CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Solihull Metropolitan Borough Council
TPO Panel, Tuesday 22 January 2019 at 3.00pm

TPO 1178 - 207 Green Hill Way, Shirley

Decided Committee 2 papers

TPO Panel decided this item on Tuesday 22 January 2019. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item1

Resolved

The Panel were advised that the Order was made following the assessment of a planning application at this site for a change of use from dwelling house (C3) to house of multiple-occupancy (C4) and with extensions to the side and rear, the latter of which would potentially place the retention of the Oak tree at risk. Any extensions would be built within the existing root protection area of the tree and also into its canopy. It was considered appropriate to protect the tree which contributed to the character and distinctiveness of the area by way of public amenity value. An objection was received to the Order which is summarised as:- · You have not served proper notice. There is no owner/occupier at the address as the property has been vacant since September 2017. The Council should be well aware that this is the case; · There is no known species your amenity assessment is not considered to be correct. of tree known by the name Qercus (sic) Robur ; · Your amenity assessment is not considered to be correct. In fact looking at the way you have assessed the tree which we might assume to be the TPO target, it seems that you may have mistaken a tree approximately 5metres away in the land in the crematorium when assessing some of the relevant scores; · Specifically as follows in relation to the Oak tree within the curtilage of 207 Green Hill Way:- I believe the tree is in poor condition, but do not demur from your view that the form is poor. The reason that the form is poor, leaning considerably over the crematorium land, as it does, and lacking any semblance of symmetry, is because there have been frequent branch fractures, leading to an estimated loss of 30% of the trees structure. These have been occasioned by normal weather events leading to ground-fall of very substantial branches in to the garden during high winds and snowfall. There have been several of these events over the last 4-5 years an I see no reason to believe that pattern of events will not continue. This must be down to the poor condition of the tree. I therefore believe the score here should be poor 1-1 (poor form) = 0 point; · Similarly because of the comparative recent history I would think a life expectancy of less than 20 years is far more realistic and believe the score here should be Just Suitable (1 point); · The relevant public visibility issue is clearly an issue. This tree is barely visible from the street because of trees in land to the front of the house and the substantial oak tree adjacent on the crematorium land. From the rear the tree is screened by a huge oak tree in the adjoining garden of the house in Streetsbrook Road. The score here should, respectfully, be 2. I believe that the assessor has mistaken the adjacent tree on the crematorium land as being the tree in question. That tree almost completely screens the ...
Word for word from the decision Solihull published for this meeting. Source: democracy.solihull.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Solihull's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to TPO Panel

METROPOLITAN BOROUGH OF SOLIHULL

PLANNING COMMITTEE

TREE PRESERVATION ORDERS

MAKING OBJECTIONS OR REPRESENTATIONS

A GUIDE

Including the

Terms of Reference and Procedures

for the

Tree Preservation Orders Appeals Panel

February 2016

1 MAKING OBJECTIONS OR REPRESENTATIONS TO TREE PRESERVATION ORDERS................... 3

1. INTRODUCTION ........................................................................................................ 3 2. RELEVANT LEGAL BACKGROUND TO TREE PRESERVATION ORDERS ........................... 3 3. TYPES OF TREE PRESERVATION ORDER ................................................................... 4 4. PROCEDURE FOR MAKING A TPO ............................................................................. 4 5. MAKING OBJECTIONS OR REPRESENTATIONS ............................................................ 5 6. THE COUNCIL’S RESPONSE TO THE OBJECTION OR REPRESENTATION ........................ 6 7. CONFIRMATION OF A TPO WHERE THERE ARE NO OBJECTIONS OR WHERE OBJECTIONS HAVE BEEN WITHDRAWN FOLLOWING DISCUSSION, CLARIFICATION OR MODIFICATION. .. 7

8. POWERS OF THE COUNCIL’S TREE PRESERVATION ORDERS APPEALS PANEL ............. 7 9. COMPOSITION OF THE PANEL ................................................................................... 7 10. MEETING OF THE TPO PANEL .................................................................................. 7 11. PROCEDURE BEFORE THE PANEL MEETING ............................................................... 8 12. WHO ATTENDS FROM THE COUNCIL .......................................................................... 8 13. PROCEDURE OF THE PANEL MEETING WHERE OBJECTOR IS PRESENT ......................... 8 14. PROCEDURE OF THE PANEL MEETING WHERE OBJECTOR DOES NOT APPEAR ......................................................................................................................... 9 15. APPEAL TO THE SECRETARY OF STATE FOR THE ENVIRONMENT, TRANSPORT & THE REGIONS .............................................................................................................. 10 16. APPLICATIONS TO FELL OR CARRY OUT WORKS TO A TREE PROTECTED BY A TPO ..... 10 17. TREE REPLACEMENT.............................................................................................. 10 18. COMPENSATION .................................................................................................... 11 19.. FELLING LICENSES................................................................................................. 11 20.. NOTES .................................................................................................................. 11 21. CONTACTS ............................................................................................................ 11

2 Planning Committee Making Objections or representations to Tree Preservation Orders

A Guide

A copy of this guidance note is to be sent to every recipient of a Tree Preservation Order together with information leaflets on protected trees

1. Introduction These notes are intended to advise anyone who wishes to respond to a Tree Preservation Order on the procedures that need to be followed.

They are not intended to be a statement of the law, nor do they cover all aspects of Preservation Orders. The Tree Preservation Order contains a detailed recital of all the necessary legal provisions and you should read it carefully.

If you have queries, you should telephone Council enquiries at 0121 704 6000 and ask for the Conservation Planner, or you may wish to discuss legal queries with a solicitor or other professional advisor. A reference in these notes to “Authority” or “local authority” means the Solihull Metropolitan Borough Council as Local Planning Authority.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
TPO 1178: 207 Green Hill Way, ShirleyReport 266 KB DownloadRead as text
PDF
TPO1178GHW220119Report 1.2 MB Download

At this meeting

Whole meeting
1TPO 1178 - 207 Green Hill Way, ShirleyThis decision

Who was there

6 of 6 attended
GS
Councillor Glenis SlaterChairman, present
PH
Councillor Peter Hogarth MBECommittee Member, present
MD
Councillor Mrs Diana Holl-Allen MBECommittee Member, present
SG
Santokh GillOfficer, present
BW
Benn WatkinsonOfficer, present
NW
Nicholas WrightOfficer, present

On this subject at Solihull

Search all
  1. TPO 1178 - 207 Green Hill Way, ShirleyThis decision
  2. Pl/2014/01530/tpo - 87 ludworth avenue, marston greenApproved

More from Solihull TPO Panel

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
11 Jul 2023 Tree Preservation Order 1357 - 2 Gainsborough CrescentRESOLVED The Panel, in view of the information and advice received, considered that Tree Preservation Order No. 01357... Decided Open
20 Mar 2023 Tree Preservation Order 1350 - 176 Norton Lane, EarlswoodRESOLVED In view of the information and advice received, the Panel considered Oak tree (T1) was substantial enough to... Decided Open
12 Aug 2019 TPO 1183 land r/o 20-28 Danford Lane and 24 Westwood GroveThe Panel were advised that the Order was made following concerns of a local resident about a perceived threat to unp... Decided Open
9 Jun 2016 TPO 1036 - 58 Alderbrook Road, SolihullPRESENT:- COUNCILLORS: Potts (Chairman), Slater, and Windmill. OFFICERS: Santokh Gill (Solicitor), and Martin Saunder... Decided Open
9 Jun 2016 TPO 1038 - Rumbush Lane opposite Hirdemons Way, Dickens HeathPERSENT:- COUNCILLORS: Potts (Chairman), Slater, and Windmill OFFICERS; Santokh Gill (Legal), Martin Saunders (Planni... Agreed Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies