What was decided
Cabinet noted the Strategic Delivery Review. It found that no tested scenario produced positive land value and that the original whole site approach could not proceed through a development agreement or joint venture. Report 3.2, 3.5
Cabinet approved the key principles in paragraph 5.3, as amended at the meeting. The listed principles cover land sale to satisfy grant requirements, a capital receipt, town centre development in line with the current masterplan, early removal of hoardings, new permanent or temporary amenities and improved public realm. Report P31, P32, P33, P34
The Executive Head of Property and Growth, Executive Head of Governance and Law, and Executive Head of Finance and Section 151 Officer were authorised, in consultation with the Housing, Planning & Property Portfolio Holder, to progress the sale of Plot B for housing or other uses within the wider masterplan scope. The Executive Director, Executive Head of Governance and Law, and Executive Head of Finance and Section 151 Officer were authorised, in consultation with the Economy, Skills & Regeneration Portfolio Holder, to agree the grant variation. Legal and agency fees would be met from the capital receipt in due course.
Why
The review found that no tested scenario was viable because none produced positive land value. It also found that the project had become substantially less viable since the 2022 planning decision. Report 3.2
Global events raised material and construction costs, while the Building Safety Act made taller buildings more expensive. Property values remained flat in real terms, interest rates rose sharply, and Farnborough's small market made large developments slow to sell. Report P14, P15, P16, P17, P18
The former funding model relied on private residential sales to pay for infrastructure, affordable housing and wider benefits, but maximising housing units made viability worse. The expected whole site routes were not deliverable because of economic and regulatory pressures and uncertainty over the local authority entity during Local Government Reorganisation. Doing nothing would also trigger grant repayment without improvement or a capital receipt. Report 3.4, 3.5, 6.1
What happens next
Develop a detailed marketing and disposal strategy, then continue engagement with potential purchasers before deciding the final parcelisation options. Plot B remains the preferred first site because it is cleared, accessible and ready for redevelopment. Report 5.10, 5.11
Prepare separate outline business cases for skate park refurbishment, a reduced Meudon Avenue speed limit and Farnborough Fields on the former community centre and police station sites. Further spending, including the £36,159 feasibility request, should wait for clear direction on the post LGR MTFS deficit. Report 10.2, 10.5, 11.1
Officers should explore a Meudon Avenue scheme with Hampshire County Council, including a possible new pelican crossing and an above ground walking and cycling route. Report 5.23, 5.24
The money
- £1,725,636 One Public Estate capital grant for masterplan delivery. The do nothing option calls for returning £1.7m. Report 2.5, 6.1
- £662k Spent on Pinehurst Car Park demolition. It and the unspent grant must be returned if grant requirements are not met. Report 2.7
- £300k One Public Estate Phase 9 grant received in 2024 and used for Public Sector Hub design work. Report 2.8
- £225k Refundable Phase 9 grant linked to the sale of the Council Offices. Repayment is due by June 2027, but the date is negotiable with a clear intent and an alternative Civic Quarter plot disposal. Report 2.8, 5.8
- £7.4m Outstanding borrowing from land accumulation and demolition. The net Plot B capital receipt will reduce it. Report 10.3, 10.4
- £418,000 Annual interest and MRP cost payable for the next 47 years. Report 10.4
- £36,159 Feasibility funding request. Further spending is held until there is a clear direction on the post LGR MTFS deficit. Report 10.5, 11.1
Options considered
- Chosen: Progressive sale of individual plots. The masterplan cannot proceed as intended. Selling one or more plots with preferred uses but no full masterplan may attract the market, meet grant terms and reduce the risk of returning grant funding. Report 5.4, 5.5, 5.6
- Rejected: Whole site development agreement or joint venture. The review found that neither expected route was deliverable because of economic and regulatory pressures and uncertainty over the future local authority entity. Report 3.5
- Rejected: Do nothing. This would require returning the £1.7m Brownfield Land Release Fund and refunding £225k in 2027, with no capital receipt. It would also leave the town centre unimproved and could reduce the value of Council assets. Report 6.1
- Rejected: Sell part of the site with no interim or meanwhile action. This would meet the grant obligations but provide little beyond possible housing and no wider improvements. Unavoidable costs would likely increase, along with deterioration and vandalism of the hoardings and vegetation growth. Report 6.2
Implications
- Financial: Failure to meet the One Public Estate grant conditions would require repayment, with a significant detrimental effect on the Council's already depleting reserves. The repayment position must be revisited and reconciled. Report 2.7, 2.8, 10.1
- Financial: Net capital receipt from the Plot B sale will reduce £7.4m of Civic Quarter borrowing. Legal and agency fees and later legal support will also come from the receipt, while the annual interest and MRP cost is £418,000 for the next 47 years. Report 9.1, 10.4
- Staffing: Existing resources are expected to meet the recommendation's human resource needs. The £36,159 feasibility request should not proceed until there is clear direction on the post LGR MTFS deficit. Report 11.1, 10.5
- Legal: The report identifies no additional legal implications from its content. Legal support and budget will be needed as implementation proceeds, and the governance issue in paragraph 10.1 must be addressed. Report 9.1
- Equalities: The Equality Impact Screening Assessment found positive or neutral impacts for all protected characteristics, so a full Equality Impact Assessment is not required. Report P72
- Climate: The current disposal and early feasibility work has no fixed outcome, so a full climate impact assessment cannot yet be completed. Officers must revisit the screening tool and full matrix after a purchaser is identified and detailed business cases are prepared. Report 13.2, 13.3, 13.4
- Risk: Sale of land reduces the Council's grant funding risk. Further interventions from feasibility studies would need agreed business cases and further approval. Report 8.1
- Other: A sale to a Registered Provider could bring forward town centre housing and affordable accommodation, increase footfall for local businesses and mean more people are present to watch public spaces. Meanwhile uses can revitalise vacant sites and produce revenue, but leases of 5 to 10 years delay permanent disposal. Report 5.9, 5.16, 5.17, 5.18
Who and where
- Farnborough town centre residents and visitors Report P32, P33, P34, 5.9
- People seeking affordable housing in Farnborough town centre Report 5.9
- Registered Providers, including housing associations Report 4.2, 5.9
- Care home developers Report 4.2, 5.10
- Build to rent developers Report 4.2, 5.10
- Local businesses near the Civic Quarter Report 5.9
- People using the public open space and skate park Report 5.19, 5.21
- Council land and assets Report 5.22, 6.1
Timeline
- February 2022: The outline masterplan was approved by the Development Management Committee. Report 2.2
- August 2023: The Council received One Public Estate capital funding for the Brownfield Land Release Fund. Report 2.5
- 2024: The Council obtained One Public Estate Phase 9 funding for Public Sector Hub design work. Report 2.8
- April 2026: Cabinet agreed the Strategic Delivery Review, and Atkins Realis was subsequently appointed over the summer. Report 2.4
- 31 March 2027: The longstop date for Land Release. It may be extended if there is a clear alternative housing pathway. Report 2.6
- June 2027: The refundable £225k Phase 9 grant was due for repayment, although the date was negotiable. Report 2.8
- before 2029/30: The report said a new unitary authority was not likely, so some intervention costs were unavoidable. Report 6.2
Plain English for the jargon
- One Public Estate: The organisation that provided the Brownfield Land Release Fund and Phase 9 grants. [2.5][2.8]
- Brownfield Land Release Fund: A capital grant programme for preparing and remediating land for housing in line with the masterplan. [2.5]
- Plot B: The cleared former leisure centre site, identified as the preferred first site for disposal. [5.11]
- Parcellisation: Selling a plot or plots with preferred uses without setting out a full masterplan for the site. [5.5]
- Meanwhile use: A temporary lease, usually for 5 to 10 years, used while waiting for permanent redevelopment. [5.16][5.18]
- Local Government Reorganisation: The planned creation of a new unitary authority, whose timing and identity uncertainty affected potential development partners. [3.5]
- MTFS: The Council's budget and financial strategy framework, which it must keep legally balanced using reserves. [10.5]
- MRP: A charge payable alongside interest on the Civic Quarter borrowing for the next 47 years. [10.4]