Resolved
The Panel were advised that the Order was made following the assessment of a planning application at this site for a change of use from dwelling house (C3) to house of multiple-occupancy (C4) and with extensions to the side and rear, the latter of which would potentially place the retention of the Oak tree at risk. Any extensions would be built within the existing root protection area of the tree and also into its canopy. It was considered appropriate to protect the tree which contributed to the character and distinctiveness of the area by way of public amenity value. An objection was received to the Order which is summarised as:- · You have not served proper notice. There is no owner/occupier at the address as the property has been vacant since September 2017. The Council should be well aware that this is the case; · There is no known species your amenity assessment is not considered to be correct. of tree known by the name Qercus (sic) Robur ; · Your amenity assessment is not considered to be correct. In fact looking at the way you have assessed the tree which we might assume to be the TPO target, it seems that you may have mistaken a tree approximately 5metres away in the land in the crematorium when assessing some of the relevant scores; · Specifically as follows in relation to the Oak tree within the curtilage of 207 Green Hill Way:- I believe the tree is in poor condition, but do not demur from your view that the form is poor. The reason that the form is poor, leaning considerably over the crematorium land, as it does, and lacking any semblance of symmetry, is because there have been frequent branch fractures, leading to an estimated loss of 30% of the trees structure. These have been occasioned by normal weather events leading to ground-fall of very substantial branches in to the garden during high winds and snowfall. There have been several of these events over the last 4-5 years an I see no reason to believe that pattern of events will not continue. This must be down to the poor condition of the tree. I therefore believe the score here should be poor 1-1 (poor form) = 0 point; · Similarly because of the comparative recent history I would think a life expectancy of less than 20 years is far more realistic and believe the score here should be Just Suitable (1 point); · The relevant public visibility issue is clearly an issue. This tree is barely visible from the street because of trees in land to the front of the house and the substantial oak tree adjacent on the crematorium land. From the rear the tree is screened by a huge oak tree in the adjoining garden of the house in Streetsbrook Road. The score here should, respectfully, be 2. I believe that the assessor has mistaken the adjacent tree on the crematorium land as being the tree in question. That tree almost completely screens the ...