AI summaryCabinet approves commissioning an independent external appraisal of the Council's housing delivery arrangements, including the current ALMO model with Solihull Community Housing. No change to current arrangements is made at this stage.
Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeNotedNo change to current housing delivery arrangements
MoneyCost met from existing HRA budgetsNo specific sum given in the papers
What happens nextFurther report to Cabinet after appraisalTo include findings, recommendations and any tenant consultation needs
Who it affectsCouncil tenants and housing servicesCouncil retains landlord and Registered Provider accountability
What was decided
Cabinet approved commissioning an independent external consultant to carry out a comprehensive appraisal of the Council's housing delivery arrangements, including the current ALMO model with Solihull Community Housing. Report P7
Cabinet noted substantial changes to the social housing regulatory regime and the Council's continuing accountability as landlord and Registered Provider. Report P7
Cabinet noted the increased level of Council intervention over the past 18 months, beyond traditional client oversight, to support housing delivery, assurance and risk management. Report P7
Why
The social housing regulatory framework has materially changed, with the Social Housing (Regulation) Act 2023, Building Safety Act 2022 and Fire Safety Act 2021 strengthening landlord duties that rest with the Council and cannot be delegated. Report P15, P16, P17, P18
Over the past 18 months the Council has moved beyond routine client oversight into active delivery support, raising questions about blurred accountability, duplication and the long term sustainability of the current ALMO arrangement. Report P20, P21, 3.9, P23
The Housing Revenue Account faces compounding pressures from inflation, regulatory investment requirements and new competence standards, making it appropriate to test whether the current delivery model delivers value for money. Report P25, P26, 3.12, 3.13
What happens next
Commission the independent appraisal, with SCH and relevant Council services engaged as part of the process. Report P55, 3.19
The appraisal is expected to conclude by the end of the calendar year 2026, after which a further report will be presented to Cabinet with findings and recommendations, including any requirements for tenant consultation. Report 3.19, P7, P54
Any future proposal involving a material change to housing management arrangements will need to have regard to the Section 105 consultation duty under the Housing Act 1985 and the terms of the Management Agreement with SCH. Report P59
Options considered
Chosen: Commission an independent external appraisal of the Council's housing delivery arrangements now. Proportionate way to test whether the current delivery model remains the right fit and to support any future Cabinet decision with a stronger evidence base in a changed regulatory and financial environment. Report P38, P39, 5.1
Rejected: Take no further action and defer the appraisal to a later date. Would not address current regulatory, intervention and financial pressures on the Council as landlord. Report P38, P39
Implications
Financial: Appraisal cost to be met from existing HRA budgets; the appraisal will consider HRA financial sustainability, the HRA Business Plan and the Council's Medium Term Financial Strategy. Report P58
Legal: Council retains statutory landlord responsibility; commissioning the appraisal does not itself change contractual, governance or delivery arrangements, but future material changes would require Section 105 consultation with secure tenants under the Housing Act 1985. Report P18, P59
Equalities: No direct equality implications from commissioning the appraisal, but the appraisal must consider impacts on tenants and residents, including those with protected characteristics. Report 6.7
Risk: Without the appraisal, the Council risks continuing with a delivery model that may not be the most effective basis for managing current regulatory, financial, governance and assurance pressures. Report P61
Staffing: Appraisal will consider leadership capacity, organisational effectiveness and potential alternative delivery models including reintegration in-house, with associated transition, risks and costs. Report P35
Other: No direct corporate parenting implications, though safe housing is recognised as a wider factor supporting children, young people and families. Report P57
Who and where
Solihull Community Housing (SCH) as the current ALMO managing the Council's housing stock of approximately 10,000 homes Report P10
Council tenants and residents of the approximately 10,000 social housing homes Report P10
Council functions delivering housing related services alongside SCH, including homelessness, housing allocations, the Solihull Independent Living Service and private sector housing regulation Report P13
Council as landlord and Registered Provider, retaining statutory accountability Report P18
Timeline
Since 2004: Management of the Council's housing stock has been delivered through Solihull Community Housing as an ALMO. Report P10
Past 18 months: Council intervention in SCH has moved beyond traditional client oversight to active delivery support. Report P20
2023: Joint Council and SCH desktop review considered three broad delivery models but did not constitute a full options appraisal. Report 3.16
April 2024: Social Housing (Regulation) Act 2023 came fully into force, alongside earlier Fire Safety Act 2021 and Building Safety Act 2022. Report P15
By the end of this calendar year (2026): Commissioned independent appraisal is expected to conclude, subject to Cabinet approval. Report 3.19
Plain English for the jargon
ALMO: Arm's Length Management Organisation: a not for profit company set up by a council to manage its housing stock on its behalf, with the council remaining the landlord.
SCH: Solihull Community Housing, the Council's ALMO since 2004.
HRA: Housing Revenue Account: a ring fenced account councils must keep for income and spending on council housing.
RSH: Regulator of Social Housing, which carries out programmed inspections and issues graded judgements C1 to C4.
BSR: Building Safety Regulator, which receives Building Safety Case Reports for higher risk buildings.
MTFS: Medium Term Financial Strategy, the Council's multi year financial planning framework.
What was decided, why, and what happens next
Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.
Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
Item8
Resolved
RESOLVED that: 1. the substantial changes to the social housing regulatory regime and the Council’s continuing accountability as landlord and Registered Provider be noted; 2. the increased level of Council intervention required over the past 18 months to support housing delivery, assurance and risk management, beyond traditional client oversight be noted; 3. the commissioning of an independent external consultant to undertake a comprehensive appraisal of the Council’s housing delivery arrangements, including the current ALMO model be approved; 4. it be agreed that a further report be presented to Cabinet setting out the findings of the appraisal and recommendations on next steps, including any requirements for tenant consultation.
Word for word from the decision Solihull published for this meeting.Source: democracy.solihull.gov.uk
This report seeks Cabinet approval to commission an independent external consultancy to undertake a comprehensive appraisal of the Council’s housing delivery arrangements, including the current Arm’s Length Management Organisation (ALMO) arrangement with Solihull Community Housing (SCH) and the wider configuration of housing services across the Council.
The proposed appraisal is being undertaken in response to:
a) significant changes to the social housing regulatory framework b) the increased level of Council intervention required over the past 18 months moving beyond traditional client oversight arrangements to support delivery confidence and regulatory assurance c) the Council’s statutory responsibilities as landlord, which remain with the Council regardless of who delivers services and the need to ensure tenants continue to receive safe, effective and accountable services d) the dispersed delivery of housing and housing related services across SCH and several Council function e) growing financial pressures on the Housing Revenue Account (HRA) and the Council’s wider Medium Term Financial Strategy (MTFS)
1.3This report does not seek a decision on any change to delivery arrangements at this stage. It seeks approval to undertake an independent, evidence based appraisal to inform a future Cabinet decision.
2. Decision(s) Recommended
Cabinet is recommended to:
a) Note the substantial changes to the social housing regulatory regime and the Council’s continuing accountability as landlord and Registered Provider b) Note the increased level of Council intervention required over the past 18 months to support housing delivery, assurance and risk management, beyond traditional client oversight c) Approve the commissioning of an independent external consultant to undertake a comprehensive appraisal of the Council’s housing delivery arrangements, including the current ALMO model d) Agree that a further report be presented to Cabinet setting out the findings of the appraisal and recommendations on next steps, including any requirements for tenant consultation
3. Matters for Consideration
Background and current arrangements
Since 2004, the management of the Council’s housing stock of approximately 10,000 homes has been delivered through Solihull Community Housing as an ALMO. Throughout this period, the Council has remained the landlord, retained ownership of the housing stock and held full responsibility for the HRA.
The ALMO model has delivered significant benefits over many years, including successful delivery of the Decent Homes programme and a period of operational stability within a comparatively less prescriptive regulatory environment. However, the external context in which the model operates has changed fundamentally.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
Exclusion of the Public and PressRESOLVED : That, pursuant to Section 100A (4) of the Local Government Act 1972, the press and public be now excluded ...
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.