CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Southend-on-Sea Borough Council
Development Control Committee, Wednesday 6 June 2018 at 2.00pm

18/00382/FUL - 117 -119 Hamstel Road, Southend on Sea (Southchurch Ward)

Refused Planning 7 papers

Development Control Committee refused this item on Wednesday 6 June 2018. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item29

Resolved

That planning permission be REFUSED for the following reasons: 01 The proposed development by reason of its design, scale and the proposed intensity of the use with 10 bedrooms, 5 car parking spaces and up to 18 residents living in the building, would result in material harm to the residential amenity of the adjoining residents in terms of noise and disturbance. The development is therefore unacceptable and contrary to National Planning Policy Framework, Policies KP2 and CP4 of the Core Strategy (2007), Policies DM1 and DM3 of the Development Management Document (2015) and the advice contained within the Design and Townscape Guide (2009). 02 The proposed development by reason of the extremely limited internal communal living accommodation being provided, the limited size and poor quality of the external amenity space provided, the inconveniently located refuse facilities and as a result of the ground floor rooms being materially overlooked and providing lack of privacy, would provide substandard living conditions for the future occupiers of the site and a poor quality residential environment. The proposal is therefore unacceptable and contrary to the National Planning Policy Framework, Policies KP2 and CP4 of the Core Strategy (2007), Policies DM1, DM3 and DM8 of the Development Management Document (2015) and the advice contained within the Design and Townscape Guide (2009). 03 The proposal would provide insufficient parking facilities to meet the needs of the development, resulting in an increase in on-street parking to the material detriment of highway safety and the free flow of traffic. The development is therefore unacceptable and contrary to the National Planning Policy Framework, Policy CP3 of the Core Strategy (2007) and Policy DM15 of the Development Management Document (2015). The Local Planning Authority has acted positively and proactively in determining this application by identifying matters of concern with the proposal and determining the application within a timely manner, clearly setting out the reason(s) for refusal, allowing the Applicant the opportunity to consider the harm caused and whether or not it can be remedied by a revision to the proposal. The detailed analysis is set out in a report prepared by officers. In the circumstances the proposal is not considered to be sustainable development. The Local Planning Authority is willing to discuss the best course of action Informatives 01 A large HMO falls outside of Use Classes C3 and C4 and constitutes a sui generis use. However, the use is residential in character and therefore the change of use from a dwellinghouse to a large HMO would not represent a CIL liable change of use.
Word for word from the decision Southend-on-Sea published for this meeting. Source: democracy.southend.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Southend-on-Sea's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Development Control Committee

Reference: 18/00382/FUL

Ward: Southchurch

Convert ground floor shop (Class A1) and vacant first floor accommodation into a 10 bedroom HMO (Sui Generis), erect Proposal: two storey rear extension, alter front and side elevations and layout parking to rear (amended proposal)

Address: 117-119 Hamstel Road, Southend-on-Sea, Essex

Applicant: Higgins Property Investments Limited

Agent: BGA Architects

Consultation Expiry: 11.04.2018

Expiry Date: 06.06.2018

Case Officer: Charlotte White

17-047A 0-300, 17-047A 0-001, 17-047A 0-002, 17-047A 2- Plan No’s: 001, 17-047A 1-001, 17-047A 1-300 Rev. A

Recommendation: REFUSE PLANNING PERMISSION

Development Control Report Page 1 of 12 1 The Proposal

1.1Planning permission is sought to change the use of the building from a ground floor retail shop with first floor residential accommodation into a house of multiple occupation (HMO). Operational development proposed includes alterations to the fenestration with the shop front and part of the ground floor front projection removed, a ground floor bay window installed and ground floor windows inserted that align vertically with the existing first floor front windows. The existing single storey, rear extension will be removed and a two storey, hipped roof rear extension will be constructed. Two additional northern side windows will also be installed.

1.2To the rear of the site 5 parking spaces and a turning area will be provided accessed from South Avenue along with cycle parking and refuse stores. An amenity space measuring some 29sqm will be provided between the rear extension and the parking spaces (some 3.2m deep), although there is no direct access from the rear of the building to this amenity space.

1.3Internally the development comprises:

1.4Ground floor: 5x bedrooms, each with a kitchenette (the plans indicate that these bedrooms constitute 4x double bedrooms and 1x single bedroom), 2x shower rooms and 1x W.C

1.5First floor: 5x bedrooms, each with a kitchenette (the plans indicate that these bedrooms constitute 4x double bedrooms and 1x single bedroom), 2x shower rooms and 1x W.C

1.6The application has not been submitted with a planning statement or any other supporting documents.

1.7The application was referred to Committee by Cllr VanLooy.

1.8A similar application was withdrawn (reference 17/01659/FUL). The main changes between the previous withdrawn application and this proposal include alterations to the front elevation, removal of the fascia and inclusion of fenestration changes and a ground floor bay window. The two storey extension was previously flat roofed and now includes a hipped roof. Internally there are some slight alterations, although, like the previous proposal, this HMO proposed constitutes 10 bedrooms (8 double bedrooms and 2 single bedrooms). Externally the refuse and cycle parking facilities have been relocated, and an additional fifth parking space is now proposed.

2 Site and Surroundings

2.1The application site is located on a corner plot, to the west of Hamstel Road and to the south of South Avenue. The site is currently occupied by a vacant retail premises at ground floor level with residential accommodation above. There is an existing, large single storey rear extension at the site and an existing crossover providing vehicular access to the rear of the site from South Avenue.

Development Control Report Page 2 of 12 2.2 The surrounding area is mainly residential in nature, with some commercial units and a school in close proximity of the site.

2.3The site has no specific allocation on the Development Management Document Proposals Map.

3 Planning Considerations

3.1The main planning considerations in this case are: the principle of development, living conditions for future occupiers, car parking arrangements, highway and transport considerations, design quality and impact on surrounding area, amenities of neighbouring occupiers and CIL (Community Infrastructure Levy).

4 Appraisal

Principle of Development

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
18/00382/FUL: 117 -119 Hamstel Road, Southend on Sea (Southchurch Ward)Report 204 KB DownloadRead as text
PDF
Existing elevationsReport 257 KB Download
PDF
Existing floor plansPlan 115 KB Download
PDF
Existing site planPlan 173 KB Download
PDF
Proposed Site PlanPlan 211 KB Download
PDF
Proposed floor plans and elevationsPlan 300 KB Download
PDF
Site location planPlan 155 KB Download

At this meeting

Whole meeting
19Minutes of the Meeting held on Wednesday 7th March 2018Decided 20Minutes of the Meeting held on Wednesday 4th April 2018Decided 21Supplementary ReportOn the agenda 2218/00634/BC3M - Land at Former Esplanade House (Kursaal Ward)Approved 2317/02196/FULM - Tylers Avenue, Southend on Sea (Milton Ward)On the agenda 2417/01319/FULM - Empire Theatre, Alexandra Street, Southend on Sea (Milton Ward)Agreed 2518/00669/FULM - St Bernards High School, Milton Road, Westcliff on Sea (Milton Ward)Approved 2618/00480/FUL - 241 Carlton Avenue, Westcliff on Sea (Prittlewell Ward)On the agenda 2717/02074/FUL - Havens, 138 - 140 Hamlet Court Road, Westcliff on Sea (Milton Ward)Approved 2817/02075/LBC - Havens, 138 - 140 Hamlet Court Road, Westlciff on Sea (Milton Ward)Approved
2918/00382/FUL - 117 -119 Hamstel Road, Southend on Sea (Southchurch Ward)This decision
3018/00341/OUTM - 9 Elmer Approach, Southend on Sea (Milton Ward)Approved 3118/00579/FULH - 27 Glenbervie Drive, Leigh on Sea (Blenheim Park Ward)Approved 3217/00009/UNAC_B - 74 Undercliff Gardens, Leigh on Sea (Leigh Ward)Approved 3318/00484/FULM - Riley's, 258 Leigh Road, Leigh on Sea (Leigh Ward)Agreed 3417/02183/RESM - 939 London Road, Leigh on Sea (Blenheim Park Ward)Approved 3516/01723/DOV5 - Marine Plaza, Land between Southchurch Avenue and Pleasant Road fronting Marine Parade, Southend on Sea (Kursaal Ward)Refused 3618/00254/FUL - W5, The Shore, 22 - 23 The Leas, Westcliff on Sea (Chalkwell Ward)Approved 3717/01574/FUL - The Shore, 22 - 23 The Leas, Westcliff on Sea (Chalkwell Ward)Approved 3817/01716/FUL - The Shore, 22 - 23 The Leas, Westcliff on Sea (Chalkwell Ward)Approved 3918/00329/ADV - Street Record, London Road, Southend on Sea (Victoria Ward)Approved

Who was there

18 of 27 attended
DG
Councillor David GarstonChair, present
BA
Councillor Bernard ArscottVice-Chair, present
BA
Councillor Brian AylingCommittee Member, present as substitute
MB
Councillor Margaret BortonCommittee Member, present
SB
Councillor Steve BuckleyCommittee Member, present
AC
Councillor Anne ChalkCommittee Member, present
AD
Councillor Alan DearCommittee Member, present
FE
Councillor Fay EvansCommittee Member, apologies
DG
Councillor Denis GarneCommittee Member, present
JG
Councillor Jonathan GarstonCommittee Member, present
SH
Councillor Stephen HabermelCommittee Member, present
RH
Councillor Roger HadleyCommittee Member, present

All 27 on the meeting page

More from Southend-on-Sea Development Control Committee

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
30 Apr 2025 Minutes of the Meeting held on Wednesday, 2nd April, 2025- That the Minutes of the Meeting held on Wednesday 2 nd April 2025 be confirmed as a correct record and signed. Decided Open
30 Apr 2025 25/00280/AMDT - Garages at Eagle Way, Shoeburyness (Shoeburyness Ward)That PLANNING PERMISSION be GRANTED subject to the following conditions: 01 The development hereby being amended shal... Approved Open
30 Apr 2025 25/00167/FUL - 18 Brightwell Avenue, Westcliff-on-Sea (Westborough Ward)- That PLANNNG PERMISSION be REFUSED for the following reason: 01 The proposed development would result in room 3 bei... Refused Open
30 Apr 2025 25/00358/FUL - 19 Blatches Chase, Eastwood (Blenheim Park Ward)- That PLANNING PERMISSION be REFUSED for the following reasons: 01 The development introduces types and levels of no... Refused Open
30 Apr 2025 TPO 5/2024 - Land Between 89 - 91 Alexandra Road, Southend-on-Sea (Milton Ward)- That Tree Preservation Order 05/2024 be confirmed. Decided Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies