Article 4 Direction - Houses of Multiple Occupancy (HMOs)
DecidedExecutive6 papers
AI summaryRushcliffe Cabinet has decided not to introduce an Article 4 Direction for Houses of Multiple Occupation, finding insufficient evidence to meet the legal threshold. The matter will be referred to Communities Scrutiny Group in July, with HMO numbers and complaints continuing to be monitored.
Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeDecidedCabinet confirmed insufficient evidence to justify removing permitted development rights
MoneyNot stated
What happens nextCommunities Scrutiny Group, JulyMatter referred for scrutiny of key lines of enquiry
Who it affectsHMO operators and residents in RushcliffeMost relevant in West Bridgford, where HMOs are concentrated
What was decided
Cabinet confirmed there is insufficient evidence to meet the legal threshold to justify an Article 4 Direction to remove or restrict permitted development rights for HMOs in the Borough. Report P5
The number of HMOs and complaints received will continue to be monitored. Report P6
The matter will be referred to Communities Scrutiny Group at its July meeting to scrutinise whether there is robust evidence, the likely impacts of a Direction, and whether one would be proportionate and aligned with policy.
Why
There are currently 186 licensed HMOs in Rushcliffe, 184 in West Bridgford, with only four complaints from four residents in 2025 relating to two properties, and none in 2024. The evidence is too limited to meet the robust evidence test required by national policy. Report 4.10, 4.12
National Planning Policy Framework and Planning Practice Guidance require Article 4 Directions to be based on robust evidence and applied to the smallest geographical area possible, justified by clearly identified harm to local amenity or well-being. Report P19, P21, P22, P23, 4.8
Implementing an Article 4 without sufficiently robust evidence could expose the Council to significant legal challenges, Secretary of State intervention and compensation claims from landlords and developers. Report P48, P49, P50
What happens next
Communities Scrutiny Group to consider the matter at its July meeting, examining the evidence base, the intended and unintended impacts of a Direction, and whether one would be proportionate, enforceable and aligned with local and national policy.
Officers to continue monitoring the overall number of HMOs in the Borough and any complaints received, with the evidence base dated as at January 2026. Report P6, 3.3, 5.3
If the position changes in future, an Equality Impact Assessment would be required before any new policy is implemented. Report P64
Options considered
Rejected: Implement a Borough-wide Article 4 Direction for HMOs. Low number of HMOs across the Borough and very low number of complainants does not support use of such powers; would not meet the robust evidence test for a wide area. Report 5.1, 5.2, P22
Rejected: Implement an area-specific Article 4 Direction, for example in West Bridgford. Although 184 known HMOs are in West Bridgford, the low number of complainants and lack of evidence of adverse impact on amenity and well-being is insufficient. Report 5.2, 4.10, 4.12
Chosen: Continue monitoring HMO numbers and complaints, with referral to Communities Scrutiny Group. Prudent approach given current evidence; allows future review if conditions change. Report 5.3, 3.3
Rejected: Stop monitoring HMOs and complaints. Evidence is only current as at January 2026, so ongoing monitoring is needed to evidence any future case. Report 5.3
Implications
Financial: Agreeing the recommendation results in little to no financial implications; ongoing monitoring would use some staff resource but at current complaint levels this would be minimal. Report P60
Legal: Some legal challenge from residents is possible, but the implications are minimal compared with the risks of implementing an Article 4 without sufficient grounds, notice or consultation. Any future withdrawal of permitted development rights could give rise to compensation liability. Report P62, P63, P50
Equalities: No Equality Impact Assessment is required at this stage as no new policy is being introduced. An EIA would be required if an Article 4 were implemented in future. Report P64
Risk: Risks of implementing an Article 4 without robust evidence include court challenge to the order, intervention by the Secretary of State, and compensation claims from landlords whose permitted development rights are withdrawn. Report P48, P49, P50
Other: Possible unintended consequences of an Article 4 include reducing the supply of affordable accommodation for those on lower incomes, young professionals and students, and displacing HMOs to other, less sustainably located areas of the Borough. Report P52, P53, 4.28
Staffing: Current HMO regulation is delivered through licensing and ongoing review of licensed properties, with complaints investigated and informal action taken where needed. Report 4.15, 4.14
Who and where
Operators and landlords of Houses in Multiple Occupation across Rushcliffe, particularly in West Bridgford Report 4.10, 4.11, P29
Residents of Rushcliffe, especially in West Bridgford, who may be concerned about HMO concentrations Report 4.12
People on lower incomes, young professionals and students who rely on HMOs for affordable accommodation Report 4.9, P52
The Council itself, in its role as Local Planning Authority and HMO licensing body Report 1.3, 4.3, 4.15
Timeline
18 September 2025: Rushcliffe Borough Council Full Council debated a motion on perceived increases in small HMOs and directed officers to investigate an Article 4 Direction. Report 1.1, 1.2
2024: No complaints relating to HMOs were received by the Council. Report 4.12
2025: Four complaints from four residents were received regarding two HMO properties, three of them relating to the same property in Compton Acres and one in West Bridgford; one complainant made 271 complaints about one property. Report 4.12, 4.14
As at January 2026: Evidence base compiled by officers and presented to Cabinet. Report 5.3
10 February 2026: Cabinet decided not to implement an Article 4 Direction and to refer the matter to Communities Scrutiny Group.
July (next meeting): Communities Scrutiny Group to scrutinise key lines of enquiry on evidence, impacts and proportionality.
Plain English for the jargon
Article 4 Direction: A legal tool that removes or restricts certain permitted development rights in a defined area, requiring a planning application before specified development can take place.
HMO (House in Multiple Occupation): A rental property housing at least three people from different households who share facilities such as kitchens and bathrooms. Licensing is required at five or more occupants from different households.
Permitted development rights: Automatic planning permission granted by national rules for certain types of development, which can be removed or restricted by an Article 4 Direction.
Use Class C3 / C4: Planning use classes covering a dwellinghouse (C3) and a small House in Multiple Occupation of three to six unrelated people sharing facilities (C4).
NPPF and PPG: The National Planning Policy Framework and the Planning Practice Guidance, which set national policy and guidance on planning, including the use of Article 4 Directions.
What was decided, why, and what happens next
Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.
Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
Item59
Resolved
It was RESOLVED that Cabinet: a) confirms that there is insufficient evidence to meet the legal threshold to justify an Article 4 Direction to remove or restrict permitted development rights for Houses of Multiple Occupation (HMOs) in the Borough; b) requests that the number of HMOs and complaints received continues to be monitored; and c) requests that the matter is referred to Communities Scrutiny Group at the July meeting to scrutinise the following key lines of enquiry: · Is there a robust evidence base demonstrating harm or risk of harm? · What are the likely impacts – intended and unintended – of introducing an Article 4 Direction to remove or restrict permitted development rights for HMOs? · Is making a Direction proportionate, enforceable and aligned with local and national policy?
Word for word from the decision Rushcliffe published for this meeting.Source: democracy.rushcliffe.gov.uk
1.1At the Rushcliffe Borough Council (RBC) Full Council meeting of 18 September 2025, a motion was debated about a perception that the authority is experiencing an increase in small Houses of Multiple Occupation (HMO) falling within Planning Use Class C4.
1.2Councillors directed officers to investigate and collate an evidence base to look at whether there is a case for introducing an Article 4 Direction across the Borough, which would remove permitted development rights for HMOs of three to six unrelated people sharing facilities, like kitchens and bathrooms.
1.3The purpose of this report is to inform Cabinet of the evidence collected in support of implementation of an Article 4 Direction to remove permitted development rights, which would introduce a new requirement for submission of a planning application to the Local Planning Authority (LPA) for planning permission to change from a Use Class C3 Dwellinghouse to a Use Class C4 HMO across the Borough.
Recommendation
It is RECOMMENDED that Cabinet:
a) confirms that there is insufficient evidence to meet the legal threshold to justify an Article 4 Direction to remove or restrict permitted development rights for Houses of Multiple Occupation (HMO) in the Borough; and
b) requests that the number of HMOs and complaints received continues to be monitored
Reasons for recommendation
3.1Following investigative work, there is insufficient evidence to support the implementation of an Article 4 Direction covering the entire Borough, given the known numbers and distribution of HMOs. 3.2. The evidence shows a greater concentration of HMO properties in West Bridgford; however, even here, the evidence is insufficient to justify the implementation of an Article 4 Direction for this area. In 2025, the Council received four complaints regarding two HMO properties. Of the four complainants, one complainant made 271 complaints regarding one property, which were investigated and informal action taken. In 2024, no complaints were received in relation to HMOs.
3.3It is recommended that Cabinet agrees to the continued monitoring of the overall number of HMOs and any complaints received.
4. Supporting Information
Houses of Multiple Occupation
4.1A HMO is a rental property, which houses at least three people from different households who share facilities like kitchens and bathrooms. The legal threshold for licensing a HMO is at an occupancy of five or more people from different households. Licenses cannot be sought for HMOs of three or four person occupancy.
4.2Planning permission for HMOs is required in the following circumstances:
o to create a large HMO (7+ occupants); or
o if a property falls within an Article 4 area, planning permission is required for three to six person occupancy.
Article 4 Direction
4.3An Article 4 Direction is a legislative tool used to remove or restrict certain permitted development rights, including change of use, from an area or specific property in certain limited situations where it is necessary to protect local amenity or the well-being of an area.
4.4In removing specific permitted development rights, an Article 4 Direction does not prevent the type of development specified but instead requires an application for planning permission to be made prior to any development within that use class taking place. In making an Article 4 Direction, an LPA can be liable to pay compensation to those whose development rights have been withdrawn or restricted by the Direction.
4.5The National Planning Policy Framework (NPPF), paragraph 54 states that Article 4 implementation should:
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.