Item3
Resolved
PERSENT:- COUNCILLORS: Potts (Chairman), Slater, and Windmill OFFICERS; Santokh Gill (Legal), Martin Saunders (Planning), and Nic Wright (Landscape) OTHERS: [name removed] (Objector), and [name removed] ( Cedarwood Tree Care). TREE PRESERVATION ORDER NO. 1038 LAND OPPOSITE 2 HIRDEMONSWAY AND 153-157 RUMBUSH LANE, DICKENS HEATH The Panel were advised that the Order was made following concerns that proposed development might adversely affect the health and amenity value of the prominent trees or produce future demands for their reduction without control over the quality of such works. It was considered appropriate to protect the trees and secure their public amenity value, as they made a strong contribution to the character of the area, and represented a good survival of the earlier rural character of the area linking with other retained trees and hedgerows as well as new planting agreed for developments nearby. An objection was received to the Order, which is summarised as:- · Trees T7, 8, and 9 (Holly and some Hazel) are included as they form part of the road frontage, and whilst retention is highly desirable their inclusion as ‘trees’ is questionable; · It is considered that there is insufficient space for all three Alders (T13, 14, and 15); · Alders within groups G1 and G2 are five trees that were being felled prior to the original TPO in July 2015; there is dead wood in at least one and the trees are considered dead or of such limited amenity value as to be inappropriate for inclusion in a TPO. It is not accepted that there is potential for the trees to recover and contribute to the local setting. Even if some vegetation is produced this spring the trees are broad poles unsuitable for inclusion in the TPO; · The Ash (T22) is covered in ivy and a full ground-based inspection is not possible, some evidence of localised dieback is visible. It is unlikely that both the Oak (T17) and the Ash can be retained and vehicular access be created to the site. The Oak is considered more important to the site, and it is possible that the Ash will not be in its current vigour within the next ten years; · Group G4 exhibits a high density of trees and an Oak with potential to become an important tree is being overshadowed by more vigorous Alder and Birch around it; if it remains included selective removal of some trees to benefit a smaller number of trees long term should be agreed; and · It appears appropriate on site that T2 (Holly) and T6 (Ash) should be excluded from the TPO if it is confirmed. The Panel considered further written and oral submissions of the objector and his witness, and the responses of the Council’s Landscape and Planning Officers. RESOLVED That, in view of the information and advice received, Tree Preservation Order No. 1038 was confirmed without modification due to the trees visibility and public amenity value.
Word for word from the decision Solihull published for this meeting.
Source: democracy.solihull.gov.uk