2025/1468 for a 400kV Gas Insulated Switchgear substation on land at Long Lane, Whiston, subject to a Section 106 legal agreement for £24,954 biodiversity monitoring and the planning conditions listed in the report. Report P12, P174
Approved application RB2026/0241 for roller shutter doors, palisade fencing and replacement roof at Rear of 94 to 100 Melton High Street West Melton, with an additional condition for structural improvements to be agreed by the Chair and Vice-Chair and implemented within one month.
Approved applications RB2026/0371 for 5 residential dwellings at 13 Quarry Lane North Anston, and RB2026/0480 for 4 apartments at 41 Worksop Road Swallownest, subject to the planning conditions listed in the report.
Why
The site is assessed as Grey Belt land under NPPF paragraph 155, with the proposal meeting a demonstrable unmet need for renewable energy transmission infrastructure, in a sustainable location, and not fundamentally undermining Green Belt purposes. Report P113, P126, P127, P128, P129, P139, P140, P141, P142, P146
The scheme delivers biodiversity net gain well above the 10% statutory minimum, with a calculated uplift of approximately 158.67% in habitat units and 38.68% in hedgerow units, to be secured through a 30-year Habitat Management and Monitoring Plan. Report P171, P172, P173, P174
The development is not considered EIA development under the 2017 Regulations, and the noise impact assessment, flood risk assessment, ecological surveys, and archaeological evaluation conclude that impacts can be appropriately mitigated by conditions. Report P10, P187, P188, P189, P191, P198, P204, P205
What happens next
The Council will enter into a Section 106 legal agreement with National Grid Electricity Transmission Plc to secure the £24,954 biodiversity monitoring payment over 30 years, before the planning permission is granted. Report P174
Conditions will be applied including a Construction Environmental Management Plan for Biodiversity, a Written Scheme of Investigation for archaeology, a Habitat Management and Monitoring Plan, a flood preparedness plan, and an Arboricultural Method Statement and Tree Protection Plan. Report P168, P173, P182, P190, P198
For RB2026/0241, details of structural improvements must be agreed by the Chair and Vice-Chair, with the works implemented within one month of the decision.
The money
- £24,954 Biodiversity Net Gain Monitoring over thirty years, secured via Section 106 legal agreement Report P174
Options considered
- Chosen: Approve RB2025/1468 subject to Section 106 agreement and planning conditions. Site is Grey Belt land meeting unmet need for renewable infrastructure, with significant biodiversity net gain and no significant environmental harm subject to mitigation Report P146, P172
- Rejected: Refuse RB2025/1468 on Green Belt, flood risk, or environmental grounds. No strong policy reason to refuse; flood risk, heritage, and ecological impacts can be addressed through conditions, and very special circumstances are accepted as a fallback Report P124, P125, P146, P147
Implications
- Financial: Developer pays £24,954 to the Council for biodiversity monitoring over 30 years via Section 106 agreement, avoiding the monitoring cost burden on the authority. Report P174
- Climate: Scheme supports net zero by providing transmission infrastructure for renewable energy as part of National Grid's Great Grid Upgrade, with significant weight given to the proposal's contribution to a net zero future. Report P103, P132, P133, P135, P136, P137, P139
- Legal: Whiston Footpath 10 to be permanently realigned through a diversion process; multiple planning conditions to be applied covering archaeology, ecology, trees, and noise. Report P13, P91, P198
- Risk: Flood risk on Long Lane could occasionally cut off the unmanned substation; welfare facilities will be available on site and maintenance visits will be deferred during flood events. Report P31, P190
- Other: Biodiversity net gain significantly exceeds the 10% statutory minimum, with 158.67% habitat units uplift and 38.68% hedgerow units uplift, secured for a minimum 30 year period. Report P172, P173, P174
- Other: Application attracted 345 letters of objection, one letter of support, and a 61 signature petition, with objections from seven parish councils. Report P54, P55, P56
Who and where
- National Grid Electricity Transmission Plc, the applicant for the Whiston substation
- 345 individual objectors and 61 petition signatories Report P54, P55
- Thurcroft, Treeton, Aston, Uley, Conisborough, Whiston and Killamarsh Parish Councils Report P56
- Users of Whiston Footpath 10, which will be permanently realigned Report P13, P91
- Whiston Meadows Local Wildlife Site and surrounding Habitats of Principal Importance Report P166
- A&J Real Estate 2021 Limited, the applicant for Melton High Street
- Eton Home Developments Ltd., the applicant for North Anston dwellings
- The applicant for 4 apartments at 41 Worksop Road, Swallownest
Timeline
- 6th March 2014: National Planning Practice Guidance launched by the Department for Communities and Local Government Report P48
- 10th September 2014: Rotherham Core Strategy adopted as part of the Local Plan Report P42
- 27th June 2018: Rotherham Sites and Policies Document adopted Report P42
- 20th June 2025 to 28th June 2025: Unattended noise survey undertaken at the most exposed receptor location Report P22
- 16 July 2026: Planning Board approves all four applications, with the substation subject to a Section 106 agreement
Plain English for the jargon
- GIS: Gas Insulated Switchgear, substation equipment enclosed in a gas filled building
- NPPF: National Planning Policy Framework, the national planning policy document for England
- Grey Belt: Land in the Green Belt that does not strongly contribute to its main purposes, as defined in the NPPF
- EIA: Environmental Impact Assessment, a formal assessment of a project's likely environmental effects
- BNG: Biodiversity Net Gain, a measurable improvement in biodiversity resulting from development
- BMV: Best and Most Versatile agricultural land, the highest quality farmland (Grades 1, 2 and 3a)
- S106: Section 106 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990, used to secure planning obligations
- SGT: Supergrid Transformer, a large transformer used in high voltage electricity transmission