CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Rushcliffe Borough Council
Corporate Overview Group, Tuesday 22 September 2020 at 7.00pm

Consideration of the Future of Scrutiny

Noted Scrutiny 1 paper

Corporate Overview Group noted this item on Tuesday 22 September 2020. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item16

Resolved

RESOLVED that a) The report of the Executive Manager – Finance and Corporate Services be noted. b) The transitional arrangement for scrutiny be endorsed by the Group in order to become the permanent arrangements as currently stated in the Council’s Constitution.
Word for word from the decision Rushcliffe published for this meeting. Source: democracy.rushcliffe.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Rushcliffe's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Corporate Overview Group

Purpose of report

1.1This report provides information relating to the operation of scrutiny over the last 16 months with a view to informing debate at the Corporate Overview Group leading to a recommendation to Cabinet about the future of scrutiny.

Recommendation

It is RECOMMENDED that the Corporate Overview Group endorse the ‘transitional arrangements’ for scrutiny to be the permanent arrangements as currently stated in the Council’s Constitution.

Reasons for recommendation

3.1An independent review of scrutiny was undertaken in late 2018. This led to a revised model for scrutiny being introduced in May 2019 following the Borough Council election. A review of this new model has now taken place and has found high levels of satisfaction with the current model.

4. Supporting Information

4.1Between September 2018 and February 2019, a review of the Council’s scrutiny arrangements was undertaken. This was done with independent assistance from the Centre for Public Scrutiny (CfPS) and reported to Council in March 2019. The reasons for undertaking a review at this point were: growing frustration of scrutiny members, continuing financial pressures the authority is experiencing, the desire for greater transparency and accountability, and the growing need to ensure resources and councillors’ skills are utilised more flexible and responsively.

4.2The review found that scrutiny at Rushcliffe was doing well but could ‘always do better’. Additionally, the CfPS felt that there was lots of activity at scrutiny but its focus could be better placed and that the Executive ambition could be better supported or enhanced by the scrutiny function. Strengths identified by the CfPS included: high levels of officer support and engagement; task and finish groups are effective and satisfying for councillors; and both councillors and officers are well engaged and positive about their role. However, they also identified a number of areas for improvement, including: a shared understanding about the purpose of scrutiny; routine and repetitive work programmes; lack of understanding or visibility of the Council’s corporate strategy; no, or limited, consideration of the forward plan, corporate strategy, MTFS or other key documents in setting the work programme; limited, or no, public democratic accountability; and limited use of the provisions in the Constitution for holding the Executive to account.

4.3The CfPS report suggested a new model for scrutiny at Rushcliffe centred around a single 15-member Scrutiny Overview Group (as commonly seen in unitary and county councils) which commissioned multiple task and finish groups to investigate topics and concerns. To minimise risk and ensure continuity, a transitional model was proposed and agreed for a period of 12-18 months. The transitional approach also enabled any new councillors, following the 2019 Borough Council Elections, to become familiar with the operation of the Council, receive training in scrutiny and for new ways of identifying topics to scrutinise to bed-in.

4.4The transitional model was approved at Council in March 2019 and consisted of a Corporate Overview Group and three themed scrutiny groups. Terms of reference and membership for these groups was agreed at Annual Council in May 2019 and the groups were operational from 1 June 2019.

4.5A change champion, also the Chair of the Corporate Overview Group, was appointed to oversee the changes recommended in the CfPS report to revitalise scrutiny at Rushcliffe and also to respond appropriately to new statutory guidance published in May 2019 (Overview and scrutiny: statutory guidance for councils and combined authorities).

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Consideration of the Future of ScrutinyReport 474 KB DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

7 of 14 attended
TC
Councillor Tina CombellackChairman, present
BB
Councillor Bal BansalCommittee Member, present
AB
Councillor Abby BrennanCommittee Member, present
NC
Councillor Neil ClarkeCommittee Member, present
FP
Councillor Francis Purdue-HoranCommittee Member, present
JW
Councillor Jen WalkerCommittee Member, present
JW
Councillor Jonathan WheelerCommittee Member, present
CC
Charlotte Caven-AtackOfficer, in attendance
PL
Peter LinfieldOfficer, in attendance
LW
Laura WebbOfficer, in attendance
SW
Sarah WhittakerOfficer, in attendance
TC
Tracey CoopOfficer, expected

All 14 on the meeting page

More from Rushcliffe Corporate Overview Group

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
1 Sep 2026 Consideration of Scrutiny Group Work ProgrammesIt was agreed that the Assistant Director for Growth, Property and Projects would meet with Councillor’s Combellack a... Agreed Open
16 Jun 2026 Diversity Annual Report and update on the Equality and Diversity StrategyRESOLVED that the Corporate Overview Group: a) considered and endorsed the information provided for the Diversity Ann... Decided Open
16 Jun 2026 Consideration of Scrutiny Group Work ProgrammesIt was agreed that the item was not suitable for scrutiny at this time and should be revisited when national changes ... Agreed Open
24 Feb 2026 Mid-point Review of the Corporate StrategyRESOLVED that Corporate Overview Group: a) Considered the information provided outlining the Council’s progress towar... Approved Open
24 Feb 2026 Consideration of Scrutiny Group Work ProgrammesRESOLVED that the Corporate Overview Group: a) Considered any additional items for scrutiny from current Cabinet Forw... Decided Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies