Refused against officer recommendation as Members considered that due to the assertive modern design with its use of extensive areas of glazing, raked corner profile, and asymmetric cladding panels, together with the scale and massing of the proposal (particularly in relation to the High Street setting) the proposal would be out of scale and harmfully dominant in the street-scene, and would disrupt and compete with the more restrained detailing of existing development. It would therefore result in substantial harm to the character and appearance of the conservation area and would be contrary to the NPPF and Policy P16 of the Solihull Local Plan (2013).
Word for word from the decision Solihull published for this meeting.Source: democracy.solihull.gov.uk
Location: 159 - 161 HIGH STREET AND 5 - 7 DRURY LANE SOLIHULL
Date Registered: 01/12/2014
Applicant: IM PROPERTIES (MELL SQUARE) LLP
Proposal: DEMOLITION OF 159-161 HIGH STREET AND 5-7 DRURY LANE, AND ERECTION OF A FOUR STOREY BUILDING WITH A RESTAURANT (CLASS A3) AT GROUND FLOOR AND OFFICES (CLASS B1) ABOVE.
This application is being reported to Planning Committee for the following reason(s):
The proposals are a substantial departure from the Development Plan A new section 106 agreement is required x The proposals would have a significant impact outside of its immediate vicinity The proposals have given rise to substantial weight of public concern The application has been called into Committee by a Member The application has been submitted by (or on behalf of) the Council (or it relates to Council owned land) and there has been one objection or more. The applicant is a Member or Officer of the Council (who has contact with Development Management) (or a close relative of such a person) The Head of Development Management has elected to refer the application to Committee
PROPOSAL
This application seeks planning consent to demolish the building within the conservation area, and for the construction of the new four storey building. This would comprise three storeys occupying the full plot area to High Street and Drury Lane boundaries with the fourth floor as a glazed and metal clad structure set in from both the High Street and Drury Lane edges. This would leave an L-shaped external amenity area approximately 3 metres deep from the High Street facade and 1.5 metres from the side elevation façade, defended by a glazed balustrade.
The building would provide a restaurant with kitchen and other service space at ground floor and three floors of office accommodation above. It would follow the current building line with the facade set back slightly from the RBS bank building to its west and with the appealing curved facade to the long Drury Lane elevation. The ground floor elevations to the streets would be fully glazed apart from the panel of stone cladding to the left of the entrance and a narrow recessed panel of brickwork linking the proposed building and the RBS bank from ground to second floor.
The predominant cladding material would be a light coloured mineral based render system over first and second floor wall surfaces above the ground floor, with aluminium framed glazed curtain wall wrapping around the corner. Window modules would occupy a significant proportion of the first and second floor elevations. These project slightly from the wall surface and would have obscure lower panels. Other external finishes include the brick panel, stone cladding to some pilasters between ground floor windows, and a vertical timber band at the side of window modules at first and second floor. The fourth floor accommodation would be set back from the front and side elevations with glazed curtain walling to 60% of the elevation and metal rainscreen cladding elsewhere. A glass balustrade would defend the perimeter to create a usable outdoor space offering new views of heritage assets and roofscapes. Full height glazing through all four floors would enclose the stair core adjacent to Drury Lane. The combined effect would be of a building of roughly 50 per cent glazing above a ground floor of around 90 per cent clear or obscured full height windows. Where these would be obscured to conceal kitchens and other service space it is important that this is achieved in a way that ensures a sympathetic view from the street. This is no doubt what the applicant would desire as it is part of the initial offer to potential customers.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.