CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Rushmoor Borough Council
Cabinet, Tuesday 21 April 2026 at 7.00pm

FARNBOROUGH CIVIC QUARTER - STRATEGIC REVIEW

Approved Executive 1 paper

AI summaryRushmoor Cabinet approves £98,000 for a strategic review of the Farnborough Civic Quarter, funded from the Stability and Resilience Reserve.

AI summaryIn plain English

Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeApprovedStrategic Delivery Review of Farnborough Civic Quarter
Money£98,000Funded from the Stability and Resilience Reserve
What happens nextCabinet to receive reportRegeneration Team to report back with suggested next steps
Who it affectsFarnborough town centre regenerationLand assembly, outline masterplan and council finances

What was decided

Cabinet approved a budget of £98,000 to carry out a Strategic Delivery Review of the Farnborough Civic Quarter. Report 3.1

The budget is to be funded from the Stability and Resilience Reserve. Report 4.5

Why

Since the 2023 outline permission for the masterplan, several parameters have shifted, including highways layout, the Building Safety Act, housing market conditions and intended uses on key plots, which have reduced the scheme's viability. Report 2.1, 2.2

The Council Delivery Plan 2026-28 requires a masterplan review, including work on phasing, funding and implementation for Farnborough town centre regeneration. Report P3

The review is needed to establish a robust land value, test development options, and put the council in a strong position to negotiate with partners, investors or land purchasers. Report 3.2, 3.3, 3.5

What happens next

The Regeneration Team will report back to Cabinet with suggested next steps once the review is complete. Report 3.7, 5.1

The Pagabo Framework Lot 1 with Atkins Realis as lead consultant will be used to commission the work, running until April 2028. Report 3.8, 3.10

A saving will need to be identified to replace use of the reserve, to be reviewed alongside the MTFS and Outturn review due in summer 2026. Report 4.5

The money

  • £98,000 Total budget for the Strategic Delivery Review, funded from the Stability and Resilience Reserve Report 3.11, 4.5
  • £25,000 Commercial advice element of the review Report 3.11
  • £25,000 Architectural and landscape design element Report 3.11
  • £15,000 Cost consultancy element Report 3.11
  • £10,000 Planning advice element Report 3.11
  • £10,000 Transport advice element Report 3.11
  • £4,000 Coordination element Report 3.11
  • £9,000 10% contingency Report 3.11
  • £7.4m Council investment in FCQ land assembly between 2020 and 2022, funded by borrowing Report 4.4
  • £420k Annual interest and MRP cost on the land assembly borrowing, charged to the revenue account Report 4.4
  • £1.72m One Public Estate Brownfield Land Release Fund II grant received by the council Report 3.12
  • £716k Grant already spent on demolition of Pinehurst car park; due for repayment on 31st March 2027 if housing development is not actively pursued Report 3.12, 4.4

Options considered

  • Chosen: Commission a Strategic Delivery Review via the Pagabo Framework Lot 1 with Atkins Realis. Competitively tendered rates, minimised procurement risk, ability to reprocure the same team, and needed to comply with the Council Delivery Plan Report 3.8, 3.9, 3.10, 3.11
  • Rejected: Do nothing. Would prevent delivery of Council Delivery Plan objectives and put at risk repayment of the £716k One Public Estate grant due on 31st March 2027 Report 3.12
  • Rejected: Procure specialist advice directly through separate procurements. Five independent procurements are beyond current council capacity, create significant procurement risk, and would not allow a tailored delivery team Report 3.13

Implications

  • Financial: Use of the Stability and Resilience Reserve will reduce reserves available to meet projected budget gaps, so a saving will need to be identified. Report 4.5
  • Financial: Without an approved scheme, the £7.4m of borrowing for land assembly continues to cost about £420k a year on the revenue account. Report 4.4
  • Risk: The £716k One Public Estate grant must be repaid on 31st March 2027 if housing development is not actively pursued, which would have to be funded by unsupported borrowing. Report 3.12, 4.4
  • Risk: There is a risk the review could find no development option that creates land value, though this is considered unlikely given the ongoing sale of Meads Block 3. Report 4.1
  • Risk: Carrying out the review reduces the risk of grant clawback and supports an unconditional land sale as a backstop option. Report 4.2
  • Legal: No specific legal implications; the review will support future decision-making on this asset. Report 4.3
  • Equalities: An Equalities Impact Assessment screening found the proposal to have a neutral impact, so no further assessment is required. Report 4.7, P31
  • Staffing: The review will be coordinated within existing resources in the Regeneration team. Report 4.6, P29

Who and where

  • Rushmoor Borough Council, as landowner and accountable body for the One Public Estate grant Report 2.1, 3.12, 4.4
  • The Rushmoor Development Partnership, which holds the February 2023 outline permission Report 2.1, P41
  • Farnborough town centre residents and businesses, given the planned leisure centre, up to 960 homes, hotel, shopping, skatepark, green space and mobility hubs Report P41
  • Potential development partners, investors and land purchasers, with whom the council will negotiate once land value is established Report 3.5

Timeline

  • February 2023: Development Management Committee approved outline permission for the FCQ masterplan Report 2.1
  • February 2026: Council approved the current Medium Term Financial Strategy Report 4.5
  • 2026-04-21: Cabinet decision to approve the £98,000 review budget
  • Summer 2026: MTFS and Outturn review will consider the saving needed to replace the reserve use Report 4.5
  • 31st March 2027: Deadline for repayment of the £716k One Public Estate grant if a housing development is not demonstrably being actively pursued Report 3.12, 4.4
  • April 2028: End date of the Pagabo Framework, allowing the same team to be reprocured if the council proceeds with development Report 3.10

Plain English for the jargon

  • FCQ: Farnborough Civic Quarter, the town centre regeneration area covered by the masterplan
  • Strategic Delivery Review (SDR): An independent review of land value and deliverability of the FCQ, based on a residual valuation approach
  • Residual valuation: A method of valuing land by subtracting total development costs from total development value, with the remainder treated as the land value
  • One Public Estate grant: Brownfield Land Release Fund II grant of £1.72m, of which £716k has been spent on demolishing Pinehurst car park
  • Pagabo Framework: A procurement framework used to appoint consultants, with Lot 1 covering Complete Service Solutions
  • Stability and Resilience Reserve: Council reserve proposed to fund the £98,000 review, whose use will reduce balances available for budget gaps
What was decided, why, and what happens next

Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.

Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
Item89

Resolved

RESOLVED that the provision of a budget of £98,000 to carry out the review be approved, to be funded from the Stability and Resilience Reserve.
Word for word from the decision Rushmoor published for this meeting. Source: democracy.rushmoor.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Rushmoor's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Cabinet

Background

2.1In February 2023, the Council’s Development Management Committee approved an outline permission in relation to the FCQ masterplan. Unfortunately, since the masterplans proposals were considered, a number of underlying parameters have shifted, negatively impacting the viability of the scheme in the current economic climate.

2.2In the Council Delivery Plan 2026-28 under the regeneration priority the following activity is required:

“Undertake the Farnborough Civic Quarter masterplan review and work with key partners on potential phasing, funding, and implementation as part of a wider approach to the regeneration of Farnborough town centre.” 3. DETAILS OF THE PROPOSAL

General scope of review

3.1It is proposed that the Council commissions a Strategic Delivery Review to inform regeneration activity on FCQ. The brief for the delivery review is below at Appendix I. This work is necessary to understand the real value of the Council’s FCQ land assembly, and what is deliverable under a variety of economic and policy scenarios.

3.2The accepted methodology for working out the value of land is via a ‘residual valuation’. This subtracts the total cost of development (construction, fees etc) from the total value of that development (sales and capitalised lettings), and the result is the residual valuation of the land.

3.3In order to generate an accurate valuation, work has to be carried out in terms of design studies, cost plans, commercial advice on sales/rental values and planning/transport consultancy to ensure the assumptions that the residual valuation is based on have been robustly tested.

3.4To avoid producing a delivery plan that is unaffordable the review will start by developing a housing-led base case that generates the highest land value possible i.e. the Council acting in the same way as a commercial property owner. This will include meeting current planning policy obligations and any other non-negotiable requirements e.g. regulations or existing grant agreements.

3.5Having a fully worked out base case and resulting land value will mean that the Council is in a very strong position to negotiate with any potential partners, investors or purchasers of land on FCQ.

3.6Beyond the base case the review will consider further options to include other Council requirements, for example in relation to affordable housing, public realm, transportation, wider placemaking etc, beyond those which a commercial property owner might consider, resulting in a preferred option to be progressed that best fits the council’s objectives. The review will also consider what the best route is to delivery.

3.7Once the review has taken place the Regeneration Team will report back to Cabinet with suggested next steps.

Procurement & Cost

3.8It is proposed that the Council uses the Pagabo Framework Lot 1 - Complete Service Solutions. This would utilise Atkins Realis, a national construction industry consultant to lead the review and provide cost advice, while giving flexibility in terms of sub-consultants to ensure that the Council gets exactly the right specialist input in terms of design, commercial and planning advice.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
FARNBOROUGH CIVIC QUARTER: STRATEGIC REVIEWReport 454 KB DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

5 of 6 attended
GA
Councillor Gaynor AustinCommittee Member, apologies
KD
Councillor Keith DibbleCommittee Member, present
CG
Councillor Christine GuinnessCommittee Member, present
JH
Councillor Julie HallCommittee Member, present
SP
Councillor Sophie PorterVice-Chair, present
GW
Councillor Gareth WilliamsChair, present

On this subject at Rushmoor

Search all
  1. FARNBOROUGH CIVIC QUARTER - STRATEGIC REVIEWThis decision
  2. Farnborough civic quarter regeneration - strategic delivery reviewNoted
  3. Planning Application No.: 22/00193/OUTPP - Farnborough Civic QuarterDecided
  4. Farnborough leisure and civic hub – approval of outline business case and next stepsApproved
  5. Farnborough civic quarter masterplan supplementary planning documentApproved

More from Rushmoor Cabinet

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
20 Oct 2026 Budget management - month 4RESOLVED that (i) the revenue budget forecast, as set out in Section 3 of Report No. FIN2617, be noted; (ii) the writ... Noted Open
20 Oct 2026 Temporary accommodation placement policyRESOLVED that (i) the Temporary Accommodation Placement Policy, as set out in Appendix 1 of Report No. PG2617, be app... Approved Open
20 Oct 2026 Farnborough civic quarter regeneration - strategic delivery reviewRESOLVED that (i) the outcome of the Strategic Delivery Review exercise, as set out in Report No. REG2604, be noted ;... Noted Open
15 Sep 2026 Crisis and resilience fundRESOLVED that the information within Report No. ED2615, including work underway to support residents’ financial resil... Noted Open
15 Sep 2026 Young people’s planRESOLVED that (i) the approach to the production of the Young People’s Plan, including to support and engage with all... Agreed Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies