Item1
Resolved
TREE PRESERVATION ORDER APPEALS PANEL 10 MARCH 2016 Present: Councillors Davis (Chairman), Hogarth, and Windmill. Officers: Santokh Gill (Solicitor), Charles Venables (Forestry), David Wigfield (Planning). TREE PRESERVATIN ORDER NO 1031 63 HARGRAVE ROAD, SOLIHULL LODGE The Panel were advised that the Order was made following expressions of concern that pruning might adversely affect the health and amenity value of the prominent tree adjoining a primary distributor road. It was considered appropriate to protect the tree and secure its public amenity value as it made a strong contribution to the character of the area. An objection was received to the Order, which is summarised as:- · The Oak prevents safe use of garden in the autumn; falling acorns and leaves cover the back garden causing a slippery and dangerous surface for anyone in the garden. The back garden needs to be cleared each time our child wants to play out there due to the above; · High winds during the winter cause branches and acorns to fall from considerable height which could harm anyone in the garden; · Some west facing branches are about three metres from the back wall and could damage the property; · A considerable part of the crown overhangs the back garden bringing substantial shadow and blocking sunlight during the summer; · The tree has not been maintained regularly and grows rapidly in an uncontrolled manner; if not looked after it could damage private and public property (such as fencing, house, schools green area and other trees); · During our two-and-a-half years occupancy the owner has not undertaken any maintenance which leads to uncontrolled and dangerous growth; and · After discussion with the owner a local tree surgeon was consulted, and advised that to maintain healthy growth and balance the oak tree needs to be pruned regularly all around the crown (including school area). The Panel considered the written submissions of the objector and the responses of the Council’s Forestry and Planning Officers. resolved That Tree Preservation Order 1031 was confirmed without modification. TREE PRESERVATION ORDER APPEALS PANEL 10 MARCH 2016 Present: Councillors Davis (Chairman), Hogarth, and Windmill. Officers: Santokh Gill (Solicitor), Charles Venables (Forestry), David Wigfield (Planning). Others: [name removed] (Objector) and [name removed] (Cotswold Wildlife Surveys Ltd). 2 tree preservation order no. 1033 LAND TO THE REAR OF 51-53 HANBURY ROAD, DORRIDGE The Panel were advised that the Order was made following concerns that proposed development might adversely affect the health and amenity value of the prominent trees or produce future demands for their reduction without control over the quality of such works. It was considered appropriate to protect the trees and secure their public amenity value as they made a strong contribution to the character of the area. An objection was received to the Order, which is summarised as:- · There is no objection to the inclusion of T3 Acer Plantanoides (Norway Maple); · Tree T1 Picea Abies (Norway Spruce) is a former Christmas tree planted out and now causing shadow and concerns regarding falling branches, and requiring lower branch trimming to prevent ...
Word for word from the decision Solihull published for this meeting.
Source: democracy.solihull.gov.uk